The Best Conversations Happen At Happy Hour, Welcome to Ours!
July 9, 2026

Why Patients Quit PT After Visit 3

Why Patients Quit PT After Visit 3
Why Patients Quit PT After Visit 3
PT Pintcast
Why Patients Quit PT After Visit 3

This week on PT Breakfast Club, Jimmy McKay and Dave Kittle start with a simple patient text exchange and end up inside one of the biggest problems in physical therapy:

Expectation rarely matches reality.

Dave shares how he responds when a prospective patient asks whether his clinic is in-network or out-of-network. Instead of dodging the question or pushing the sale, he explains the difference between choosing the lowest-cost option and choosing a higher-touch model.

That opens the door to a larger conversation about why patients often disappear after visit three.

Is it really because patients do not care?

Is it because they will not do their home exercises?

Or is the experience inconsistent enough that leaving is actually a rational consumer response?

Jimmy and Dave talk about the in-network volume model, cash-pay customer acquisition costs, personal training, patient switching, the third-place concept, Equinox, Planet Fitness, Starbucks, Ironman, APTA, payment advocacy, and whether physical therapy can ever become more than a series of appointments.

The episode closes with a practical reminder: the easiest growth lever is not always finding new patients. Sometimes it is serving the people who already trust you at a much higher level.

In this episode
  • How to respond when patients ask about in-network vs out-of-network care
  • Why cash practices need to explain the tradeoff, not just the price
  • Why visit 3 drop-off may be an experience design problem
  • How inconsistent therapist switching damages trust
  • What PT can learn from personal training
  • Why volume-based models create predictable consequences
  • The role of customer acquisition cost in patient retention
  • What physical therapy can learn from Equinox and Planet Fitness
  • Why community-first businesses win
  • Why a package is not the same thing as a membership
  • What APTA can and cannot realistically solve
  • Why retention and relationship may be the most underused growth strategy
Best quote

“If you launched a video game where 70% of the people played it three times and never played again, would you blame the player? No. You’d blame the game.”

<p>This episode is part of the <a href="/physical-therapy-business-podcast">Physical Therapy Business Podcast</a>, where physical therapists and clinic owners learn how to get more patients, improve operations, and grow their clinic without relying only on referrals.</p>

<p>Looking for more episodes? Explore the full <a href="/physical-therapy-business-podcast">Physical Therapy Business Podcast</a> for real-world strategies on physical therapy marketing, patient acquisition, and clinic growth.</p>

Transcript

0:02 Broadcasting way too early from three separate Wi-Fi connections. It's PT Breakfast Club with Tony Meritato, Dave Kittle, and Jimmy McKay. All right. Happy Thursday, July ninth for PT Breakfast Club. I'm Jimmy McKay. That's Dave Kittle. Tony Meritato is holding down the fort. Didn't he have some people out on vacation? He's holding down the fort. Um, today I want to talk about a text exchange that you shared in the group chat. And I don't think there's anything special about it. And I think that's why I want to share it is there's nothing special about it, except I think sometimes people over complicate this exchange where I think your exchange was just simple and basic and nothing flashy about it.

0:52 So like set the stage, who was this? And like, just like, you know, paint the picture. Yeah, prospective client that was reaching out. And if someone is not always, but it doesn't matter the age always, but someone who reached out that's like twenty or thirty, like they're typically they're like a little bit more in tune. So they're usually saying things like, do you take my insurance? But then they'll double down. They'll say, like, are you guys in network? Because they probably got burned or they got surprised elsewhere recently or before with like. and we never want that we never want someone to like come to our office and then find out that we're out of network right so we are like over we want to over communicate up front it reduces conversion rates but it also results in like no poor online reviews about billing or you know nefarious activity or secret you know like um bait and switch whatever type of stuff so it was a prospective client that had reached out um obviously in this example like the diagnosis is irrelevant so they were in a text exchange.

1:56 We were in a text exchange and they said, hey, would this be in-network or out-of-network? And then we said, we're out-of-network, are you only looking for the lowest cost slash in-network, question mark, or fastest results, question mark. Now, the in-network practice owners out there will not like that because I'm kind of framing us as faster results, but arguably, if you had more one-on-one time with more patients, I believe you can get results faster. Now, of course, in-network practice owners that have twenty, thirty years of experience, they can probably get faster results than I can, even if they're treating, you know, three patients or four patients at the same time.

2:37 Right. Because they're just so experienced and they're way more efficient and all that. But I'm talking about like staff P.T. compared to staff P.T. across the country. anyway so that's how i wrote it then this person wrote back in network so i i asked hey are you only looking for the lowest cost slash in network question mark or fastest results question mark they replied in network my out of network deductible is super high so that's this is totally fine but we want to like flush this out like we want to make sure um we want to communicate and get clarity on like the person and there's nothing wrong with this like they're just a little more cost conscious like if i was i think this i think this person reaching out was like in their twenties right so if you don't have your parents paying for everything and you live in new york city and you're and you're in your twenties i totally get it if you have out of network uh and not a network deductible that was like i forget what it was for him but it was um It was probably I think it was closer to ten grand.

3:35 Right. So it's like you got to pay ten grand out of pocket before you're out of network will cover at eighty or seventy or one hundred percent or whatever. Right. So when I moved to New York City in twenty twenty in twenty fourteen, I I could put myself in these shoes. I totally get it. Right. So. this this individual had you know said that they're specifically looking for in network now at that point um we're not going to book them or anything like that because we know that we are not in network and we want to be completely clear so then i wrote totally understand within network the therapist is usually treating two or three or four plus patients at the same time if you ever get frustrated with that model and want more time and attention feel free to reach back out to Concierge Pain Relief.

4:27 And I was actually, one of the reasons why I shared this with you and Tony in the chat privately is because they replied thank you with an exclamation point. I mean, that's great. I feel like, hey, we've established some communication where this person is budget constrained and that's totally fine. We don't want to make people feel bad if they can't afford us or they don't want to pay out of pocket more to work with us. That's totally fine. Even the in-network places, we've talked about this before, even the in-network places are now stopping to take, they're not taking some insurances, right? So they're not taking GHIs and they're not taking some of the lower paying.

5:07 a lot of them are dropping UnitedHealthcare. So the beneficiaries of those plans across the country, even in New York and New York State, New York City, but also across the country, all those practices can't serve everyone either. They are choosing not to serve everyone because the plans are just lower. They're just so low that it doesn't even cover their costs to deliver a visit. So I liked that this person wrote back, texted back, thank you, excellent point. And now... i've also foreshadowed by the way like they could they could go somewhere and have an amazing experience at some of the other network practices in the in the city where they go for they have thirty minutes one-on-one with the pt then the next thirty minutes is like some of the therapeutic exercise with like a tech or an aid which obviously is not not really legal but like and they still bill they still bill for that's another conversation but i planted a seed in this person's head this is this is obviously on purpose i planted the seed and i said hey you know when that's totally cool and i don't want to make someone feel bad but if you're going to go in network that's totally fine get it but But that model is going to be typically the therapist treating two, three, four patients at the same time.

6:19 And what I oftentimes hear now recently is, patient will go and have an amazing first visit. And they'll be like, oh, the first visit was like one on one for like a whole hour with the therapist. And then I went back and then it was twenty seven minutes with the first therapist. Then I went back for visit number three and it was a different therapist. And that was also thirty minutes only total or whatever. Or or or they say I went back for visit number three and my therapist was treating for four people at the same time. So that, unfortunately, because of the crunch in payment reimbursement, a lot of these practices have to make it up on volume. You know that. Everyone that's watching or listening knows that.

7:01 And therefore, they're delivering sometimes, oftentimes, not always, but oftentimes, the network practices have to deliver more on volume. And when it's more about volume, then you can't deliver a consistent product or service. meaning the services, the product. You can't deliver something that's consistent. And when it's not consistent, you get people that say, the first visit was amazing. It was one hour with Dr. Tom. Whole hour, one-on-one. I couldn't believe it. It was amazing. I'm going to stay forever. Visit number two. Oh, now it's like, thirty minutes and it was like a little rushed or a little busy, but like, it was good.

7:42 It was good enough. It was good enough. It was decent or whatever. It was cool. It was good. It's fine. And then visit number three, it's a different person. Now the second therapist, Dr. Mary, is asking me all these questions that I already told Tom twice, and they're in the medical record, in the EMR. Dr. Mary is asking me all these questions as if they didn't talk and didn't communicate, or it's like new exercises, or it's redundant stuff. And so now it's like, oh, that's like... So now the person that's going to book, the patient that's going to book visit number four and five and six or seven, or if they're making them book all the visits up front or multiple weeks up front before they leave, now there's doubt in their head.

8:25 And they're like, I mean, is this going to be like a wild card every time I come in? I want it to be consistent. And that, unfortunately, is in a nutshell why... What's the stat like? Ninety one percent of people don't finish their plan of care. I mean, that's part of it. There's a lot of other things. But let's let's let's banter. Let's go back and forth on this text and this whole kind of like scenario. Well, I mean, Larry, I just had a conversation with Larry Benz not long ago, and he talked about that that. Visit three drop off, which you just sort of what everybody says, oh, it's visit three. Why is it visit three? Walk me through that. And that's one example. And but that is the prevailing example.

9:06 I, of course, like to break everything down or boil everything down. Let's go back to what you did. You didn't frame in or out of network. You framed quality versus question mark. That's even better. Or I just... Because I want to be nice to the in-network practice owners out there. I respect them. So I'm framing it as... different experiences so i don't i don't want to i don't want to i don't want to i don't want to say that we're elevated and i don't want to prove that so like what you did was you're like hey that's great totally understand that in your brain you're like i was twenty as well if that was the choice i'd probably be making that one just so you know and so you're foreshadowing which is a great line too which is like if you haven't done this it's also great too because they might be like yeah i don't think so and then when they get there they're like oh this is exactly what he said.

9:59 And that's like exception-y. And some patients reach back out in two weeks, two months, whatever. And they're like, oh, like I... it started off good or, and obviously I'm not going to mention any names or practices, but like they'll, they'll reach back out and be like, Oh my gosh, like you, like it was, it was, it was better than I thought it was going to be then. And then it turned into exactly what you said. And it's not even always practices. Sometimes it's like you have great therapists working in a model that there's no possible way that they could do that because their hands are tied. so what you what we're really doing or what we're really talking about is expectations versus reality if you've never been to pt and you've only seen it on tv or heard it from a friend you're sort of expecting something like that you've heard and then when you get there if it isn't like that you might give it another chance or two but then we're humans and then we're gonna go i'm not feeling better and i've already invested time and effort and money And my expectation does not match my reality.

10:58 Therefore, I leave. And that is such a human response. I was reading something yesterday where they said, if you launched a video game where seventy percent of the people played the game three times and then never played it again, would you blame the player? No, you blame the game. You'd say the game shocks have redesigned the game. But we love to go, no one does their home exercise plan. And I'm like, okay, same thing. If you developed a service, you sell pizzas and people try you three times and then they ghost you. I would start changing up who's cooking the pizzas or something or start looking at yourself a lot. And we in healthcare don't do that for some reason.

11:41 I don't know why. obviously like it this is so we've talked about this a million times and it's like so challenging because a lot of this in my opinion goes back to payment reimbursement but it's also like let's do a quick exercise right so if you're in that busy type of a clinic and the patient you know jimmy's the patient and we're at upstate physical therapy just a fake you know acme physical therapy place up there and it's a network and jimmy has that experience like good like great first visit Second visit, good. Third visit, like below expectations. And now questioning, like, does this even make sense to continue to pay? And why would I drive here and park and pay a twenty to fifty dollar copay when I don't know what to expect?

12:26 Take time out of work, get babysitting for the kids, whatever it is. Right now. Now, Jimmy, the patient is questioning, like, does this even make sense? And. yeah so it's it's a little bit on the therapist but they were hired and coached and trained or should have been on how to navigate whatever model they might be in So it's like part of the health insurance, you know, third party payers. But again, we know that's not changing. But right. Maybe it's also it's. Yeah. Well, no. Right. But then then you can say, OK, well, part of it is the payment reimbursement, which is like kind of one of like one or the main root causes of all this, this whole situation.

13:12 But in like the day to day reality, it's like, OK, some blame maybe goes towards the a staff physical therapist or the front desk that's now on Jimmy's visit number three, it's a different therapist. And now Jimmy's got to explain everything all over again to a new therapist because they don't communicate because they're so busy, because there's so many patients per day and so many notes. So then you just like, OK, so there's a little maybe there's a little blame for the therapist. Maybe there's a little blame for the admin, the front desk or the clinic director, which is typically a physical therapist. But then for us, so I'm a practice owner, obviously. And like the buck stops with me. Like ultimately it's, if I own that upstate physical therapy practice that Jimmy's coming to, it's my fault.

13:58 It's my fault because I am like, participating in that model I didn't uh coach or train my therapist well enough to navigate like the switching or the front desk and they didn't communicate it I mean where my first job dude in New Jersey sometimes like patients would be switched patients would get a confirmation over text or email about hey you're going to be seeing Dr Dave tomorrow and then they come and uh I was never sick, but like if I, if I got too busy or whatever, like sometimes it would be like moving patients off my schedule to like Nick, the PTA. And it's like, of course people don't like that.

14:38 Like they got a notification that says it was going to be with Dave. Now the show of, and now it's with Nick that they don't know as much or don't know as well. Sure. I mean, no wonder that we have this chronic issue in like crappy, uh, delivery of the service like the product of physical therapy this is where and there's multiple arguments that happen we've seen them a hundred times they happen they go round and round in circles they go nowhere this is where people comparing pt to personal training it's where personal training like kind of gets it right a lot that's your trainer forever like how often does a personal trainer switch a client maybe in extreme circumstances i don't know i've never used a trainer i've used a coach before And I'm not re-explaining the last six months of what we've been doing or my weird isms that maybe my coach has never even explained to me before.

15:27 Maybe he's just like, oh, I get Jimmy. I understand how he works. I pay the coach. I get the coach. But in healthcare, in PT specifically, that's not the case. I don't know the percentages of how often you see a different... That'd be a good stat to have if you had a large enough data set. How can, what's your, what's your, what's your clinician patient batting average? Like how often is it bang? You know, in baseball pitchers have a catcher. That catcher might not be a great hitter. Pitcher's like, I don't care. I like how he catches the game. So I'm out there for seven innings, maybe more, hopefully that's who's catching. And that's why, because we know each other.

16:09 We understand. I don't have to say anything. I give him a look and he's like, don't wave me off. Why do you think in the in-network PT world, there's that switching? Oh, it's just, like you said, you have to pull the volume lever, or you've got three clinicians, thirty-three clinicians. Yes, and? Oh, am I missing something? I don't know. So, also, like, okay, Jimmy, if you're paying a twenty dollar copay, Like, I feel like there's some what's the word? I feel like there's some I don't want to say disrespect, but I feel like there's like we know, like if you're paying a twenty dollar copay and we're going to move you around to a different clinician on your way into the clinic, like you don't even know what's happening.

16:52 All right. or that morning or whatever and you're busy so like you don't see the update or whatever and you're so you're still going to come and then you're like oh i thought i was with dave and now i'm with nick or mary or whatever i haven't met them before so now and now i got to explain everything again because you guys don't communicate because you're so busy um it happens way more in in network and it's like okay would you be just paying like a twenty dollar copay now can you imagine if we did that where someone's paying three fifty a visit right what's the difference expectation I paid for this and got that, and I don't like that. I feel flim-flammed. But it's like in these in network world, these front desks or this therapist or whoever are like, ah, we're just like moving around or whatever.

17:34 Cause it's almost like, well, it's so you're paying so low out of pocket. You have minimal skin in the game. So it's kind of like, I'll just move them around wherever. And it's kind of, it's kind of disrespectful. Yeah. I have to solve a problem, which is like slots and providers, right? Like I, you know, this person's out. So I've got to do this today. It's not an easy problem. It's a volume problem because you've chosen volume. You've chosen volume as the thing that you have to do. Based on this thing, and again, I'm not trying to pimp it too hard, but Larry Benz is writing about this stuff. This invisible... The article he had this week was about this. Who's in the room with you when it's like clinician, patient, payer.

18:16 They're in the room. They're in your brain. They're on your shoulder going, we're not going to reimburse for that. And then you change your... I want Larry to do a video set where there's a devil and an angel. The devil's like, we're not going to reimburse for that. So do you think it is some disrespect of or like the because the because the person is indirectly they're paying for it through their insurance premium. But in terms of that thing, I think it's I have if I'm a clinic director and I've got ten clinicians, why do I juggle people? Because I'm when I'm given a hammer, the world is full of nails. I have to move people around.

18:57 What would the other option be? Cause my goal is I need to stay above water. So that person's got a slot for an eval or to see Jimmy again. Yeah. Yes. It's about volume. My point is, okay. So, so, um, Ben Boggy has a practice, a big location in San Diego. I think they have like eight or something therapists there. So probably, I mean, it's bigger and any, and they're doing really well. He's got multiple locations and it's all cash. It's like, I think they're charging around two fifty, three fifty per visit. They sell packages, whatever. If you were in San Diego, if you were a client, Jimmy, of this practice, they're not going to just switch providers on you in the five hours leading up to your visit and not tell you.

19:38 And you come into the office and you're like surprised. And because part of it is you... Are more, I think part of it is you're more valuable because you ponied up a lot of this money out of pocket directly and they want to over, they want to over communicate like, Hey, listen, so-and-so is not available today. Do you want to just reschedule this for a different day? Or do you want to try a coverage visit with one of our other therapists? And here's their name, here's, here's their bio, all that. Because they make more per person so they can be... Right. So Ben's place, if you can use that example, is like I'm seeing eight a day versus another place I'm seeing sixteen. I'm just making those numbers up, right?

20:20 It's not as easy to find a new slot when you're seeing sixteen, especially if that person's like, I need to be seen today. So there it is. It's you've chosen time or volume. And when you choose volume, there's less room because you've sold more of your time in smaller increments. So the volume part and then through in-network insurance, the practice is going to make less per visit and less per plan of care. So they're just forced. Their hands are tied. Right. Right. And they... Also know that there's it's just easier to fill that.

21:00 Like, let's say Jimmy gets pissed off on that third visit and he's like, you know, I can't. And then he drops off, which happens all the time. I mean, it happens. We get some drop offs and we're not the right fit for everyone. But obviously it's way more in the network world. So then now Jimmy, the patient drops off visit number three in the network world. They don't care as much. Why do they not care as much? Thirty eight people behind me. Exactly. Because it's a low barrier to entry. It's in network. They accept a ton of insurances. There's always going to be the next person. All right, next person, step right up. You know, like McDonald's. Whereas a cash practice, it's like for us to convert somebody to then pay two fifty, three fifty per visit out of pocket or for the eval and then sell a package, whatever.

21:41 Like the stakes are a little bit higher. I don't know how much higher, but they're higher. Do you estimate your customer acquisition costs? Yeah, I haven't updated it in a while. I would love to see yours. We can use AI. What would be average cash pay clinics customer acquisition cost versus an in-network customer acquisition cost? I would love to see the difference in that. I mean, my expectation is yours is way higher. Yeah, of course. So round figures, it used to be like a hundred dollars and sometimes it goes to above a hundred dollars and sometimes it goes down to like twenty six dollars. But in general, it's like it's like a hundred dollars cost per lead for someone to like either call in or write into our Web site.

22:28 which is the lead just to get their contact information, not then the time and effort to call them and then convert them and then book them and then make sure that they show up or home visit or office visit or whatever. So acquisition cost is probably closer to like two hundred bucks. So you're breaking even, you're at least in the black on the first visit because you're like, I know what I charge, I know what it costs to get a patient Well, still a loss because of labor, right? So if you take away the acquisition costs and labor, then, but yeah, by visit two or three, there's profit, right? But the point is to be like over-delivering. That's why it's not falling off.

23:08 Exactly. You just lost money on this experience. Yeah. That would be a great start to see. um okay so that was good that we talked about that i thought that one little screenshot says a lot and i think there's a lesson in there for people whether they want to learn it or not and i don't remember hearing that at all i'm not saying it doesn't happen but in pt school i don't it's not really the place for it but uh yeah now just just to close the loop on this if you're a cash practice owner out of network owner and you have people that balk at your pricing and they want to go in network or they want to go somewhere cheaper or whatever, feel free to take that text. You need to be texting or emailing that or saying it to them over the phone and then putting it in text or email so they have it digitally so that they can refer back to it later.

23:56 Yeah. you absolutely need to be saying something like that because why are you different, right? You're going to say, oh, well, priority scheduling and all you have to do is text me to schedule. And if you want to go to upstate New York PT that takes your network insurance, that's fine. But then you got to like call in, you know, press one, press two, get the person on the phone. They're going to put you on hold, right? So it's just, there's just more resistance to the volume game and that's fine. But so you got to call out the things that you personally We talked about it before, like features and benefits. You got to call out the things of like what they get with you or the challenging potentially issue type things that they might experience if they go to one of your competitors.

24:39 So you could say it in like a nice playing field kind of way, but call it out. I'm in upstate New York. I got one nice restaurant in my town. One. If I call and I go, hey, man, you got a reservation? And they're like, yeah. And I'm like, what's average cost of dinner? And they're like, eighty three dollars a person. I'm like, my man, I got McDonald's down the road. Why wouldn't I go there? They're going to go have at it and hang up because they understand what they provide. I need you to start thinking about that. It's McDonald's isn't bad. It's just different. Because after I play a beer league hockey game and we get out at midnight or one in the morning, that nice restaurant ain't open. And what am I doing? But I know what I'm getting. So understand that you know what you're getting.

25:21 I want to change topics, but not really. This is another screenshot that you shared. So I'll put the stat on there. Gyms have a new third place. And I brought this up a couple weeks ago where I said, if I were opening a gym now and I gave the things that I would do outside of squat racks, dumbbells, treadmills, I would also have some things to make it a third place. And just for context, again, the third place is... The first place is home. Second place is work. And this is where you spend time or where you seek out. Bars used to be the third place. Still are, probably, right? And then which big company was trying to be the third place, let's say, in the last twenty years?

26:05 Like a brick-and-mortar place? Which company was trying to be... No, that's digital. Which company was trying to be the third place? Do I know it? Is it a bar? No, it can't be a bar. Oh, Starbucks. Coffee shops. And that's the non-alcoholic open your laptop i remember in the beginning of like wi-fi in like businesses they'd never tell you the password or you have to buy something and now they're like it's like the bathroom code you gotta buy something for the bathroom the large cities don't understand the stress of the bathroom code you do you know that there's a secret you can go to like yelp if you ever want to get a bathroom code there will be heroes that will do yelp reviews and they'll put it in the in the album that's that's an aside so anyway this is the this is a graph showing and i gotta zoom in here number of us locations indexed from i'm trying to figure this graph out anyway it's showing gyms and studios fitness studios outpacing bars and nightclubs uh social clubs bowling alleys and movie theaters Bowling Alley says come hang out, but every minute you're there, you're paying.

27:26 Like every game, you know what I mean? The meter is running, right? There's no one purchase. Unless you're the weird person who's hanging out at the Bowling Alley bar, but that's on you. Unless Bowling Alleys have a monthly membership. If they do, kudos to you guys. Which would be a killer idea, right? Movie, it's a transaction, and then get the hell out. Although when I was in high school or middle school, we'd pay for a movie. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

28:10 It's not a small difference in terms of how many gyms and studios. So I wanted to talk about this because we also just announced that Orange Theory was closing locations. Nike tried to jump into the space and open their own gyms. And that was all pomp and no circumstance in less than a year. I think they're closing all of them. Essentially, it was a franchise model. Take our logo, build our own Nike version of Orange Theory or whatever. And it didn't work out. Why? Why? We can get into that. I've got a friend who... Did you ever meet Megan Brown? I can introduce you to her. You guys would get along famously. Megan Brown is a PT. She owns a fitness studio. She owns a Pilates and yoga business in Alexandria.

28:53 So expensive zip code. Shadow of Washington, D.C. Three locations. She does four... I asked her three times if I had this number right. Four hundred classes a week across three locations. That's wild. Are you doing math? Because the math is wild. She's got multiple rooms at each location. Let's go. Four hundred divided by three locations would be one hundred and thirty three on average per week. She's open seven days or what? Seven days. Yeah, baby. How's that possible? Nineteen classes because she's got multiple she's got multiple rooms in each place. Well, and what's the class size?

29:34 Do you know three to five or what? No, very. I mean, her class is like twenty thirty. Like she's got a frickin beast of a student. And it's Pilates class yoga so that you figure they're an hour. three locations, but do you know what she charges for classes? I'd be curious, but it's a membership model. And then you vie for, you've got a, Oh, you want to get in on this? Got it. Or this, I mean, it's the model, the difference between Megan and it's called it's a mind, mind to the mat. The difference between Megan and Nike, you would have said if you pit Nike against Megan Brown, this woman you've never heard of, you're like, well, Nike is going to win.

30:16 Megan understands what business she's in, which is community. She walks in on a random Saturday dressed as Beyonce because it's Beyonce's birthday. And now you don't forget that for the rest of the week. She sells... community. So these two things sound like I'm just changing topics, but I'm really not because the question is, are you the third place and what are you offering? So Equinox isn't Nike, but they're kind of the Nike of gyms, or at least they're like the Goliath, right? They're trying to be the big highest end. If someone raised their prices, I bet you Equinox would raise their prices again just to be more expensive. But Equinox and the video that you shared as well that we found on Instagram was showing that people were spending...

31:00 Is this an additional four thousand dollars a year on top of dues? Or is this total? No, it says total here. So, four K. Seventy percent of the four thousand per year is the dues. And then the thirty percent, it says personal training, spa services, which I guess are upsells, smoothies, you know, protein smoothies, whatever, snacks, whatever, other purchases. So, whatever, like T-shirts, towels, bottles, whatever merch or like protein bars. So, this is a good breakdown. See, the funny thing is, if you asked me before we put this stat on the screen, how expensive equinox was i would have been like really expensive but if you pushed me for a number per month i don't know i would have said i don't know eight hundred dollars six hundred dollars but when you say four thousand dollars a year and that's only seventy percent that number feels more palatable if i know i'm going to go Do you know what I mean?

31:57 The X number of dollars a month feels like a poke in my ribs. But if you're like, four grand, you can come to Equinox, three hundred and sixty-five times, use everything you want, up to and including this, that number doesn't look ridiculous now to me. Especially if you live in New York or Chicago or LA. Yeah, it comes out to three hundred and thirty-three bucks a month. Seventy percent of four thousand? Obviously... No, no. I'm sorry. Four thousand total. So four thousand divided by twelve months. That's not even a lot. Three hundred and thirty three bucks a month. That's not a lot. It's less than a hundred bucks a week. Well, there's other people that are like, that's expensive, right? And it's like that's because there's different consumers out there. There's people that want to just spend like, you know, a hundred dollars a month or eighty dollars a month.

32:39 And by the way, let me just shout out Tony Maritato because he's not here right now. But this is something that he would say. And he has said this a lot about physical therapy pricing, that it makes... It only makes sense to go one way or the other, meaning you take all the insurances the way that he does. He takes Medicare. He takes a lot of the network insurances. So this bell curve, he's on one side of the bell curve. I'm on the other side of the bell curve. And if you're in the middle trying to charge, you know, one twenty five per visit out of pocket and not take any insurances, you don't have the extra money for marketing and hiring and all that. But you have the sales resistance and the hurdle of trying to get yourself or others busy so he takes all the insurances uh and he's a little bit more volume based and we don't and so we're more boutique but we have higher margin and this same example for gyms or any health and wellness service right it only makes sense to be the planet the planet fitness that it's so cheap that people don't come and if they do come it's pizza fridays or whatever you know eat a bagel while you're doing it like press like whatever, like they spit, you know, the lunk alarm.

33:43 They got rid of like the heavier weights. They don't want any bodybuilders there. Like it's a genius model of ninety two percent of people at Planet Fitness do not come. They pay ten, twenty whatever dollars a month. And they don't use it in general because they knew that the bodybuilders and the people that exercise a lot wear out the equipment faster and then they have to pay for more equipment. Take up room. And so they got rid of the people that they literally made a model to get rid of the people that actually use the gym, which is insane. So now Equinox is the opposite. So it's like they know their people are going to use the equipment. They got to keep the facility clean because it's premium. So they got to charge a premium rate. The floor is premium.

34:24 The The equipment is premium, the locker room, the amenities, all that type of stuff. And so you got to go one way or the other. So it makes no sense to have a gym that charges a hundred dollars a month or whatever, you know, it's like a one fifty or something like you got to be like low end or high end. Otherwise you're going to get squeezed. Yep. Tony, you brought up Tony. He then... So his brick and mortar business model is more probably aligned to Planet Fitness. But then while he's there, he's like, I'm going to be the high end of my clinical brain. And he goes, if you're an equipment company, I'll make a video for you.

35:04 Five hundred bucks. And he's like, I'm going to make five hundred bucks in twenty two minutes stitching together a video. And that transaction is done. he's on a different side of the bell curve for different audiences. Yep. And we in healthcare can't get away with that. We're like, I need to be cheap. So I'm available to everybody. Okay. But then you're cheap and you can't offer some of those things. You can be different things to different audiences. Look at car companies, right? Scion, Toyota, Lexus. I got a buddy who's a former Toyota mechanic. He's like, there are differences between the Scion and the Lexus. But he's like, a lot of the parts are interchangeable. You're buying... Yeah, the leather seats.

35:44 You don't have a... They don't even make Scion anymore. You don't even have... I don't know. You don't have the leather in the low end. You have it in the high end. But you're paying for that difference. But there is some crossover. So you can do that. So I do like this graphic too. So the first one was... Equinox member spending, average Equinox members dropping four grand a year. Again, as I say that, that does not feel a lot because I like to move and I would appreciate that. This is the extra one. In five years, they don't need to get more people per location. They're expected to now net in five years, six thousand dollars per member per year.

36:27 How do you think they'll do that? Just offer different things or raise their rates? I mean, the dollar is also losing value every day, so. I mean, raising their rates is going to be the biggest thing. I'm sure they're going to add other things, too. And if you got to think about it, they had also recently added some forty thousand dollar. And then this is only for like executives or people that can afford it. But Equinox added recently like a forty thousand dollar, like longevity, something, you know, they'll take your blood and, you know, get a physician to look at it or like a nurse or something up your butt. Look at this. Look at your butt. Look at this. yeah so so if they made projections based off of that so like the people that spend forty K plus the four grand for so they're playing they're paying forty four grand a year and if you take enough of those people but you divide it over all your members does that result in the boost to go you know faster route to go from four thousand per year spend to six thousand per year spend maybe um So what's the difference between to go from four grand a year to six grand a year?

37:37 Am I doing this properly? Is it like a sixty-seven percent increase in five years? It's a third. it's a third sort of thirty three percent increase because you're doing two with two math geniuses doing it today oh yeah so so two two back yeah two x would be eight two x would be eight thousand dollars per year so six grand per year so how yeah how else i mean the easiest lever is to raise rates but again you typically need to offer sometimes offer more or something different to justify why you're raising rates but cam needed You never, you never know. I mean, I was going to say, you never know what we're going to say.

38:19 You never know. You never know. You never know what Jimmy's going to say here live. But Cam, um, this is where I like Alex Hormozy. Some of his stuff gets a little too flippant, but like, he's like, there's three ways to make money. Let me see if I can not screw this up. Find more people. Get more people to come to your business. So Equinox is like, we don't want more people because then we got to do more stuff. So find more people. Get those people who pay you to come back more often. A gym model, you actually don't want them to come back more often, but you want them to buy more things or sell them different things. Those are the three things. Those are the three ways. And if you can come up with a fourth way, you're going to be a bajillionaire.

39:00 But those are the three ways. And we do pay attention to that, but we like to just sell people more visits. And I'm like, visits ain't it. That's a race to the bottom. Or that's the model you want to be in. That's fine. That is fine. I think I started by saying that if that is your model, that is one hundred percent OK. But just understand what game you're gaming, what game you're in. So Iron Man. Not the comic book character, the corporation that is around triathlon. They did something similar. Like where Equinox has like an executive program, Ironman started doing this about ten years ago, which is like, we'll give you... Are you a CEO making more than two hundred grand a year that wants to be an Ironman?

39:44 And everybody's like, yes. Then you do Ironman Elite. And you got, for more money per race, you got into races that were closed. Access. Access. You start closer to the front. Access. Status. You have a different badge or whatever. Or if you complete three executive races, you get an extra badge. Badge value. You become triple exec. Triple Iron Man. You're a war machine, right? But they understood what they were selling because what Iron Man realized was If we do Ironman, they have done Ironman in New York City, which was, I heard, a debacle.

40:26 We can only put about three thousand athletes and make it a good experience, safe experience. For a race. Well, how can we make more money? Do more races? Those are logistically nightmares. So they're just like, how do we get more money out of each athlete? They understood what game they were in. Now, they faced a lot of backlash because the true, the middle of the bell curve triathletes were looking at the executives and they were like, who are these rich douchebags? The thing I used to have to... Oh, you could buy your way into certain races that you used to have to earn your way into. Yeah. And people were like, dude, I just busted my ass for a decade becoming a great athlete. But Johnny's CEO could pay for it. It's like, well, they're the company.

41:06 Yeah, they let people buy their way into it. Will there be a healthcare company who understands this? Let's screw healthcare. Will there be a PT organization that understands this in the next five years and does more Equinox? Do you think they will? I would love for someone to do it. Do you think someone will? Well, when you say do what, you mean have that type of a spend per person? Or what do you mean specifically? Yeah, that's probably good. That wasn't a good question. It was in my head. What I mean is, will there be an organization, a physical therapy first organization, who will lean into the membership model and offer, we are the third place?

41:50 Because that's how we started this conversation. I feel like PT or a PT first organ... Megan Brown is a PT clinic, but she's not. She's smart enough to not put PT on her sign because she knows what she sells. Community, third place. People die to get into her clinic, right? Is it possible for a physical therapy organization to do that model and survive? With program packages of like, I've heard more and more PTs talking about like, they'll do an evaluation. They charge you whatever, two hundred bucks, three hundred bucks, whatever, hundred fifty, whatever. And then they sell you like a three month program for your issue but that's still the one-on-one treatment so it's not and that's just you come a third place as i show up whenever i'm lonely teresa's saying she will at wish clinic soon that's her goal good wish clinic is a killer name by the way like genius i do i teresa do you have wishclinic.com or is it like she's gonna have to pay she's got to buy it for me in a minute because i'm gonna Or she's like, I wish I could get it.

42:58 I wish. I used to have wish sandwiches when I was younger. You just wish there was some stuff between the bread. That was me in college. Because a package is not Equinox. Think about that. Would you ever go to Equinox and buy ten walk-ins? No. Equinox probably wouldn't let you do it. What they would do is run a credit check, see what you make, and go, we'll let you come for free today because we know what we are. Here's a good comparison, right? So Even in the cash physical therapy world, so there's the one-on-one treatment. That resembles the Equinox personal training offering. Correct. You're asking, will people pay a membership to go to a physical therapy practice like...

43:45 megan brown's place so she she sounds like she had she had she has the infrastructure to sell the membership but then the if someone had wants the one-on-one attention and time or has an issue now it's one-on-one physical therapy she's going in a different direction so like the pt clinic it's a transaction you come in you go into a small room or you walk into our gym but there's it's a guided megan's like you come in megan treats twenty-eight people at the at a time that math And no one's mad about it because it's a class. But you get her eyes only when she needs you or you're like, hey, look at my downward dog. How's that doing? And she's like, move your butt, move your leg. The expectation walking in is not Megan and you for an hour.

44:27 It's I'm part of this. So Megan goes in a different direction that we go. We said on our previous episode, the three things that we would do if we opened a gym tomorrow is you would have a gym, walk in, use the equipment. It's Disney World. Also in that facility is a room with the Norma Tech boots and a cold plunge and the weird masks that people put on their face to blast their face with infrared. That's like use your own recovery. And then the third option would be food, smoothies, places to chill. It's before, during, after. And PT clinics want to get you out the door as soon as you're done.

45:09 Like they look like PTs will literally walk you to the front desk, right? They're like, okay, and you're out. They quite literally are the anti this. It's an assembly line that you ride versus you come in and you go anywhere you want. I don't see anybody doing that anytime soon. Maybe like a rehab to perform. No, because they're a network. But you could do both. You could do a membership or Tony does that. We would have to get Josh Funk here, the CEO, on a call here on an episode because the model of what they do is all mapped out in terms of spacing and square footage and he knows how many billable units and once they get a therapist up and running and how many therapists in terms of breaking even and then like that's, that's hard to change that model, man.

45:59 Like once you're in that model, like it's hard to, it's about spacing. Right. So like his spacing is some open gym. Yes. He has a lot of places. His places have like the, the turf and, you know, pushing the sleds and there's, there's room for sprinting and running and stuff. But also some of that space is treatment tables, like out in the gym, like a bunch of treatment tables next to each other, which is, In the Equinox example is there's like two to five or six treatment tables because the people stretch on them or the trainers sometimes for better or for worse. I don't like it, but stretch people, stretch their members out. But most of the facility is the gym equipment. Right. Does that make sense? So like our our our setup is, you know, the space is utilized differently.

46:41 I mean, if you watch a bar rescue like John Taffer knows what. A chair. This fascinated me. I never thought about it like that. He's like, well, we can get six more chairs in here. I'm like, why do you care about chairs? Like every chair brings in seventy eight dollars a day. And I'm like, really? Yeah, they're full. But even if they're not full, then the average cost per chair goes down. So he's like, I get it. I need to I need to be good. Know your customer acquisition cost, knowing what it costs to get someone in the door. Yeah. This is where people get mad at Lifetime Fitness. Was it Lifetime Fitness that was writing DPT? Yeah, they were. Across their chest. Yeah. And I just go like, are you mad they're doing it? Or are you mad they're doing it and you're not?

47:22 Like, are you mad about the letters? I need you to get past that and ignore that. Someone is suing someone on that. That's not your worry. Your worry is their model is eating your lunch, not the letters. That's not what you should be defending. Talking about people suing people and people defending. I am going to an APTA event. Dave is not. Are you an APTA member? You don't care. I mean, you care, but you're like, you like show me a better ROI. I am going because I am a joiner. I just like groups of people and I hope for the better. They are having here. And here's what I wanted to say, which might make people like Dave do a little eyebrow raise. They are having this weekend, their APTA payment summit.

48:07 And I think if they held this ten years ago, they would have called it the reimbursement summit. But they are not. They're calling it the payment summit. Yes, that's true. That's true. It's back to back in Portland. I got to fly all the way to Portland tomorrow morning at zero dark thirty House of Delegates, which is like the APTA's version of Congress where like rules get made. That stuff is over my head. I need people to I'm like, I don't know what you're saying. They're banging gavels and doing Robert's rules. I do like the idea of payment and what they're doing there. I know advocacy needs to happen and move slowly. I'm not the guy to do advocacy. I'm the guy that talks to the people who do advocacy because they got to do meetings and write a lot of strongly worded emails.

48:50 Are you at least excited that someone's doing it, but you're not? No, no, it's never. Reimbursement will never change. I don't care. Well, it will change. It's just going to go down. Well, yeah, it's definitely going to go down. But with all this effort, it's crazy that they can't even get a three or five percent increase every year. They can't even do that. I will say this. If you look at other professions, it's the same. So it's not like APTA is inefficient. It's like the system is designed. What was the line? The system is designed to get the result, the exact result it gets. It's like the system's broken. Are we shocked about it? I will say this. It's impossible to know. what the world would look like if you didn't have your APTA or AOTA or ASHA.

49:30 It could be worse. That's not a great business model. Hey, without us, it could be worse. It could be worse. Yeah, I mean... I also say this isn't the main value if you're an APTA member or not. I stood in front of students at Keene University in New Jersey and a student asked, should I join APTA right out of school? And Ben Aguila, do you know Ben Aguila? Great guy, New Jersey. He was like, of course, this, this, this. And I said, Ben, I'm going to offer a counterpoint. And Ben was like, what are you doing here, buddy? We're on stage. We're pushing. I said, don't join APTA. And the room went quiet. And then I said, until you understand what you're looking for and what APTA actually provides.

50:13 If you're looking for a community, APTA provides that, a network, right? If that's what you're looking for, what I'm trying to do is have nobody in the comments section a year later going, I paid APTA five hundred bucks and I didn't get anything. Make sure you have expectations in reality. If you think you're going to pay APTA five hundred bucks and payments going to turn around tomorrow, you will be disappointed and then you'll leave and you'll never come back. I don't want that. It's four hundred people out in Portland. I'll report back what actually is done. I hope it's good. I hope it's good. But I thought all three of the topics today were all about money, expectation matching reality and understand what game you're playing.

50:59 And for me, I can't outsource that to Jimmy and Tony. I can't outsource that to the APTA. Structuring a model that's profitable. Here's your decision tree. What should you do? Join APTA. What should you do after that? Immediately continue to work on your own problems. Because they're going to be background stuff. It's too big to move. So you'll notice... The stuff that APTA or large organizations do, it's moving like a, you know, you time it like a sundial. It's moving. It's just super slow. It's like, all right, well, that's out of my arena. But I am going there this weekend.

51:41 I'll be doing some short interviews too. I'm doing more of those, just like three question interviews. Those turn out well. As well as, did you see the video I shared yesterday? Do you know those reaction videos? where it's a guy, he's really funny. He's got a beard and he'll have just a bunch of like videos from people like hurting themselves on job sites. Like a guy shoots himself with a nail gun or a guy falls off a ladder. And the video is weird clip. And then the guy's like looking at it. It's like him just like straight. And then he looks over here. So I was like, I'm going to steal that format. And I did that. And I went on Instagram and I found a bunch of weird rehab stuff, guy with a flamethrower, a guy with a Milwaukee buffer. And I'm like, I'm going to be the weird face between that video blew up. This just tells you.

52:23 How many views right now? Because it looks like it got a bunch of comments and likes and reactions. It got a bunch of comments, a bunch of likes. I'm looking up. Is that like five or ten K already? It's already five. It was five K this morning. Wow. Nice. Actually, that's where it went down. It can't go down. It's not how views work. for for credit for k right now that's lower than i thought it would be i thought that would have been like a ten k in twenty four hours but we still got some time that is also funny how videos work though could do nothing nothing nothing pop so you never know um so that's the lesson there is take a format that's that's already working and then just how do i do my spin on it bow dr bow out in colorado says brilliant borrow yeah i just stole it i didn't borrow it i just stole it i was like i can do this Yeah, APT is a great community if you like that.

53:13 Anyway, all right, parting shots. What do you got for us, Dave? Just for us continuing to focus on over-delivering value to our patients and clients. And when we do that, then we can easily map out projections of, hey, we got people paying four K per year. And here's how we could get them to pay six K per year. But it's not salesy. It's not pressuring. It's not... anything nefarious it's like can we unlock more value can we help them with more things get more referrals uh and that like i shared that with you guys because i was like that's always on my head which is like how can we obviously we want to grow and and get more patients and clients but one of the easiest levers for us is having the same patients and clients that were recently with us or even years ago continue to work with us and without that new customer acquisition cost They're a text message away, guys.

54:06 They're an email away. I have them nearby somewhere. Send them handwritten thank you notes. Send them handwritten letters. Hey, hope you're having a great summer. Happy birthday. I mean, one of my patients that's been with me for two years, it was just his birthday like a week or two ago. and i was like i bought him a mini massage gun because he loves the massage guns i'm like you could travel with it you could do it when i'm not here uh yep jimmy's got this is this is uh sponsored here we go um so so i got this i got this guy a one of those heichi massage guns they're like fifty bucks and then i said i'm also gonna get you uh a fifty five minute in-home massage from this other company this other person now i'm i'm giving this massage therapist a referral And the patient is beyond impressed and was super surprised.

55:00 But this guy has spent forty five thousand dollars with us in two years. He bought himself the massage gun. It's already baked into the profit, baby. So anyway, for it. Oh, long thing for Matt. Matt's saying what we're saying. People need to stop looking for a potato to solve their problems. They're not a marketing agency. They're not. It's in the name. They're a professional association. They're where professionals associate. That is a place. That is a community. Not a marketing agency. I'm very sorry. They're not built for that. That's brilliant. In your brain, do you have... hey, when a patient has netted me or grossed, no, netted, netted me ten K, I should get them a dinner at like four seasons or something.

55:46 Yeah, yeah. Dude, if someone netted us ten K, why would I not spend a thousand dollars on them? Stop being cheap. Stop being cheap. Come on. But never say spend ten K and get the tote bag. Just... Send them a thing like I have a reservation for you standing at Smith and Walensky's. What's Peter Luger, right? That's the big one. Was that Brooklyn? Peter Luger. Your name, whatever you want. The bill comes to me. Thank you. And that feels gangster. That feels like Goodfellas, which is worth way more than a thousand bucks. And it's got to be something that it's not a branded t-shirt from us.

56:30 That's not a birthday gift. that's about us it's got to be something that they care about that would benefit them that does not have your logo on it and then when their friends come over they want to show their friends and tell their friends about their physical therapist that got them this gift or whatever so you know cutting knives like whatever it is yeah knives would be cool If they cook, if they prepare their own food, you got to know their thing. And when they're spending four to six grand with you per year, you better know their thing. And time. That has probably come up. Oh my God, I've always wanted to take my kid to a Yankee game and sit in a box.

57:12 And you're like, mental note, got it. Don't worry about it. And you go on eBay and you get whatever. That carries weight. My parting shot would be expectation for reality, make sure they match. And if they don't, that's why people are pissed. And again, to reiterate, it's not really Alex Ramos's thing, but he does hammer it a lot. There's only three ways to not even make more money, serve people better, get more people to come to your thing or buy your thing. Get those people to come back more often. Those are different. And get those people who come back to spend or do more. Those are the only three ways. I'll report back after I'm back from APTA. We'll see how that goes. We'll see if we've changed the world in Portland this weekend.

57:55 Dave, have a good weekend. Yeah, fingers crossed. That's it. We're out. Boys, what the hell are you doing? Follow Tony Meritato on YouTube at Total Therapy Solution. Find Dave Kittle at ConciergePainRelief.com and on YouTube at The Dave Kittle Show. And follow Jimmy McKay at PT Podcasts on YouTube, the socials, and wherever you binge podcasts you pretend are for CEUs. And hey, just a reminder, none of this was for advice. This was for entertainment only. Our lawyers say that counts. Thanks, Keith.