Why Insurance PT Models Are Breaking Down
This episode dives into one of the biggest shifts happening in physical therapy right now: the gap between what patients need and what insurance allows.
Jimmy, Tony, and Dave break down:
• Why most AI solutions in healthcare never make it past pilot phase
• How insurance limitations are shaping care delivery
• The rise of hybrid and post-rehab fitness models
• Why clinical skill is no longer the main differentiator
• How communication, sales, and patient buy-in drive outcomes
Key Insights:
• 95% of AI pilots in healthcare never scale—adoption is the real problem
• Insurance caps are forcing clinics to find new care models
• Neuro and long-term patients are underserved by traditional PT
• Cash-based PT is growing because patients value time and outcomes
• Pre/post testing isn’t just clinical—it’s a sales and trust tool
• PTs are trained to “not lose,” but progress requires risk
Why This Matters:
If you’re a clinic owner, this is about adapting your model before it’s forced on you.
If you’re a staff PT, this is about understanding what actually creates value in today’s market.
<p>This episode is part of the <a href="/physical-therapy-business-podcast">Physical Therapy Business Podcast</a>, where physical therapists and clinic owners learn how to get more patients, improve operations, and grow their clinic without relying only on referrals.</p>
<p>Looking for more episodes? Explore the full <a href="/physical-therapy-business-podcast">Physical Therapy Business Podcast</a> for real-world strategies on physical therapy marketing, patient acquisition, and clinic growth.</p>
0:01 and there we go happy tuesday uh he's tony maritano i'm jimmy mckay and this is pt breakfast club dave will be here in a minute um we had a lot of action in the uh the group chat the last couple days a lot of things that were going on what do you want to start with first You go. You look at it because my computer is rebooting. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Well, first was the response to Sam Altman saying that there will be a one-person AI-built billion-dollar industry. Did you see that, the company? He has said that since the release of ChatGPT-Tree.
0:42 So I haven't seen anything recent, what's going on. And then I think David shared this. um someone had said they had done it but really what the guy was doing was he was just he was just using ai to just create hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of ads and then connect them to things to people actually doing the thing so he was he was selling glp ones so i think it's yeah i think what it is i think dave is sharing that because he's saying look ai isn't all it's cracked up to be it's not doing this thing i also don't think either of us think ai is going to do everything But I think AI is doing a lot of different things and you can choose where in your life.
1:23 Remember that like in Mario Kart, where there was those things you could go over, you drive over and all of a sudden the car would just sort of boost forward. Yeah. That's sort of what AI is, right? It's going to do the same thing that you're doing now. It's just going to give you a little bit of an edge in doing it. I did read a statistic yesterday. I was talking with Andrea. We do sort of a marketing show every week. And she quoted the statistic that I had actually already found. An MIT study showed that about ninety five percent of AI pilots in health care Never leave the pilot stage. So essentially, a tech company makes a bold claim. This will save every one of your providers three hours of documentation time per day.
2:07 They do a pilot and it doesn't move forward. And I sort of read that as we're coming in this thing pretty hot where everybody's got the solution. eventually someone will have a better solution to do this or the writer's solution or the easier solution. So I think David shared some information like that too. Yeah, but I mean, so two things here. First, the original point of, okay, this guy created a billion dollar business, air quotes. How do we define what a business is? He's using AI to do these things to make this money. Um, just because he's not like in a lab making the GOP one, he's reselling it effectively.
2:54 Uh, I still say it's a business. It's still a functional business. It's still a single person business. Go back. Twenty or thirty years. He couldn't have done what he's doing right now. Um, so, you know, maybe it's not the business we expected, but still works. Right. It shows up in his bank account or, you know, it showed up in his bank account. And two, why are so many of these pilots not taking off? Is it the technology or is it the human that refuses to adopt it? I look at how long it takes me, how long it took me to adopt EMR, how long it took me to bring in and really, really refine the system for AI documentation.
3:40 and even now it's far from perfect but it's like we're under such a heavy burden of compliance and hipaa and state laws and local laws and federal laws and association all of this stuff is virtually impossible i mean i can't imagine where healthcare would be if we eliminated so much of the burden of compliance and regulation i i think we'd be so far ahead Some of the discussion I've had with people who are in technology that bring it to healthcare is, well, it might be a few months into the person already having developed the technology and the question is, well, why can't we just do it this way? And the answer is, I don't know, because we can't.
4:23 You need a way around that. It being a bad idea doesn't prevent it from being the rule or the law. Dave is doing some construction. Setting up the lighting. Good morning. Dave, you shared a story about a former NHL player opening up what looks like a PT and rehab center in Connecticut. Yeah, I figured I figured you would like it. Hockey player Jimmy is still playing men's league hockey and any anything that is serving the neuro population is wonderful. I'm not sure if you guys had much to look into it, but anything that even if it's against the traditional rehab, like you share something maybe a few months ago where it was like just.
5:11 personal training and not physical therapy or not rehab, but nonetheless, anything that is like this, um, especially if it's someone that is, or previously was in the public eye and is serving the neural population, it's a wonderful thing. Yeah. So I can't see the story cause it's gate kept, but is it, is it not a PT clinic, but it's on the outside or what is it? So I think it's both. I think they do therapy and then also training. So it would be maybe after... And this is the unfortunate thing that when someone has a neurological condition, it's obviously like a long-term thing, but most insurances are only going to cover like a certain amount of visits per year or even the first year.
5:54 And so it seemed like it would be a way to kind of segue those folks into training in the same facility after they have like their acute outpatient experience of rehab and therapy. Yeah. I just talked to the AP, the president of APTA Minnesota. I'll bring up her website. I've talked to a guy by the name of Yanni Corey, who's decided to essentially make gyms filled with equipment that's perfect or tailored to people with spinal cord injuries, post-stroke, traumatic brain injury. And the thing missing from the location are the PTs because they're too expensive.
6:34 So that model will not allow it. The insurance won't cover it. So it doesn't cover things. and but but we understand especially with with the populations we're talking about that ongoing treatment is needed and yet the financial model isn't there so they flipped it so they've made it more of a gym model and they find a way to make it work it just sucks the fact that like we know these these people need this it's ongoing and we have to come up with I mean, I like creativity, but it sucks that we have to come up with creative ways to give people a thing that we know will help them. We have to sort of like skirt the rules and figure out ways around it or remove PTs from the equation altogether.
7:16 Or, hold on, hold on. Go ahead, Tony. I was just going to say, put PTs in the role that we were designed for. We are not designed for counting reps and sitting there watching the patient. We're designed for the evaluation, developing the plan of care, establishing the patient-centered goal, teaching, all of these things. Dave, go ahead. While you do talk, Dave, Jimmy, I shared two links related to this topic in the chat just now. Go ahead, Dave. So let me let me double click on what you said. So I agree with everything you're saying, except then you're saying that physical therapist develops the plan of care. But then, all right, let's have some PTA or unlicensed person carry out the plan of care.
8:00 It's it it doesn't I don't know. It doesn't fully make sense. It's as if like an orthopedic surgeon would say, all right, you need surgery. And here's why you would need surgery. And here's why your insurance will pay for it. But then I'm going to turn it over to an esthetician or someone that's not a surgeon. I get what you're saying for financial reasons and all that. Logistically, it doesn't make sense. If money was not a factor here, right, Tony? Wouldn't you have physical therapists do the evaluation and go through the plan of care? Or maybe the first three to five visits or something and make sure the person's on the right track and make sure that they are... getting the differential diagnosis correct and making sure that the patient does not need to be referred back for advanced imaging.
8:47 Maybe it's, you know, a tumor or something malignant or something that is, you know, serious. And then after visit number three or five, then they go to a PTA or then they go to, you know, this unlicensed person that's like part of the team, but they're not a licensed healthcare provider. If money's not an issue, if money was not a factor, that's the thing I would like to talk about. Yeah, if oxygen wasn't an issue, I'd live on the moon, but it is. So I think money is always a factor for the majority of the population, not everyone, but a lot of people. And so, yeah, if money wasn't a factor, I'd eat off gold plates and I'd drive a Lamborghini, but it is.
9:29 So Jimmy, real quick, this is a company, they're franchising that machine. It's all crazy expensive. I don't know why somebody did it, but this is for individuals with neurologic conditions like brain injury, stroke, that are finished with PT, finished with OT, self-paying out of pocket to come sit in this machine and work on motor function. uh all self-pay i think they're charging three hundred a month but don't quote me on that no no therapist in the building this is just post rehab and then the other one is stroke fitness which dave and i talked about last week uh same thing they have a series of machines people who have had strokes go in for for exercise there's no pts on site ot's on site and it's it's post rehab and i think they're around that same price point two three hundred dollars a month i mean these are popping up obviously because there's clearly need and it's clearly lacking and the system is screwed in terms of insurance we'll say i mean that's how you know i'll bring up the website in a second but that's where next step fitness which essentially is this model and yanni the guy i met years ago friend had a spinal cord injury and said i was told i was going to get three weeks worth of PT.
10:53 I wasn't even going to be at a hospital yet that I was going to be done, but was told I had all this function still to go and it wasn't going to be covered. Now he was financially able to fly himself across country and live somewhere while he was getting treatment. But he's like, I understand that that's not possible for everybody. So he decided to build sort of that gym model. But I mean, this goes back to the conversation we've had before, which is, I understand what Dave's talking about. In a cash model, if someone can afford it, if oxygen wasn't an issue, you'd want the person who's got the most skill doing the most time with the person who's paying the most money. In an insurance model, you get paid the most for doing the evaluation, and then you're underwater for doing anything past that, it seems, or close to it, right?
11:42 I mean... Dave? Yeah, well, yeah, but... We've had other examples on the show historically, like when I brought up the Spiro Clinic, I think they're in like Arkansas and they charge like an enormous, I think it was like forty grand, forty two thousand for what they do to help people with complex regional pain syndrome and reflex, reflex dystrophy and all that type of stuff. So like the real like POTS and MCAS and all these like global rheumatological slash neurological multi-system presentations. And they help, and I'm not saying this is great.
12:23 I'm not saying this is, I'm not saying even what I'm about to say, I'm not saying this is the solution, but they help their potential clients set up GoFundMes to raise the money. And I'm not saying that's great or just or the right solution or anything, but that's just another way. That's another solution. So this practice that does That charges forty two thousand dollars for however long the plan of care is. I think it's like I think it's like three or four or six months. It's like a really long time. You would go and live in the town to get your treatment for however long. And they have people that fly in from every state, every country. And.
13:03 That's not the best solution maybe, but that is just what they've found to work for them. And they help their patients set up GoFundMes to raise money from their friends, their family, their community members, all that. So, I mean, a good sales question in general for any sales is like, if someone presents some investment or some whatever, some service or whatever, it's like, you know, do you have the funds for this investment? Or do you know people that would have funds for this investment? So that's like an Alex Ramosy quote. He'll say that, or they would say that when they're selling gym launch to gyms. So you could take out a credit card, you could get a line of credit, you could get a bank loan, whatever.
13:47 And people have done that just to join gym launch. And people will do the same thing for these opportunities. I'm not saying it's the right way, but there are solutions out there. There are workarounds to make things happen depending on if the end consumer, in this case, the patient, the client that maybe has a neurological condition, wants above and beyond what their current insurance will pay. You mentioned GoFundMe. I got to tag you. Kara Wilkie had asked in the OT group, If anybody had ever heard of setting up GoFundMes, like a clinic doing it to pay for their patient's care, I had forgotten you had mentioned that. Separately, Jimmy, I don't know if you ever, did you interview this guy?
14:28 He's an OT, Dr. Phil, the OT professor. he does a neuro boot camp he's got a growing tick tock channel he basically either he goes to them or they come to him and it's this intensive multi-hour you know multi-day just taking patients who have had strokes and brain injuries and putting them through all of these workouts it's really impressive like a and then that goes back to dave's point what's that Like a train the carer? Like he trains people who are going to then train the trainer? No, no. It's a neuro boot camp is what he calls it. And he's training the patient more than anything.
15:11 But just high intensity, long duration sessions. And this goes to Dave's point. I don't think you could outsource something like that. Like the OT is doing it because these are complex cases and you're spotting the person and... They're gonna fall, they're gonna get hurt. Speaking of which, this is kind of an interesting, we had a patient fall in the clinic the other day. And I generally pride myself on never letting anyone fall. And I'm asking you guys, peer to peer, I was thinking about it and I'm like, I'm always a defensive therapist. I'm never going to put someone in a position to get hurt.
15:53 I will tell everyone coming into my clinic, you might not get better, but you won't get worse. You might not reach your goal, but you're not going to get hurt in the process, right? The difference between me and a CrossFit coach is the CrossFit coach is going to make you achieve outcomes you've never imagined possible. I'm just not going to make you get hurt. I'm not even going to make you sore. My question to you guys is, if we are really in the business of improving and challenging patients and making them do things that they want to achieve, accidents are going to happen. People are going to get hurt.
16:33 Jimmy gets hurt playing hockey. Dave gets hurt on the baseball field. I get hurt running down the block. Like, are we underdosing to the point that, you know, we're just so conservative and so scared of the liability? I mean, is it reasonable to say, okay, I'm probably going to drop two or three people a year. This is going to be the price that's paid for helping these people go into challenging positions. Is that a reasonable expectation? I think so. There's a lot of PTs out there across the country on Instagram that are always making fun of traditional PTs saying, you know, nothing's going to happen with a yellow TheraPan.
17:15 There was like the gif of the older woman deadlifting and she's got like gray hair. And she said there was like a talk bubble and it was like, you know, I don't need your yellow TheraPan or something like that because she's deadlifting like two hundred pounds or something. So there are a lot of PTs that have already acknowledged that a lot of the traditional in network physical therapy practices not or or not even i won't even say i'll just say traditional pt not even in network uh are under loading their patients and clients they're using you know therabands when they could be doing like a a farmer's carry with a dumbbell or like an overhead you know with a with a kettlebell overhead walk things like that, or sideline arm bar with a kettlebell as opposed to the yellow TheraBand.
18:00 So there's a lot of PTs out there that have kind of identified this over time. That is the price that we pay, Tony. It's kind of like that trade-off. And we have clients that we interact with. And it's like, sometimes they're one way, Tony, and sometimes they're the other way. Sometimes they are afraid to get sore. They're afraid of the current issue getting worse. They're afraid of the previous issue coming back. Some have a lot of anxiety or nervousness around how they're going to respond. And we tell them up front, like, hey, thank you for sharing that. And that's totally fine. I'll communicate that with the therapist and make sure, hey, start this person really low and progressive and really slow and easy. And then we can minimize their soreness or their discomfort or things like that.
18:45 versus if it's like a marathon runner and they're twenty five years old, they're used to getting sore and we want to ramp them up as fast as possible. So then we want to it really for us, it depends on the patient. We can deliver either experience. We don't want to be one or the other, Tony. But yes, if someone is sixty five or seventy five and they want to avoid falling, then we have to say, hey, we really need to push you outside of your comfort zone. And when we're working together, you know, we're going to have a gate belt around you or whatever. But it's possible that you might fall. Maybe you slip out of my grasp, even if we're doing tactile cues and we're holding them with their gait belt, they still might fall.
19:26 And then of course, Tony, if you're away from them and they're doing a ladder drill, stepping through a ladder, they might trip and fall on their own. So yes, it would be the price that you pay depending on the patient's clients' goals and also how you, the therapist, develop your therapeutic exercise and balance like is it low level or is it you know pushing them outside of their comfort zone where those falls would then be more likely Yeah, I mean, even Tony just saying, like, I had a patient fall brought me back to, I can picture the woman and what it felt like the second. And I think I, like, rolled myself underneath her to, like, brace her. And I thought I was like, everything's over.
20:09 It doesn't count. It doesn't count if they fell on you and they didn't hit the floor. It doesn't count. The funny part is I can still picture this woman's feet because she would come and flip-flop, like, not even flip-flops, like, slide-ins. And I remember being like, let's just go barefoot because that'd be like, you're going to trip on these. And she's like, I'm fine. I'm fine. And we're doing like step ups on a box and she, she eats it. And I'm like, I knew it. I didn't push hard enough, but like, That's the thing, right? We're taught the goal is don't lose. I was taught when I started in radio, the goal is don't lose the license of the radio station. Not win, not win, win later, but make sure you do not lose, right? Like loss aversion. So, I mean, you can't walk onto a baseball field.
20:53 You can't walk into a playground, a tennis court, a skate park without walking past a sign that is large enough for a lawyer to say there's no possible way you could miss that by saying, anything that happens here, it's on you. And then for some reason, we're very, very nervous. And I get it. Listen, if you prove negligence, listen, if you've got a person on a BOSU ball on one foot with, you know, It sort of sucks. I get what you're saying. I think most people are like, just don't Don't lose. Don't lose the license. Don't get fired. But yes, I think doing things that are hard and just outside of someone's capability is the point.
21:40 And that, someone can math this, over X number of patient interactions in a year, it's almost like a fall. Falling is normal. We don't care. We sort of look and think it's cute when a kid falls, right? They're learning to do something they haven't done or they're trying to do something they haven't done in a while. And then we do it with an adult and we're like, absolutely not. Absolutely not. So I, I, I lately meant, I lately mentioned cash-based PT, but I want to just mention that guy, Preston, I think Preston Alexander from LinkedIn. I shared that with you guys in the chat. Right. He, I don't even know what he does, but he gets like a ton of views and engagements and comments on his LinkedIn posts. And he's the one that's been really outspoken against insurance companies and, you know, like big pharma and big medicine and all that type of stuff on LinkedIn.
22:24 And then I was really surprised. I haven't been doing a lot of LinkedIn, but now I'm back on LinkedIn doing some recruiting. So yeah. Yesterday, I saw that Preston posted some posts that he was doing self-pay physical therapy. And I thought that was really interesting because I didn't think, I don't know, like I just, I didn't, I feel like there's not a lot of people that are non-physical therapists that ever post that they're the patients of a self-pay physical therapist and like why they're going. Any thoughts on that post? yeah i mean number one so i looked up who he was and he's definitely talking about health care in three hundred and sixty degrees right like he's talking about payers like that's his whole angle is like don't let payers fleece you and this goes into the fact that wellness and fitness is now a status symbol it's a possession now.
23:13 You can own fitness. And people sort of brag about the equipment they have, how often they work out, what type of diet they have. I think you're going to see more of this. In fact, as you're saying it, I'm sort of surprised that you're not. How many people, if they had one, a personal chef, I mean, that's sort of what he's sort of talking about. He's like, my therapist doesn't have to check his watch to see when we're ending because essentially I pay him well enough where time is no longer the factor. Skill is now the factor. I pay this because I want the result. I don't think you could have talked your way into this situation ten years ago or it would have been really hard for a small group of people.
23:54 I think it's easier because you have to convince people less of how valuable being well is. yeah i i agree the new status and and we saw one of the guys from uh one of the investors from uh a show that I used to watch all the time. He was saying that... Shark Tank? Yeah, one of the Shark Tank guys. He was like, the modern flex is being strong, being healthy. I think Dave asked if that was an AI video or a real video. I mean, the guy looked great. Okay, you did. Yeah, and so it's totally true.
24:36 Herjavec has always looked great. I saw so much of his content in a short period of time. It just seemed too right. You know what I mean? Like that's sort of like the litmus test that we're going to have in a year. I don't know if we're gonna be able to tell the difference between some of this stuff. Remember the test like a year ago, it was like, there's six fingers on that person's hand or they spell the word guarantee with three E's. It's like, that was obvious. Although, if I were trying to get a group of population on a planet indoctrinated into being able to think they can see through AI and then completely pull the wool over their eyes, step one would be make it sort of a C+.
25:18 and then jump to the A-plus, it's over. Because you're like, oh, I can spot this stuff. It's super easy. And then jump to it. So I saw so much of it. He didn't seem like the kind of guy or doesn't seem like the kind of guy who needs to be shooting a bunch of, I'm just walking to get a cup of coffee video. And I happened to be like sort of looking over my shoulder and like talking to my videographer about lessons in money. And it just felt too, it felt too on, it felt too on brand. Yeah. um but yes robert hershevek has always sort of that's always sort of been his angle which is like health's the only thing you can't take away when you can't buy anything else what do you buy buy time or money or sorry time or health because you can't buy either of those things but you can flex on those things yeah so i have no idea what video you're talking about with robert persia You shared it in the chat?
26:10 It wasn't even one particular video. He just had so much content. Obviously, I probably watched one of his videos too long. And next thing I know, I saw thirty of them in three days. It looked like too much different content coming out in a short period of time. Either he banged out a hard session of a weekend of just shooting stuff where the videographer was like, let's just do what you normally do on a day. Let's go get coffee and then give me a story. Give me a lesson in this. That's what I, so I went to, this is like a weird segue. I didn't plan on doing this, but that's, that's what happened when I went and Dave, you'd be a perfect audience for this. I don't think any small clinic should hire a full-time marketing person. If they're below, I don't know. I'm going to say five full-time employees, right?
26:51 Just making that number up. It doesn't make any sense, math-wise. If you're twenty-plus, maybe fractional. If you're fifty-plus, full-time, right? Again, making these numbers up. So when I was at Danny Matei's event two weeks ago, a lot of the people I was talking to were like, I've got three FTEs, I've got five, I've got seven. And I'm like, huh, now you're in the territory where You know you need some more volume to keep those five or seven people busy. You don't want it to be your job. And I'm talking about the owner. The owner is like, I've been doing it for now. Now there's sort of that step where you've got to sort of hand that off. So I've been toying with the idea of you don't need someone who's on hand all the time.
27:32 What you need is a hard weekend or a hard two days of let's map out what you're going to get, bring in the team to do it. record film walk people through it they leave they edit everything and then dave gets a google drive filled with everything a kit that says here's enough i mean you're smart enough because you've been doing it but like here's what you have here's what you ordered and here's what you get it's like a custom burrito from chipotle it's a marketing kit that's delivered to you but that person doesn't need to live in your clinic because that math doesn't math Yeah, for sure. Speaking of videos and stuff, Jimmy, I sent you a link. Did you guys see that two thousand five video that I shared?
28:13 Oh, yeah. You were going full Gary Vee. Oh, Dave, if you can pull it up. Where is it? i'll get it on facebook i i thought i tagged you but maybe not we were going my wife and i were going through old kid photos and kid videos and we came across a couple folders of uh videos from and pictures from like and i had no idea i completely forgot like look at this this is like uh i'm holding i'm holding a camcorder I'm not spotting the poor guy. I'm not guarding the poor guy.
28:54 Even in two thousand and five. This is back in Florida. I'm like focused on I need to get the video. I don't know what I was going to do with it. This this was, you know, so far back. But this goes to like, remind people, look, I've been doing this over twenty years, virtually the same stuff, you know? Now, what this video did remind me of, I can't believe this could be a scene in my clinic today. Like, we have not innovated. I've still got people doing a sit-to-stand from a bench. Maybe not on an AirX anymore, but I've got the AirX for other stuff.
29:36 I'm wearing the same clothes. My geriatric seniors are exactly the same except, you know, a new generation of them. It's like a time warp. Other than my hair is darker and I have a little more of it and I'm thinner, but my clothes are baggier. It could be today. It could be today. I love it. Incredible. Incredible. I mean, yeah. Tony, this almost looks like the gentleman with the joke book, like when he was younger. Yeah. I can't even tell you how many people... over the years have been replicas of themselves it's just oh yeah you know it's just the same person keeps walking in my doors but they're they have different names paul's convinced you're a time traveler there tony seriously This is just a reminder, like anyone that like, sometimes like when I had the grant, my grandfather-in-law video that now is up to like one hundred and fifty six thousand views, which is still like decent, but not like.
30:49 And then you go to I go over to Tony's Instagram and I look at those reels and I look at the most viewed and it was like two point three million. I'm like and I got I got excited from that video on my my account. And it's like. I can't even compare it. Tony's been messing with these camcorders in his clinic in two thousand one, two thousand three, two thousand five, like before Gary Vee was on YouTube before there was a YouTube. Right. I'll bring up the post, but I share this and I think both of you are excited to talk about it. Somebody anonymously. posted in a large PT Facebook group that they said, I feel like I will have to spend between five and eight thousand dollars to get some skills before I can get in my own cash practice.
31:37 Have any of you done that? I rushed to the comments and hoping and i'll bring the post up maybe i was wrong but from what i remember i rushed to the con to the comments hoping people would be like you don't need to do that do not do that you don't need it fight why do you just have five to eight k burning a hole in your pocket if so happy to take it off your hands but you don't need to do that And many of them were saying, yes, I did the same thing, but never saying I did the same thing and it burned me. I didn't need to do the same thing. What were your thoughts when I shared this? What would have been your reaction had you had been in that group when it was shared?
32:18 What group was it in? I remember the post. Just the big physical therapy group. Go ahead, Dave. So the first distinction would be what type of skills. That's the, that's the biggest question. Are we talking about clinical skills, which in general you should have, maybe not as a new grad. Cause I think the first three years I was like, I had a, I had a big ego and then I realized like how much I didn't know, but I thought I knew a ton or I thought I knew everything in the first one or two years of being a DPT. I think there was a lot of like ego with that. Um, But are we talking about clinical skills or are we talking about business marketing sales, right? So in cash practice, you need marketing and sales.
33:02 You need repetitions of being told no, which takes months, if not years. You need the marketing. You need the sales process of like, how am I going to overcome the insurance question? How are we going to navigate? What is the pricing? Like, how do we do all that? Like that we're not even taught in school. And if you like, we talked with Tony a million times, if you didn't have a business before DPT school, you haven't gone through this. You haven't gone through rejection and starting a business from scratch and all that. So are we talking about clinical skills? If, if that's the case, I think you had enough with DPT with the DPT. Or are we talking about business and marketing skills? If that's the case, yes, you probably do. I didn't. But you probably do need a coach that you need to spend five or eight K on for a course on how to do Facebook ads or Google ads or set up Google ads or how to have a coach keep you accountable with reviewing your sales calls, with patients and overcoming their objections, all that.
33:58 So it depends on what skills we're talking about. Right. I read this first as clinical skills. And then I read back and said, oh, to get my own cash practice was hoping they were talking about skills that they weren't already taught. So they weren't paying for them twice. That is sort of the way I looked at it. I commented, I asked, what skills are you looking for? And they replied like pelvic floor therapy, maybe manual therapy. And if you scroll through the comments, which you don't have to do now, but one of my previous teachers, Thomas Eberle, He and I don't agree on a lot of things.
34:39 We agree on some things. He's working with Ron Miller down in Florida now. He's a cash PT, manual therapist. But he had suggested, yes, definitely you can't start a cash-based therapy without better clinical skills. And of course, I knew the three of us would be like, heck no, the clinical skills, you just have to be not bad. You just have to be good enough. You need business skills, marketing skills, communication skills. You need to understand the consumer and what the consumer is actually buying in order to go into the cash-based world.
35:22 Yeah. I do want to mention though, I don't know if I was taught in the DPT program or if we were, I don't know if it was, there was a big emphasis on it. So for like orthopedic or outpatient PT, I don't think I ever saw or remember. And I, please correct me if you guys got it in your rotations or your first DPT job, your first outpatient job about the pre and post tests, like to actually show the patient like, okay, so you're feeling seven out of ten knee pain. And then we're going to do some interventions. We're going to do, knee joint mobilizations. We're going to look at your hip. We're going to do this, that we're going to do. single leg stand, whatever. And then we're going to do these interventions. Then we're going to check your knee pain again with whatever the squat or whatever movement.
36:04 Okay. Oh, now it's a five out of ten. Okay. So now it feels better. And kind of showing the patient at the eval, like, hey, like what we just did, like what we just did in like a treatment preview, not even the full visit because we did the whole evaluation and everything. This is a treatment preview. And we just dropped your pain down from seven out of ten to five out of ten. That's a little bit of sales in a way. It's I think it's a great evaluation and treatment for the first visit. And the patient realizes that you can help them. And now it's like, hey, if we string a bunch of visits together, just can you can you imagine? Like, obviously, I would be the right one to help you with this. Tony, is that something that you ever recall your other therapist doing that had that you taught them or they came out of school with that or Jimmy?
36:46 I mean, is this something that you learned or what? I know we did it in school. We were taught pre-test, post-test, you know, measure the difference. In school, we were taught it as this is good clinical practice. But as a business owner, I knew this is a sales process. The only reason why I'm doing this is to be like, oh, my gosh, you just improved thirty percent in twenty minutes. Like you said, Dave, imagine what we could do over twelve visits. You know, it's totally a sales process. But in school, yes, we did learn it. We learned it as, you know, this is what you document. This is how you do a good assessment.
37:26 I don't think they even realized because they were so stuck in academia that, no, you're selling. That's a sales process. Paul, watching live, anyone watching or listening live, can you just comment wherever you're at, YouTube, LinkedIn, wherever this is being aired live, can you comment if you learned it in school or at a rotation or did it in your first job? Because maybe, Tony, maybe everyone's getting it. Maybe everyone's not. I don't know. Jimmy, do you remember that in your DPT program? I don't think it was in the program. Again, it was a decade ago, so I don't want to say it. And of course, it'd be there. But I think this is two different things. Maybe three different things.
38:07 Is it clinical? I guess. But really, if it's clinical, I think it's clinical psychology. It's showing someone, hey, look, you had this. We did this. It led to this. And then that is also sales. So I don't know if it's clinical. If it is, it's on the side of patient buy-in. Them seeing something and understanding something. Us showing that movement and doing these movements will actually do better outcomes. So I think it's probably... one, if not all three of those different things. But I don't think it was ever actually shown. I think that was a problem for me, is everything was shown like, oh, you got to rub the knee counterclockwise and not clockwise. Otherwise, who did you learn from?
38:48 What book did you read? You got to move the ultrasound one, clockwise, not counterclockwise. If you're north of the equator, you go clockwise, you dumbass. If you're south of the equator, you go counterclockwise. Otherwise, the magic gnomes don't provide the crystals to move in the right direction. So I think I went in thinking there was some magic and then realizing there wasn't, but then thinking I had to sort of BS my way through things, and I was like, nah, I'm good. But I think showing someone after they do something that there's not a fear, not everything makes things worse, I think that's the magic. Yeah. So Ben Galen commented live on LinkedIn. He said, never really taught for me.
39:29 Paul commented live on YouTube. He said that we did have pre post-test as a point of discussion, more for knowing if we're on the right path versus a selling point. Both are true. Yeah. You know, it's funny going back to talking about the soft skills. I think we talked about it last week. I had a patient, returning patient, this patient has known me for five, six years, had a rotator cuff repair. Perfect example. came into my clinic to schedule, didn't call to schedule, came to the clinic, was physically present. I said, hey, do you have fifteen minutes? Let's do your eval right now. So had a rotator cuff repair ten days ago in the sling, came from the orthopedic office, was driving home, said, hey, I'm going to stop into Tony's clinic and schedule an eval.
40:19 I was like, you're here. You're here. You're not leaving unless we do an evaluation. And so I'm like, hey, you know, I'm going to rub your shoulder and make it feel a little better. She's like, no, no, you can't touch it. You can't touch it. I was like, what do you mean you can't touch it? You just had a rotator cuff repair. You're cleared to start therapy. Let's go. And she was like, no, no, you can't touch it. Anyway, needless to say, the point in this was, okay, I was able to diffuse, and this is somebody who knew me, but even knowing me was so scared that I was going to do something wrong to her shoulder that I got her to stay, rubbed her shoulder a little bit, loosened her up. She was like, oh, I do feel so much better.
41:01 Fixed the sling. Fifteen minutes, we were done. Got the evaluation in the books and got her scheduled for once a week follow up for the next two weeks until we can start doing more. I don't know. Like, that's not the kind of thing you learn in school. You know, but that's the kind of thing that I think makes such a major impact. That's not the kind of thing that a typical employed therapist who's like, why the patient's not expecting to get a valve. Now the patient's fine booking the appointment and leaving and coming back. Like these are skills and, and I don't even want to call them talents, but something that if we could identify them early enough, in the individual, you know, we talked about hiring before, like these are the things that I'm looking for.
41:50 And I don't even care, it's not the money. I don't care about the money. This is a very low reimbursing insurance plan. It does not matter. The money is not even gonna, you're not gonna see it on a balance sheet, but it's the fact that the person was there. Why wouldn't I do the evaluation right now? Nobody else in the clinic needed me with them for the next fifteen minutes. I could give them some peace of mind. I can calm her down. I can make her feel a little bit better. Like that is what I wanted to do. And if you're listening to this and you find somebody out there who's a younger person, younger to work and has that kind of perspective, you snatch them up. You pay them whatever they want to get paid and you put them on your team.
42:33 Like those are the things we're looking for. I totally believe that you can train that, Tony. You're almost saying like you think a non-owner. What? I feel like you were kind of suggesting like a non-owner. It's hard for a non-owner to do that. If you put that in your playbook, I totally believe you can train that. My therapist that's been with us just for a little over like around seventy or eighty days, not like approaching his ninetieth day. He's doing twenty visits a week. He's making one hundred thirteen K on pace for one hundred thirteen. Like the paycheck was enough to be one hundred thirteen K when one hundred thirteen K when annualized. Right.
43:13 And he's seeing twenty visits a week. Right. So he but he was selected or he was interviewed and groomed to be doing all this. And he's doing what you're talking about. Maybe not exactly the same because it's some office visits and some home visits, but. I think it's possible. It is possible to find these folks. And I don't think it's just the owner to do it. Of course, that the move that you that is an owner move to do that. But I believe anyone watching and listening like you absolutely could be finding folks, grooming them, training them. It's not going to be like you say it one time and they just do it right. It's going to be like they need repetitions of like, hey, someone comes in, they have a knee replacement. Someone comes in, they got a rotator cuff repair. Someone comes in, they have a balance issue.
43:55 Well, there's no there's no time better than right now right tony like let's do it yeah what's the comment say uh ben saying it's the difference between a restaurant that stays open until the last person leaves versus one that shuts the kitchen at nine because they close at ten have to clean for an hour it's a culture not a not a something you can necessarily teach yeah i agree with that last statement more it's the culture not a teaching amen If you're part of the organization, if you empower someone to sort of be able to make decisions, you'll make better decisions because you understand it's not the letter of the law, it's the spirit of what we're actually here to do.
44:39 And I empower you to do that. I use the Zappos example all the time. They realized that customer service was a big bottleneck and they said, listen, if it costs less than five hundred bucks to solve the problem, just solve the problem. Just understand, I might be like, why did you just give that person a five dollar gift card? It's like I wanted to shut them up. Not a good answer, but it's like they got screwed. The system didn't work for them. So I just credit them back their shoes. Good use of that hall pass or whatever they want to call it. So I agree with Ben. They're saying it is the culture, not something you can't write down an SOP for four billion possibilities. You can't foresee that. You can't write it down and you wouldn't be able to find and say, well, what do we do in this situation?
45:21 No. Do right, fear no man. That's what they're trying to say. Understand that all these different options are within your purview. Pick the best one at the right time. Get close. What other topics do we have? I don't know. I think we blew through all of them for today. Well, Jimmy's coming north of Columbus. Uh, we're going to connect. A lot of these APTA chapters are turning seventy-five and doing celebrations. So it's like a one day conference and then they're throwing a big old party. So you're, so if you're traveling, you're going to be here Thursday or are you traveling Thursday?
46:04 Traveling Thursday. I'll be there Thursday night. Okay. So Jimmy's out. I will see if I can connect with Dave for PT Breakfast Club Thursday morning. I should be able to do that. Let's just do parting shots. We don't have to go the full hour. Dave, what's on your mind? What do you got? Well, I really like the comment from Ben about culture and not necessarily a teaching thing for every aspect. So that's just on my mind right now, trying to recruit more therapists. And keeping, keeping like the, the, the, the main thing, the main thing in terms of what's best for the client, what's best for the practice, what's, you know, what is that intersection?
46:46 And of course it doesn't matter what type of practice you're in, but if they stop in physically to say hello or book visits, yeah. Why, why wouldn't you say, Hey, why don't we just do a quick screen, a quick eval, you know, get them going. I just, for me, it's a great reminder. And that's something that you could always put more stuff into your playbooks around what to do when, but I love the, I love the reminder of like, it's kind of like the culture and it, you can't lay out every little scenario, but if it's kind of embedded in like the onboarding and the mentorship and the coaching and the training of therapists, then they typically would do the right thing. Right. So like I would, I want to get to the point where if, we have therapists in our office, I'm not there, but they would do what Tony did.
47:31 A patient comes in, previous client, whatever, or like a spouse or a friend of a client, and they come in and they're like looking to, you know, tour the office and look around or whatever. And can that therapist segue them into a quick consult or a vow like that, and then get them going and lay out a plan of care and all that. So like that, again, just culture. And for me right now, recruiting and retaining the team. yeah simple not easy i think i i think it's one of those things where like parent like i'm a parent i look at my kids i'm like did they come this way or did i have any kind of influence on them um i think a lot of it is they came this way and especially i always say like if we had one of the kids first we would think we were brilliant parents and we'd write a book and we'd tell dave how to be a better dad.
48:26 If we had a different kid first, we would be like, oh my gosh, Dave, what do I do? How do I become a better dad? Same with employees. I just think you hire someone, you bring them on the team, they come with raw materials. Yes, some can be influenced. I think it's really a lot easier if they just come that way. If they're the person that's going to pick up the trash, not because it's their job, just because it's trapped on the floor and I need to pick it up. I'll close with this quick story. I had a patient yesterday in the clinic. This patient has been a hairdresser in her seventies, still works, still active, wants to get stronger.
49:09 I had another patient who fell, second patient who fell but didn't fall in my clinic, fell somewhere else. The hairdresser noticed he was bleeding. And so she goes over there, grabs tissues and starts like dabbing blood on his face. I would hire that woman in a second. I don't care how old she is. I don't care what her skill set is. Just the fact that she saw a problem. She saw this guy sitting in a chair, blood dripping down his face that he didn't realize. No concern for pathogens and infection. She just goes and grabs a tissue and starts dabbing his head. That's a person I would hire in a heartbeat.
49:51 So, you know, that's the job interview. Not tell me about a challenging customer you work with. That's useless. Yeah. Show me, don't tell me. And I think to go full circle, we started talking about marketing. You show that off, but from a customer or patient perspective, viewpoint, which is here's what I want or need. Show me that. And then I understand that you're the person who can help me get that show beats tell. I think I'll be back Thursday. I don't think my flight is until late. So we'll see you guys then. All right. See you then.