Jan. 26, 2026

Philip Goldsmith: Why PTs Still Ask for Permission

Philip Goldsmith: Why PTs Still Ask for Permission

Philip Goldsmith, PT, MSPT, EMT, DScPT, is the President of APTA Home Health and a clinical expert in home health care. He joins Jimmy LIVE from APTA Private Practice’s Graham Sessions for a candid conversation on:

  • Why physical therapists aren’t practicing at the top of their license
  • How home health is leading innovation in PT
  • The psychology of “permission-seeking” in our profession
  • A revolutionary CEU opportunity — on a cruise ship
  • What Graham Sessions is (and isn’t) talking about yet
  • The legacy PTs can leave when they own their full scope

???? Learn more about “ACHH at Sea” → https://aptahomehealth.org

Transcript
WEBVTT

00:00:01.050 --> 00:00:01.731
You're listening to the P.T.

00:00:01.750 --> 00:00:02.451
Pinecast,

00:00:02.551 --> 00:00:04.593
where smart people in healthcare come to

00:00:04.633 --> 00:00:05.474
make noise.

00:00:05.854 --> 00:00:10.077
Here's your host, Jimmy McKay.

00:00:10.098 --> 00:00:11.159
Thanks, voiceover guy.

00:00:11.740 --> 00:00:13.201
Phil Goldsmith, welcome to the show.

00:00:13.221 --> 00:00:15.243
Good to be here, thanks.

00:00:15.382 --> 00:00:17.004
How many, what is your gram number?

00:00:17.775 --> 00:00:19.978
How many gram sessions have you been to?

00:00:20.118 --> 00:00:21.841
I think this is number four.

00:00:22.042 --> 00:00:22.263
Yeah?

00:00:22.283 --> 00:00:24.304
It's number three for me.

00:00:24.446 --> 00:00:25.387
Superhero backstory.

00:00:25.426 --> 00:00:26.649
Tell everybody who you are.

00:00:26.689 --> 00:00:28.071
What do you get to do in the

00:00:28.091 --> 00:00:28.611
profession?

00:00:29.132 --> 00:00:31.435
What is your superhero story?

00:00:32.875 --> 00:00:34.517
I can't say it's much of a superhero

00:00:34.536 --> 00:00:34.898
story.

00:00:35.597 --> 00:00:36.779
My name is Phil Goldsmith.

00:00:36.899 --> 00:00:40.381
I've been a PT for twenty six years

00:00:40.421 --> 00:00:41.281
and change.

00:00:41.362 --> 00:00:42.783
That's a superhero story, though.

00:00:42.862 --> 00:00:44.143
You've got a lot of stories in twenty

00:00:44.164 --> 00:00:44.704
six years.

00:00:44.945 --> 00:00:45.786
Oh, they're stories.

00:00:45.886 --> 00:00:46.985
Can't tell most of them.

00:00:47.027 --> 00:00:47.746
That's OK.

00:00:48.046 --> 00:00:48.747
HR's downstairs.

00:00:48.768 --> 00:00:49.148
That's all right.

00:00:49.228 --> 00:00:49.607
Exactly.

00:00:49.707 --> 00:00:50.488
What do you get to do in the

00:00:50.509 --> 00:00:51.130
profession now?

00:00:51.149 --> 00:00:52.511
What corner of the profession do you get

00:00:52.530 --> 00:00:52.990
to occupy?

00:00:53.371 --> 00:00:56.371
So I own a wee little home health

00:00:56.411 --> 00:00:58.893
management consulting company and do a

00:00:58.914 --> 00:00:59.734
little bit of clinical.

00:00:59.793 --> 00:01:01.073
It gets me out of the house and

00:01:01.795 --> 00:01:03.595
talking with other adults.

00:01:03.636 --> 00:01:04.415
So that's a good thing.

00:01:04.615 --> 00:01:04.835
Yeah.

00:01:04.896 --> 00:01:06.037
And then how about with an APTA?

00:01:06.316 --> 00:01:08.977
I am the president of APTA Home Health.

00:01:09.138 --> 00:01:09.498
Nice.

00:01:09.858 --> 00:01:10.879
Second term there.

00:01:11.978 --> 00:01:13.700
Right now that carries with it also the

00:01:13.780 --> 00:01:15.501
title of chief delegate for the academy.

00:01:16.700 --> 00:01:18.421
So you get to be involved.

00:01:18.682 --> 00:01:19.923
You understand what's coming down the

00:01:19.942 --> 00:01:21.362
line, the rules and the regs,

00:01:21.382 --> 00:01:22.403
and you get to weigh in on those

00:01:22.424 --> 00:01:22.664
things.

00:01:23.097 --> 00:01:26.519
I would like to think so.

00:01:26.679 --> 00:01:29.519
It hits a little hard and heavy sometimes

00:01:29.579 --> 00:01:31.519
and takes me a minute to get caught

00:01:31.599 --> 00:01:32.740
up, but yeah.

00:01:32.941 --> 00:01:35.081
Nice.

00:01:35.120 --> 00:01:37.561
So some big picture questions I'm asking.

00:01:37.621 --> 00:01:38.882
This is your fourth Graham Sessions.

00:01:39.242 --> 00:01:41.043
What's something you've either heard in

00:01:41.082 --> 00:01:44.203
the room or saw on the schedule that

00:01:44.224 --> 00:01:46.103
we're going to talk about later today that

00:01:46.164 --> 00:01:48.325
really excited you because you want to

00:01:48.364 --> 00:01:49.584
hear what people are thinking about?

00:01:49.644 --> 00:01:51.665
We'll start with topics and ideas.

00:01:51.686 --> 00:01:52.266
What do you like?

00:01:53.280 --> 00:01:55.121
I love the primary care discussion this

00:01:55.141 --> 00:01:55.281
morning.

00:01:55.322 --> 00:01:55.561
Good.

00:01:55.882 --> 00:01:56.784
So talk about the idea,

00:01:56.823 --> 00:01:57.424
not who said it.

00:01:57.504 --> 00:01:58.745
We'll leave names out of it.

00:01:58.786 --> 00:02:00.727
But what was that discussion about primary

00:02:00.748 --> 00:02:00.947
care?

00:02:01.668 --> 00:02:03.650
What did you hear?

00:02:03.671 --> 00:02:05.552
I think that the take home is that

00:02:06.313 --> 00:02:07.515
we all should be doing it.

00:02:09.056 --> 00:02:11.078
And we're all capable of doing it.

00:02:12.919 --> 00:02:13.480
But why aren't we?

00:02:17.793 --> 00:02:18.954
That's an easy question and a hard

00:02:18.993 --> 00:02:20.133
question all at the same time.

00:02:20.153 --> 00:02:20.954
That's why I look smart.

00:02:20.973 --> 00:02:21.754
I just asked the question.

00:02:21.775 --> 00:02:23.375
You got the harder job to answer.

00:02:23.935 --> 00:02:24.835
Is it permission?

00:02:25.376 --> 00:02:27.756
Are we waiting for someone else to do

00:02:27.855 --> 00:02:27.955
it?

00:02:28.015 --> 00:02:28.415
What is it?

00:02:28.436 --> 00:02:29.657
Is it waiting for permission?

00:02:31.497 --> 00:02:32.777
I think there's some people in the

00:02:32.818 --> 00:02:33.997
profession that are looking for

00:02:34.078 --> 00:02:34.717
permission.

00:02:35.358 --> 00:02:38.058
I think there's people in the profession

00:02:38.778 --> 00:02:42.580
that don't know how high top of license

00:02:42.621 --> 00:02:43.320
really is.

00:02:45.568 --> 00:02:46.549
And until they see it,

00:02:46.688 --> 00:02:48.069
or until someone's doing it in their own

00:02:48.090 --> 00:02:48.971
backyard, they just...

00:02:49.771 --> 00:02:51.052
Until they have to do it to keep

00:02:51.133 --> 00:02:51.614
up with the Joneses.

00:02:51.633 --> 00:02:52.955
You have to do it, you don't, yeah.

00:02:53.635 --> 00:02:56.899
What's something that is not on the docket

00:02:57.780 --> 00:02:58.540
that you're like, dude,

00:02:58.600 --> 00:02:59.542
why aren't we talking about this?

00:03:00.242 --> 00:03:01.463
What's something that's missing here?

00:03:01.503 --> 00:03:02.564
We couldn't put everything in grammar

00:03:02.585 --> 00:03:03.825
sessions, but what are you like, yes,

00:03:03.866 --> 00:03:05.889
this needs to be... Why wasn't this?

00:03:05.929 --> 00:03:06.990
This is hot.

00:03:07.069 --> 00:03:08.091
Why isn't this on the docket?

00:03:10.468 --> 00:03:11.808
They do a pretty good, I mean,

00:03:11.968 --> 00:03:13.530
all of the issues that I'd love to

00:03:13.569 --> 00:03:17.390
talk about are post-acute issues that I

00:03:17.431 --> 00:03:19.252
wouldn't expect this group to be

00:03:19.331 --> 00:03:20.092
interested in.

00:03:20.891 --> 00:03:21.331
I mean,

00:03:21.632 --> 00:03:24.733
they're hitting it pretty hard from the

00:03:24.812 --> 00:03:26.913
pivots that we've all had to make

00:03:26.973 --> 00:03:29.313
organizationally in the past year.

00:03:30.335 --> 00:03:32.314
Primary care PT is a big one.

00:03:34.515 --> 00:03:37.497
The differing generations, it's all there.

00:03:37.796 --> 00:03:37.977
Yeah.

00:03:38.594 --> 00:03:38.814
I mean,

00:03:39.175 --> 00:03:42.538
if you want to come hang and talk

00:03:42.557 --> 00:03:44.239
about those, and really,

00:03:45.580 --> 00:03:46.760
this is a safe space.

00:03:46.781 --> 00:03:48.081
There's no repercussions.

00:03:48.502 --> 00:03:49.703
This is the place to be.

00:03:50.582 --> 00:03:51.623
This is the hang.

00:03:51.663 --> 00:03:52.284
This is the hang.

00:03:52.844 --> 00:03:54.406
Fast forward to the hang next year.

00:03:55.067 --> 00:03:57.587
You get to pick one of the sessions.

00:03:57.668 --> 00:03:59.949
You get to title it, just the topic,

00:03:59.990 --> 00:04:00.569
the idea.

00:04:00.871 --> 00:04:02.872
What do you put on the docket for

00:04:02.912 --> 00:04:03.973
Graham Sessions next year?

00:04:04.752 --> 00:04:05.514
Look into the future.

00:04:08.399 --> 00:04:09.919
I want to go deeper into why we're

00:04:09.960 --> 00:04:11.080
not top of license.

00:04:11.199 --> 00:04:11.599
Okay.

00:04:11.659 --> 00:04:12.480
Why aren't we there?

00:04:12.520 --> 00:04:14.181
Why are we looking for permission?

00:04:15.080 --> 00:04:16.322
What type of person,

00:04:16.382 --> 00:04:17.882
person or people would you put on the

00:04:17.922 --> 00:04:18.302
panel?

00:04:18.322 --> 00:04:20.663
You don't have to name a person,

00:04:20.682 --> 00:04:22.124
but like what type of person are they

00:04:22.223 --> 00:04:23.845
all from within PT or do you go

00:04:23.904 --> 00:04:24.345
outside?

00:04:24.365 --> 00:04:25.225
Do you put a couple of people on

00:04:25.245 --> 00:04:25.584
the panel?

00:04:27.165 --> 00:04:29.766
I want somebody within the profession

00:04:30.247 --> 00:04:32.728
who's not doing primary care,

00:04:33.307 --> 00:04:35.968
who's not practicing top of license and,

00:04:38.057 --> 00:04:39.098
I guess it would be a little bit

00:04:39.137 --> 00:04:39.978
like an intervention.

00:04:40.678 --> 00:04:41.059
Ooh,

00:04:42.338 --> 00:04:45.079
that is a very Graham session way of

00:04:45.120 --> 00:04:46.440
looking at, can we,

00:04:46.781 --> 00:04:49.961
can we do an intervention for ourselves on

00:04:50.041 --> 00:04:51.601
why are we avoiding this problem?

00:04:51.641 --> 00:04:52.422
You have a problem.

00:04:52.701 --> 00:04:53.702
This is an intervention.

00:04:55.562 --> 00:04:56.524
It's a good way of looking at it.

00:04:57.363 --> 00:04:57.423
Uh,

00:04:57.524 --> 00:04:59.004
when were your first couple of Graham

00:04:59.024 --> 00:05:01.225
sessions about how long ago ballpark?

00:05:02.694 --> 00:05:04.675
five six years i've skipped a couple

00:05:04.696 --> 00:05:07.379
that's okay that's good what's something

00:05:08.019 --> 00:05:10.502
that actually you saw change it was

00:05:10.543 --> 00:05:12.745
disgusting gram sessions five or six years

00:05:12.766 --> 00:05:14.348
that's almost long enough for change right

00:05:14.749 --> 00:05:16.269
that act that you're like yeah that was

00:05:16.310 --> 00:05:18.572
cool we brought it up we did something

00:05:18.612 --> 00:05:20.656
about it any do you remember those things

00:05:21.516 --> 00:05:23.297
I think there's a more prevalence of

00:05:23.336 --> 00:05:24.517
cash-based practices.

00:05:24.798 --> 00:05:25.658
Yeah, in five or six years?

00:05:25.718 --> 00:05:26.519
Yeah.

00:05:26.538 --> 00:05:30.120
That's probably the big one.

00:05:30.141 --> 00:05:30.221
Yeah.

00:05:30.240 --> 00:05:31.762
I think people are finally starting to

00:05:31.862 --> 00:05:36.584
understand that we do have and have ways

00:05:36.624 --> 00:05:38.646
to access negotiating power with these

00:05:38.665 --> 00:05:39.326
insurance companies.

00:05:39.346 --> 00:05:39.425
Yeah,

00:05:39.466 --> 00:05:40.846
that was one conversation from earlier

00:05:40.867 --> 00:05:41.166
today,

00:05:41.247 --> 00:05:42.887
which that's been repeated several times.

00:05:43.528 --> 00:05:44.588
How are your C-legs?

00:05:46.137 --> 00:05:48.538
My sea legs are in good shape, man.

00:05:48.598 --> 00:05:49.500
Are you trying to get them in better

00:05:49.540 --> 00:05:50.220
shape for this summer?

00:05:50.439 --> 00:05:51.120
Oh, yeah.

00:05:51.180 --> 00:05:51.360
All right.

00:05:51.380 --> 00:05:51.940
Talk about that.

00:05:51.980 --> 00:05:52.882
You're doing something,

00:05:52.901 --> 00:05:54.562
and I hope Tony Maritato eventually is

00:05:54.601 --> 00:05:54.942
listening.

00:05:55.622 --> 00:05:57.144
We talked about this idea.

00:05:57.343 --> 00:05:58.704
I've seen people advertise it.

00:05:59.404 --> 00:06:00.985
Florida PTA has done it for a while.

00:06:01.005 --> 00:06:02.045
They've done it for their spring

00:06:02.086 --> 00:06:02.726
conference a few times.

00:06:02.747 --> 00:06:03.146
Of course they will.

00:06:03.166 --> 00:06:03.786
They're Florida.

00:06:03.846 --> 00:06:04.067
Right.

00:06:04.086 --> 00:06:04.827
Of course they will.

00:06:04.867 --> 00:06:08.350
So APTA Home Health decided to do

00:06:08.410 --> 00:06:09.550
something a little crazy,

00:06:10.350 --> 00:06:12.752
and we're doing ACHH at sea.

00:06:13.266 --> 00:06:14.627
A-C-A-H.

00:06:14.666 --> 00:06:16.528
Advanced Competency and Home Health.

00:06:17.550 --> 00:06:20.091
Our live portion of that is a sixteen

00:06:20.151 --> 00:06:23.814
hour live hands-on continuing education.

00:06:24.814 --> 00:06:26.175
We're an APTA component,

00:06:26.196 --> 00:06:27.838
so it's automatically approved in,

00:06:27.937 --> 00:06:29.499
I think, forty-four states.

00:06:29.639 --> 00:06:30.100
Nice.

00:06:30.199 --> 00:06:32.461
And we are approvers for, I think,

00:06:32.601 --> 00:06:34.142
all but two states.

00:06:34.802 --> 00:06:37.946
So, Eight Night Cruise, Royal Caribbean,

00:06:37.985 --> 00:06:38.927
Symphony of the Seas.

00:06:38.947 --> 00:06:39.206
Yeah.

00:06:40.987 --> 00:06:43.528
On the four C days, it's eight a.m.

00:06:43.569 --> 00:06:44.790
to noon, you're in class.

00:06:44.990 --> 00:06:46.250
The rest of the time,

00:06:46.310 --> 00:06:48.451
it's all you and your family or whoever

00:06:48.511 --> 00:06:49.552
else you want to bring with you to

00:06:49.591 --> 00:06:49.911
hang.

00:06:50.331 --> 00:06:52.492
So you're doing CEUs at sea?

00:06:52.632 --> 00:06:52.992
Yes.

00:06:54.213 --> 00:06:54.913
We were talking about this.

00:06:54.934 --> 00:06:55.574
Why wouldn't you?

00:06:55.613 --> 00:06:57.875
Why wouldn't you, right?

00:06:58.074 --> 00:06:59.615
And where do people go for that

00:06:59.636 --> 00:07:00.675
information if they're like,

00:07:00.716 --> 00:07:01.415
I want to be on board?

00:07:02.396 --> 00:07:05.458
You go to aptahomehealth.org and it's on

00:07:05.497 --> 00:07:06.137
our website.

00:07:06.237 --> 00:07:06.718
Perfect.

00:07:06.737 --> 00:07:07.579
All right.

00:07:07.678 --> 00:07:07.858
And then...

00:07:09.141 --> 00:07:09.581
When is it?

00:07:09.882 --> 00:07:12.002
It is August first through ninth,

00:07:12.122 --> 00:07:13.204
twenty twenty six.

00:07:13.423 --> 00:07:14.204
So you got this summer.

00:07:14.225 --> 00:07:15.846
You got you got a few months,

00:07:16.026 --> 00:07:17.346
got a couple of time and then ballpark

00:07:17.367 --> 00:07:17.846
of a price.

00:07:17.987 --> 00:07:19.048
Like what's someone that's the first

00:07:19.067 --> 00:07:19.708
question they're going to ask?

00:07:19.767 --> 00:07:23.211
The course is a little under five hundred

00:07:23.250 --> 00:07:25.172
dollars for academy members,

00:07:25.713 --> 00:07:26.853
for non-members.

00:07:26.913 --> 00:07:28.754
It's it's a little more expensive.

00:07:29.394 --> 00:07:30.336
I'll give you a hint.

00:07:30.636 --> 00:07:32.278
It's cheaper to be a member and pay

00:07:32.298 --> 00:07:33.639
the member price than it is to pay

00:07:33.658 --> 00:07:34.620
the non-member price.

00:07:35.199 --> 00:07:38.163
The cruise for an ocean view cabin is

00:07:38.262 --> 00:07:40.644
sixteen hundred ish dollars per person

00:07:40.685 --> 00:07:42.026
based on double occupancy.

00:07:42.726 --> 00:07:43.747
If you're flying solo,

00:07:43.788 --> 00:07:45.389
you're probably going to pay double that.

00:07:45.588 --> 00:07:48.569
yeah uh so smart people are already doing

00:07:48.589 --> 00:07:50.271
the math they're like how do i use

00:07:50.310 --> 00:07:52.351
these ceu dollars my employer has been

00:07:52.391 --> 00:07:54.512
promising me to get on the boat with

00:07:54.552 --> 00:07:57.093
phil smart that would that would be the

00:07:57.113 --> 00:07:59.254
good play that is a smart play where

00:07:59.274 --> 00:08:01.035
if you're smart and made yourself a little

00:08:01.274 --> 00:08:03.776
llc it's a business expense baby smart man

00:08:04.237 --> 00:08:06.216
um jimmy's already thinking can i live

00:08:06.237 --> 00:08:08.077
stream from the boat just i need a

00:08:08.117 --> 00:08:10.559
wi-fi signal we could we can get that

00:08:10.579 --> 00:08:12.339
i'll be at the cabana uh we have

00:08:12.360 --> 00:08:14.161
a tradition on the show the tradition is

00:08:14.201 --> 00:08:15.000
called the parting shot

00:08:16.891 --> 00:08:18.031
This is The Parting Shot.

00:08:18.591 --> 00:08:19.973
One last mic drop moment.

00:08:20.673 --> 00:08:21.473
No pressure.

00:08:21.915 --> 00:08:24.055
Just your legacy on the line.

00:08:25.257 --> 00:08:26.177
No pressure, Phil.

00:08:26.218 --> 00:08:27.999
Just your entire legacy on the line.

00:08:28.038 --> 00:08:29.439
But what's one thing you'd want to leave

00:08:29.480 --> 00:08:30.141
as we wrap up?

00:08:30.161 --> 00:08:32.363
What's the last idea, concept, quote,

00:08:32.423 --> 00:08:32.743
anything?

00:08:32.863 --> 00:08:33.703
Anything you'd want to leave with the

00:08:33.724 --> 00:08:33.903
audience?

00:08:34.940 --> 00:08:36.360
Top of scope is real.

00:08:36.821 --> 00:08:38.701
The good news is in home health,

00:08:39.101 --> 00:08:40.982
we've been doing it for twenty five years.

00:08:42.484 --> 00:08:43.225
Good for you, Phil.

00:08:43.524 --> 00:08:44.565
Appreciate this.

00:08:45.166 --> 00:08:46.025
We'll see if we can get you on

00:08:46.066 --> 00:08:46.666
the sea, man.

00:08:46.785 --> 00:08:47.866
Appreciate the time here at Graham

00:08:47.907 --> 00:08:48.206
Sessions.

00:08:48.226 --> 00:08:48.748
Awesome.

00:08:48.807 --> 00:08:49.207
Thank you.

00:08:50.559 --> 00:08:51.639
That's it for this one,

00:08:51.900 --> 00:08:53.561
but we're just getting warmed up.

00:08:54.042 --> 00:08:55.942
Smash follow, send it to a friend,

00:08:56.162 --> 00:08:57.822
or crank up the next episode.

00:08:58.342 --> 00:08:59.224
Want to go deeper?

00:08:59.703 --> 00:09:01.865
Hit us at pgpinecast.com.

00:09:03.105 --> 00:09:05.086
Or find us on YouTube and socials at

00:09:05.105 --> 00:09:06.366
pgpinecast.

00:09:06.767 --> 00:09:09.048
And legally, none of this was advice.

00:09:09.128 --> 00:09:10.889
It's for entertainment purposes only.

00:09:11.509 --> 00:09:12.509
Bullshit!

00:09:12.529 --> 00:09:13.110
See, Keith?

00:09:13.309 --> 00:09:14.389
We read the script.

00:09:14.691 --> 00:09:15.331
Happy now?