Feb. 17, 2026
It’s Okay to Be a Generalist
From CSM 2026 in Anaheim, Jimmy sits down with Ben Lindaman to discuss one of the biggest identity tensions in physical therapy:
Generalist vs. Specialist.
Healthcare rewards depth.
Marketing rewards niche positioning.
But patient care often demands integration.
Ben argues that:
- Early over-specialization can stunt development
- Generalist thinking is critical in rural and primary care settings
- Most patients don’t need hyper-specialization
- Confidence and competence matter more than credentials
- PT’s versatility is both a strength and communication challenge
If you’ve ever felt pressure to define your niche immediately — this episode is for you.
???? Key Takeaways
- Specialization has value — but so does breadth
- Young clinicians should explore before committing
- Value-based care demands better triage and integration
- Rural PTs must be adaptable generalists
- Clinical identity should be internally driven, not externally pressured
???? Guest
Ben Lindaman, PT, DPT
Assistant Professor, Tufts University
PRN Clinician, Philadelphia
???? Benton.Lindaman@tufts.edu
Social: @ben10dpt
Recommended Book: Range by David Epstein
???? Sponsors
Supported by:
SaRA Health
EMPOWER EMR
U.S. Physical Therapy
Transcript
WEBVTT
00:00:00.009 --> 00:00:01.129
She's like, I'm in bed.
00:00:01.909 --> 00:00:03.871
The best conversations happen at happy
00:00:03.911 --> 00:00:04.152
hour.
00:00:05.091 --> 00:00:06.373
Welcome to ours.
00:00:06.512 --> 00:00:07.253
Welcome aboard.
00:00:07.333 --> 00:00:09.015
This is the PT podcast.
00:00:09.175 --> 00:00:11.455
Here's your host, physical therapist,
00:00:11.717 --> 00:00:12.696
Jimmy McKay.
00:00:12.756 --> 00:00:13.256
Good timing.
00:00:13.317 --> 00:00:14.458
Live from CSM.
00:00:14.978 --> 00:00:16.440
Twenty twenty six here in Anaheim.
00:00:18.240 --> 00:00:19.861
Want to say thanks to Empower EMR.
00:00:21.158 --> 00:00:22.760
If your clinic is stuck with an EMR
00:00:22.940 --> 00:00:23.760
that's slowing you down,
00:00:23.821 --> 00:00:24.963
that's your choice.
00:00:25.504 --> 00:00:26.565
That's your choice.
00:00:26.785 --> 00:00:27.545
You chose that.
00:00:27.686 --> 00:00:28.968
You can also choose a way out.
00:00:29.969 --> 00:00:31.591
Designed for PTs.
00:00:31.751 --> 00:00:33.213
Better notes, faster documentation,
00:00:33.273 --> 00:00:34.414
smoother operations.
00:00:34.435 --> 00:00:36.698
I always yell, smooth operator,
00:00:36.857 --> 00:00:37.418
whenever I say that.
00:00:37.859 --> 00:00:39.219
All wrapped up in customer support doesn't
00:00:39.259 --> 00:00:39.640
ghost you.
00:00:39.700 --> 00:00:41.621
Upgrade your clinic's brain with Empower
00:00:41.722 --> 00:00:42.061
EMR.
00:00:42.082 --> 00:00:45.344
Visit empoweremr.com.
00:00:45.384 --> 00:00:46.826
In a profession obsessed with
00:00:46.886 --> 00:00:47.707
specialization,
00:00:48.286 --> 00:00:49.508
our next guest is here to make the
00:00:49.548 --> 00:00:52.109
case that being a generalist isn't a
00:00:52.149 --> 00:00:53.871
weakness, it's preparation.
00:00:54.752 --> 00:00:56.552
Ben Lindeman, welcome to the show.
00:00:56.853 --> 00:00:57.374
Thanks for having me.
00:00:57.393 --> 00:00:57.753
Appreciate it.
00:00:57.774 --> 00:00:58.475
Where are you from, man?
00:00:58.494 --> 00:01:00.055
I live in Philadelphia.
00:01:00.356 --> 00:01:02.317
nice yep right now where this little
00:01:02.417 --> 00:01:04.659
shindig will be next year yeah yeah i'm
00:01:04.698 --> 00:01:06.060
right down smack down the middle of the
00:01:06.099 --> 00:01:07.501
city in the convention are you from pa
00:01:07.561 --> 00:01:09.783
uh born and raised in iowa but then
00:01:09.822 --> 00:01:11.584
moved out to pa for grad school and
00:01:11.605 --> 00:01:13.585
then just never left fantastic all right
00:01:13.626 --> 00:01:15.828
so uh there was an oxford debate a
00:01:15.847 --> 00:01:17.549
couple years ago at generalization versus
00:01:17.688 --> 00:01:20.251
specialist uh it was very interesting as
00:01:20.411 --> 00:01:22.212
oxford debates which should be brought
00:01:22.233 --> 00:01:23.793
back to the apta that's a hill i
00:01:23.813 --> 00:01:25.355
will die on and i'll keep pitching about
00:01:25.394 --> 00:01:28.076
until it gets brought back um and it
00:01:28.096 --> 00:01:30.239
was interesting to hear both sides yeah
00:01:30.539 --> 00:01:32.540
We like chasing things like titles and
00:01:32.581 --> 00:01:33.501
specializations.
00:01:33.542 --> 00:01:34.522
It is neither good nor bad.
00:01:34.542 --> 00:01:35.143
It just is.
00:01:35.602 --> 00:01:39.305
So why do PTs feel pressure to sort
00:01:39.346 --> 00:01:40.927
of specialize or do these things?
00:01:41.328 --> 00:01:41.688
I don't know.
00:01:41.727 --> 00:01:42.688
I think it's a couple things.
00:01:42.748 --> 00:01:43.790
I think if you, like,
00:01:44.069 --> 00:01:45.911
zoom out and just healthcare in general,
00:01:46.051 --> 00:01:46.292
like...
00:01:47.301 --> 00:01:49.581
physicians like everyone has a specialty
00:01:50.201 --> 00:01:51.641
and I feel like every time I have
00:01:51.701 --> 00:01:53.102
patients they're like yeah I have to go
00:01:53.201 --> 00:01:55.222
see the ortho guy but then he specializes
00:01:55.263 --> 00:01:57.504
in the knee and then it's only the
00:01:57.543 --> 00:01:58.823
right knee but not the left knee and
00:01:58.864 --> 00:02:00.743
I think it's just how our health care
00:02:00.763 --> 00:02:02.564
is designed from a top-down approach and I
00:02:02.584 --> 00:02:05.646
think it's just trickled into PT and
00:02:05.665 --> 00:02:06.885
there's a time and a place like I
00:02:06.906 --> 00:02:08.885
have my neuro specialty I'm not here to
00:02:08.925 --> 00:02:10.887
rag on it but I think just so
00:02:10.967 --> 00:02:12.747
often I hear oh you need to go
00:02:12.787 --> 00:02:14.147
see Ben he's the neuro guy he's the
00:02:14.168 --> 00:02:15.027
neuro guy and I'm like
00:02:16.444 --> 00:02:17.145
People are people.
00:02:17.626 --> 00:02:18.866
You don't necessarily need to have the
00:02:18.907 --> 00:02:20.527
specialization to provide best care for
00:02:20.548 --> 00:02:20.828
them.
00:02:21.688 --> 00:02:23.810
I get people know me because I have
00:02:23.830 --> 00:02:24.450
a podcast.
00:02:24.811 --> 00:02:26.331
And people are like, he's the podcast guy.
00:02:26.391 --> 00:02:27.073
And I'm like, actually,
00:02:27.372 --> 00:02:29.633
I have a degree in communications and
00:02:29.653 --> 00:02:30.134
journalism.
00:02:30.495 --> 00:02:31.876
So I could do words, too.
00:02:32.056 --> 00:02:33.076
Or I could do pictures.
00:02:33.236 --> 00:02:35.057
Or I could do a combination of both.
00:02:36.258 --> 00:02:38.060
So yes, you might be a neuro PT.
00:02:39.221 --> 00:02:41.902
You're still PT and there's a time and
00:02:41.923 --> 00:02:43.604
a place and neither is better or worse.
00:02:43.844 --> 00:02:45.225
But where does that pressure come from?
00:02:45.265 --> 00:02:47.127
Is that is the call coming from inside
00:02:47.146 --> 00:02:47.828
the house?
00:02:48.127 --> 00:02:51.310
I feel like it's like patients like some
00:02:51.471 --> 00:02:53.352
want that specialization because they feel
00:02:53.372 --> 00:02:54.453
that they're going to get better outcomes
00:02:54.473 --> 00:02:55.473
because of it.
00:02:55.514 --> 00:02:56.493
So I think it's a patient
00:02:57.455 --> 00:02:59.436
customer service based marketing thing.
00:02:59.735 --> 00:03:00.355
I'll take credit.
00:03:00.376 --> 00:03:01.217
Yeah.
00:03:01.276 --> 00:03:01.516
Shame.
00:03:01.757 --> 00:03:02.056
Yeah.
00:03:02.157 --> 00:03:04.237
And then I think it's, you know,
00:03:04.277 --> 00:03:06.579
people want to have that identity of like,
00:03:06.800 --> 00:03:08.901
I have this thing that nobody else has
00:03:09.001 --> 00:03:10.161
or very few people have.
00:03:10.181 --> 00:03:12.181
And so then it promotes this level of
00:03:12.222 --> 00:03:13.782
autonomy that you maybe don't have as a
00:03:13.842 --> 00:03:15.044
generalist or in that sense.
00:03:15.084 --> 00:03:15.864
So I think there's
00:03:17.402 --> 00:03:18.604
like talking about in absolutes,
00:03:18.625 --> 00:03:20.268
like it's just patients or just therapists
00:03:20.329 --> 00:03:21.250
or just administration.
00:03:21.330 --> 00:03:21.790
Never is.
00:03:21.951 --> 00:03:22.111
No.
00:03:22.252 --> 00:03:23.373
Yeah.
00:03:23.433 --> 00:03:23.655
But yeah,
00:03:23.735 --> 00:03:24.956
it's just one of those things that it
00:03:24.977 --> 00:03:26.199
was always kind of annoying when I was
00:03:26.219 --> 00:03:27.862
in full-time clinical practice was like,
00:03:28.509 --> 00:03:28.669
You know,
00:03:28.729 --> 00:03:30.050
I would just get all these people like,
00:03:30.129 --> 00:03:31.531
oh, Ben, you're the neuro guy.
00:03:31.550 --> 00:03:32.550
I want you to see this person.
00:03:32.591 --> 00:03:32.811
I'm like,
00:03:32.850 --> 00:03:34.132
did you even do anything with this?
00:03:34.292 --> 00:03:35.611
Like, did you eval them?
00:03:35.632 --> 00:03:36.171
And they're like, well,
00:03:36.211 --> 00:03:38.133
I don't have like you have skills like
00:03:38.173 --> 00:03:41.014
you graduate as a generalist and you like
00:03:41.074 --> 00:03:43.294
very few times I had to like truly
00:03:43.473 --> 00:03:45.555
dig in with my neuro knowledge and like
00:03:45.594 --> 00:03:47.655
to provide care that that probably that
00:03:47.735 --> 00:03:48.575
therapist could have done.
00:03:48.596 --> 00:03:48.936
But I'm like,
00:03:49.235 --> 00:03:51.036
ninety percent of what this person needed
00:03:51.056 --> 00:03:54.076
was just basic attention or a set of
00:03:54.717 --> 00:03:54.997
eyes,
00:03:55.078 --> 00:03:56.277
all those all those different things.
00:03:56.818 --> 00:03:59.240
What do we lose when we undervalue a
00:03:59.319 --> 00:03:59.740
generalist?
00:03:59.819 --> 00:04:00.560
I mean, here's the thing.
00:04:00.621 --> 00:04:01.300
We're at APTA.
00:04:02.201 --> 00:04:03.062
Fifty state chapters.
00:04:03.282 --> 00:04:04.022
Eighteen components.
00:04:04.522 --> 00:04:05.383
None of the components.
00:04:05.524 --> 00:04:06.805
There's pediatrics, geriatrics,
00:04:06.844 --> 00:04:07.465
orthopedic sports.
00:04:07.645 --> 00:04:09.825
There's no academy of generalists.
00:04:09.846 --> 00:04:10.646
I know.
00:04:10.787 --> 00:04:11.927
So maybe it's a little bit of like,
00:04:11.967 --> 00:04:12.989
well, if I don't belong somewhere,
00:04:13.008 --> 00:04:13.628
I don't belong.
00:04:14.789 --> 00:04:16.791
And I think they're trying to probably
00:04:17.653 --> 00:04:19.576
funnel that population into the new
00:04:19.615 --> 00:04:21.677
primary care and specialization stuff.
00:04:21.697 --> 00:04:22.478
Oh, that's a good point.
00:04:22.579 --> 00:04:22.879
Yeah.
00:04:23.901 --> 00:04:26.403
So to me, I view the primary care,
00:04:26.504 --> 00:04:27.144
this is my own thought,
00:04:27.185 --> 00:04:29.528
it's like you're kind of now a specialized
00:04:29.687 --> 00:04:31.209
generalist, if that makes sense.
00:04:31.870 --> 00:04:32.911
Now we're just going in circles.
00:04:32.932 --> 00:04:34.052
Now we're just talking in circles.
00:04:36.314 --> 00:04:36.536
I mean,
00:04:36.576 --> 00:04:39.759
it's just also like I enjoy the variety.
00:04:39.939 --> 00:04:41.920
I enjoy working with people with
00:04:41.940 --> 00:04:42.882
neurological conditions,
00:04:42.922 --> 00:04:44.182
but I love treating my runners.
00:04:44.303 --> 00:04:45.665
I love treating, you know,
00:04:46.105 --> 00:04:47.065
anybody who has a pulse.
00:04:47.105 --> 00:04:48.507
Really, I'm happy to work with them.
00:04:48.867 --> 00:04:49.629
So well said.
00:04:50.269 --> 00:04:52.471
So how does value based care change this
00:04:52.492 --> 00:04:53.372
type of conversation?
00:04:54.874 --> 00:04:55.535
That's a tough one.
00:04:55.694 --> 00:04:56.156
So I think.
00:04:57.880 --> 00:04:58.880
You have to define,
00:04:59.401 --> 00:05:00.982
like how would you define value though?
00:05:01.021 --> 00:05:04.343
Like what does that mean to a payer?
00:05:04.382 --> 00:05:05.903
What does that mean to the consumer?
00:05:07.064 --> 00:05:07.884
What does it mean to me as a
00:05:07.923 --> 00:05:08.483
therapist?
00:05:08.603 --> 00:05:10.925
And probably all answers are different.
00:05:11.165 --> 00:05:12.204
Yeah.
00:05:12.805 --> 00:05:13.365
They have to be.
00:05:13.386 --> 00:05:13.906
They will be.
00:05:13.946 --> 00:05:14.665
They have to be.
00:05:14.766 --> 00:05:16.487
Yeah.
00:05:16.507 --> 00:05:16.826
So I don't know.
00:05:16.846 --> 00:05:18.387
I haven't really given that one too much
00:05:18.447 --> 00:05:18.747
thought.
00:05:18.906 --> 00:05:21.728
But I think it would be kind of
00:05:21.807 --> 00:05:23.908
understanding or triaging or better
00:05:23.949 --> 00:05:25.528
triaging like who is truly going to
00:05:25.548 --> 00:05:27.509
benefit from a specialized individual.
00:05:28.069 --> 00:05:28.990
And I was, before I came on,
00:05:29.031 --> 00:05:30.814
I was like looking into some research and
00:05:30.853 --> 00:05:32.557
there is at least some research to
00:05:32.596 --> 00:05:32.937
support.
00:05:32.978 --> 00:05:33.158
Yeah.
00:05:33.178 --> 00:05:35.762
If you have like F and D or
00:05:35.822 --> 00:05:37.346
something that's really, really niche,
00:05:37.526 --> 00:05:37.846
then yeah,
00:05:37.867 --> 00:05:39.230
you're probably going to be best off with
00:05:39.250 --> 00:05:40.271
somebody who specializes.
00:05:41.298 --> 00:05:42.399
Cause some of this stuff is coming out
00:05:42.439 --> 00:05:43.081
of Australia.
00:05:43.141 --> 00:05:45.622
They're putting a lot more research into
00:05:45.661 --> 00:05:47.504
this idea of generalist versus specialist.
00:05:49.084 --> 00:05:50.285
And they're basically just saying, yeah,
00:05:50.466 --> 00:05:53.387
like you may need a specialist for like
00:05:53.468 --> 00:05:54.608
certain very niche things,
00:05:54.648 --> 00:05:55.928
but probably you don't need it for
00:05:55.949 --> 00:05:56.290
everything.
00:05:56.449 --> 00:05:56.750
Yeah.
00:05:56.769 --> 00:05:58.511
I mean, it's probably like a bell curve.
00:05:58.870 --> 00:05:59.011
Yeah.
00:05:59.031 --> 00:06:01.072
There is an extreme on either side that
00:06:01.112 --> 00:06:01.872
will need it.
00:06:02.033 --> 00:06:03.213
And then there's the middle of the bell
00:06:03.233 --> 00:06:05.276
curve and that's how bell curves work.
00:06:05.475 --> 00:06:06.115
Yeah.
00:06:06.136 --> 00:06:06.516
Crazy.
00:06:06.716 --> 00:06:07.096
It's nuts.
00:06:07.297 --> 00:06:07.476
Yeah.
00:06:07.536 --> 00:06:07.958
Yeah.
00:06:08.317 --> 00:06:08.358
Um,
00:06:10.423 --> 00:06:13.165
Why is generalist thinking critical in
00:06:13.225 --> 00:06:14.627
rural and primary care settings?
00:06:15.127 --> 00:06:16.487
Because you might be the only person
00:06:16.528 --> 00:06:16.928
within
00:06:18.072 --> 00:06:19.473
hundreds of miles or months.
00:06:19.752 --> 00:06:19.932
Yeah.
00:06:19.952 --> 00:06:21.274
The only person in health care.
00:06:21.454 --> 00:06:22.235
Yeah.
00:06:22.314 --> 00:06:24.076
And so having that adaptability in that
00:06:24.136 --> 00:06:27.617
range and that depth of knowledge is
00:06:28.399 --> 00:06:28.858
you're it.
00:06:29.158 --> 00:06:31.300
So because these people may not
00:06:31.341 --> 00:06:33.141
necessarily have specialists with access,
00:06:33.201 --> 00:06:34.002
even with telehealth.
00:06:35.062 --> 00:06:38.485
So having that really strong generalist
00:06:38.545 --> 00:06:42.247
mindset, I think, is what's needed,
00:06:42.267 --> 00:06:43.269
to be honest.
00:06:43.528 --> 00:06:44.870
And so many times it's just
00:06:46.163 --> 00:06:47.285
Yeah.
00:06:47.384 --> 00:06:48.567
I had a patient last week who was
00:06:48.586 --> 00:06:50.389
like, yeah, I went to this physician.
00:06:50.428 --> 00:06:51.250
I went to this physician.
00:06:51.290 --> 00:06:52.211
I went to that physician.
00:06:52.730 --> 00:06:53.732
Now I'm back in PT.
00:06:53.771 --> 00:06:54.372
And I was like,
00:06:54.413 --> 00:06:56.214
you just went to twelve physicians and
00:06:56.254 --> 00:06:57.817
still aren't anywhere near where you need
00:06:57.836 --> 00:06:58.036
to be.
00:06:58.057 --> 00:07:01.420
So, yeah,
00:07:01.480 --> 00:07:04.884
I think generalists are what's needed,
00:07:04.925 --> 00:07:06.065
especially in those settings for sure.
00:07:06.887 --> 00:07:09.569
You can't walk more than ten feet without
00:07:09.588 --> 00:07:11.389
running into a pack of students at CSM.
00:07:11.428 --> 00:07:13.029
Yep.
00:07:13.149 --> 00:07:14.490
It's a constant question from,
00:07:14.771 --> 00:07:15.752
I don't know, second grade.
00:07:15.791 --> 00:07:16.471
What are you going to be when you
00:07:16.492 --> 00:07:16.932
grow up?
00:07:17.012 --> 00:07:18.273
And then you get close to college.
00:07:18.293 --> 00:07:19.252
What are you going to major in?
00:07:19.293 --> 00:07:20.473
And when you're in PT,
00:07:20.494 --> 00:07:21.514
where are you going to practice?
00:07:21.533 --> 00:07:22.855
It's constantly what is next.
00:07:23.055 --> 00:07:23.274
Yeah.
00:07:23.636 --> 00:07:23.875
So...
00:07:26.007 --> 00:07:28.408
how would you speak to a younger clinician
00:07:28.730 --> 00:07:30.911
talking about identity and scope in terms
00:07:30.930 --> 00:07:32.451
of generalists during specialists?
00:07:32.492 --> 00:07:32.791
How would you,
00:07:32.932 --> 00:07:34.572
would you tell them to slow it down?
00:07:34.612 --> 00:07:35.634
Would you tell them to,
00:07:35.653 --> 00:07:36.954
what would you tell them?
00:07:36.994 --> 00:07:39.154
So my path into PT was I graduated
00:07:39.175 --> 00:07:40.656
then went right into a neuro residency.
00:07:41.177 --> 00:07:41.877
And I think that,
00:07:42.358 --> 00:07:44.298
accelerated my thinking in some aspects
00:07:44.338 --> 00:07:46.439
but i think it really put me in
00:07:46.459 --> 00:07:48.019
this kind of pocket of all right this
00:07:48.040 --> 00:07:49.240
is all i'm doing and this is all
00:07:49.261 --> 00:07:51.701
i can do and then once i actually
00:07:51.721 --> 00:07:53.663
got out into practice full time it's like
00:07:53.822 --> 00:07:54.963
i actually kind of like more of the
00:07:55.002 --> 00:07:57.363
generalist thing so i for a younger
00:07:57.384 --> 00:07:59.785
clinician i think you know try it out
00:07:59.824 --> 00:08:01.846
like pt is such a versatile profession
00:08:01.865 --> 00:08:04.548
where you don't have to be a specialist
00:08:04.608 --> 00:08:06.687
like you know a physician going from med
00:08:06.728 --> 00:08:07.689
school to residency
00:08:08.653 --> 00:08:09.213
Um, so like, yeah,
00:08:09.233 --> 00:08:10.432
take the first couple of years,
00:08:10.593 --> 00:08:12.374
like work in a place that's going to
00:08:12.413 --> 00:08:13.774
have lots of variety, right?
00:08:13.814 --> 00:08:14.814
Whether it's an outpatient,
00:08:14.834 --> 00:08:16.295
whether it's impatient, whatever.
00:08:17.194 --> 00:08:17.375
Um,
00:08:17.834 --> 00:08:19.415
and not feel pressured to feel like you
00:08:19.454 --> 00:08:22.055
need to define who you are right when
00:08:22.076 --> 00:08:22.815
you leave PT school.
00:08:22.915 --> 00:08:23.636
Cause I don't think that's,
00:08:23.735 --> 00:08:24.315
it needs to be the case.
00:08:24.355 --> 00:08:26.257
You get one PT license.
00:08:26.416 --> 00:08:26.617
Yeah.
00:08:26.877 --> 00:08:27.456
And, uh,
00:08:27.476 --> 00:08:28.596
when you want to go from piece of
00:08:28.617 --> 00:08:30.298
geriatrics or there's no,
00:08:30.858 --> 00:08:31.937
there's no toll booth.
00:08:32.138 --> 00:08:32.317
Yeah.
00:08:32.357 --> 00:08:33.658
There's no one saying you have to have
00:08:33.697 --> 00:08:34.038
this thing.
00:08:34.057 --> 00:08:36.019
And that's a little, it's, it's awesome.
00:08:36.078 --> 00:08:36.219
Yeah.
00:08:36.938 --> 00:08:38.539
I went from sports outpatient to peds,
00:08:38.559 --> 00:08:39.860
and I was sort of like waiting for
00:08:39.921 --> 00:08:40.221
someone.
00:08:40.400 --> 00:08:41.422
I was looking to get pulled over.
00:08:41.442 --> 00:08:42.481
I was like, where's the cop?
00:08:42.562 --> 00:08:43.602
And they're like, there's no cop.
00:08:43.643 --> 00:08:44.462
You can just do that.
00:08:44.482 --> 00:08:47.424
And that's, I think, part of our strength,
00:08:47.985 --> 00:08:49.306
but also maybe part of our weakness when
00:08:49.326 --> 00:08:51.927
it comes to explaining to people what we
00:08:51.966 --> 00:08:53.967
can do because you're a PT.
00:08:54.587 --> 00:08:55.188
Who do you work with?
00:08:55.208 --> 00:08:56.229
And you're like, okay,
00:08:56.369 --> 00:08:58.190
so I could work with this to this
00:08:58.210 --> 00:08:58.690
to this to this.
00:08:58.730 --> 00:08:59.770
So it is a strength,
00:08:59.791 --> 00:09:02.672
but it's hard to explain a profession to
00:09:02.731 --> 00:09:04.692
people or the many possibilities.
00:09:04.753 --> 00:09:05.114
For sure.
00:09:05.274 --> 00:09:05.734
A hundred percent.
00:09:06.222 --> 00:09:07.423
would you say to a pt who feels
00:09:07.563 --> 00:09:10.645
less than for not specializing how would
00:09:10.666 --> 00:09:11.966
you make them i feel like we need
00:09:11.986 --> 00:09:14.889
like soft music like okay sit down look
00:09:14.928 --> 00:09:18.211
right into my eyes i don't know like
00:09:19.971 --> 00:09:21.452
where is that thought coming from though
00:09:21.592 --> 00:09:23.594
like where who put that in your head
00:09:23.614 --> 00:09:25.355
that you needed to specialize or that you
00:09:25.394 --> 00:09:26.515
need to do that like
00:09:27.769 --> 00:09:29.831
So I would want to tell that person,
00:09:29.850 --> 00:09:29.991
well,
00:09:30.011 --> 00:09:32.114
you need to get new friends because that
00:09:32.134 --> 00:09:34.336
thought didn't come from just organically
00:09:34.375 --> 00:09:34.836
probably.
00:09:35.037 --> 00:09:37.219
But I think you then just go back
00:09:37.259 --> 00:09:39.321
to your patient outcomes.
00:09:39.360 --> 00:09:40.922
Are your patients getting better even if
00:09:40.942 --> 00:09:41.942
you're not a specialization?
00:09:42.083 --> 00:09:43.164
Do you like doing this?
00:09:43.245 --> 00:09:43.585
Yeah.
00:09:43.644 --> 00:09:45.346
And then is this satisfying to you?
00:09:45.407 --> 00:09:47.629
If you hate neuro and want to be
00:09:47.649 --> 00:09:49.331
a neuro specialist, then that's on you.
00:09:49.451 --> 00:09:50.211
Yeah.
00:09:51.077 --> 00:09:51.458
Yeah,
00:09:51.479 --> 00:09:53.301
I think there are people that love
00:09:53.341 --> 00:09:55.143
specialization, and that's their jam,
00:09:55.543 --> 00:09:57.024
and I'm not here to rain on that
00:09:57.044 --> 00:09:57.445
parade.
00:09:58.066 --> 00:10:00.788
But I think it's just my clinical
00:10:00.849 --> 00:10:04.033
observations and just seeing that it just
00:10:04.092 --> 00:10:05.914
organically happens where people get boxed
00:10:05.955 --> 00:10:06.274
into these...
00:10:07.196 --> 00:10:09.616
profiles or demographics.
00:10:09.797 --> 00:10:12.258
And I think it just really then is
00:10:12.778 --> 00:10:14.479
challenging for younger clinicians because
00:10:14.499 --> 00:10:16.198
then people just keep getting triaged.
00:10:16.799 --> 00:10:18.259
And then you never fully develop a skill
00:10:18.299 --> 00:10:20.640
set because younger clinicians would be
00:10:20.660 --> 00:10:21.160
like, oh, Ben,
00:10:21.201 --> 00:10:22.142
I want you to see this person with
00:10:22.162 --> 00:10:22.562
a stroke.
00:10:22.961 --> 00:10:23.501
I'm like, well,
00:10:23.522 --> 00:10:24.903
you can still learn from this person.
00:10:24.962 --> 00:10:26.702
And now you're just really limiting your
00:10:26.722 --> 00:10:28.063
ability to work with all sorts of
00:10:28.083 --> 00:10:29.844
individuals because they get scared or
00:10:29.864 --> 00:10:30.745
they're not confident.
00:10:30.825 --> 00:10:31.245
And I'm like,
00:10:31.705 --> 00:10:33.986
you can still do the basics really well.
00:10:34.327 --> 00:10:34.888
And then, yeah,
00:10:34.927 --> 00:10:36.249
if the patient's not getting better,
00:10:36.308 --> 00:10:38.071
then potentially triage or something like
00:10:38.091 --> 00:10:38.311
me.
00:10:38.350 --> 00:10:38.630
Yeah.
00:10:39.451 --> 00:10:40.852
But so many people just punt the ball
00:10:40.873 --> 00:10:41.354
so quick.
00:10:41.994 --> 00:10:44.356
And I think that's just limiting your
00:10:44.376 --> 00:10:44.616
growth.
00:10:44.636 --> 00:10:45.456
That's internal, right?
00:10:45.477 --> 00:10:46.778
That's our own problem.
00:10:46.859 --> 00:10:47.399
I'm guilty of it.
00:10:47.479 --> 00:10:48.299
That's why I can spot it.
00:10:48.360 --> 00:10:49.140
Guilty of myself.
00:10:49.780 --> 00:10:50.682
I'm not the expert in this.
00:10:51.022 --> 00:10:52.102
But I heard someone smart say,
00:10:53.166 --> 00:10:55.750
most of the time because only the sith
00:10:55.831 --> 00:10:57.573
speaks in absolutes i learned that from uh
00:10:57.693 --> 00:11:00.619
star wars uh most of the time you've
00:11:00.639 --> 00:11:02.461
gotta you don't need to be the world's
00:11:02.562 --> 00:11:02.982
expert
00:11:03.840 --> 00:11:04.159
on anything.
00:11:04.259 --> 00:11:05.341
I've never been the world's expert on
00:11:05.600 --> 00:11:05.941
anything.
00:11:06.501 --> 00:11:07.842
We need you to have enough expertise to
00:11:07.883 --> 00:11:10.764
speak confidently and competently.
00:11:10.784 --> 00:11:13.466
Confidence and competence is sort of the
00:11:13.546 --> 00:11:14.326
ticket you need.
00:11:14.706 --> 00:11:16.408
And then when you realize, hey,
00:11:16.447 --> 00:11:17.788
spending more time with me will probably
00:11:17.808 --> 00:11:18.529
be a disservice,
00:11:18.909 --> 00:11:20.870
that's when you do that power move,
00:11:20.890 --> 00:11:23.793
which is a handoff, when you notice that.
00:11:23.832 --> 00:11:24.874
Last thing we do on an episode,
00:11:24.894 --> 00:11:27.916
we call it the parting shot.
00:11:31.052 --> 00:11:32.192
This is The Parting Shot.
00:11:32.732 --> 00:11:34.413
One last mic drop moment.
00:11:34.813 --> 00:11:35.595
No pressure.
00:11:36.054 --> 00:11:39.297
Just your legacy on the line.
00:11:39.336 --> 00:11:40.317
No pressure whatsoever.
00:11:40.337 --> 00:11:41.359
So you can have your own parting shot,
00:11:41.379 --> 00:11:42.779
or I can give you a parting shot
00:11:42.820 --> 00:11:43.220
prompt.
00:11:44.801 --> 00:11:45.381
Let's do the prompt.
00:11:45.442 --> 00:11:45.802
Prompt.
00:11:46.121 --> 00:11:48.604
What's one mindset shift physical
00:11:48.644 --> 00:11:50.264
therapists need to make about their
00:11:50.325 --> 00:11:51.346
clinical identity?
00:11:51.706 --> 00:11:52.285
That'll be your question.
00:11:52.306 --> 00:11:53.908
What's one mindset shift?
00:11:54.288 --> 00:11:55.668
I feel like you've said it a few
00:11:55.708 --> 00:11:56.208
times.
00:11:56.769 --> 00:11:57.250
Yeah.
00:11:57.309 --> 00:11:58.370
I think you just need to...
00:12:00.985 --> 00:12:02.687
know just eliminate the noise around you
00:12:02.787 --> 00:12:05.429
and like don't be influenced by what your
00:12:05.450 --> 00:12:08.032
boss wants you to do necessarily or what
00:12:08.091 --> 00:12:09.433
other people are doing around you like
00:12:09.793 --> 00:12:12.076
find what you want and make that your
00:12:12.136 --> 00:12:13.717
identity and if you haven't found it keep
00:12:13.738 --> 00:12:16.360
looking yeah yeah and if you need a
00:12:16.400 --> 00:12:18.023
place to look that's good too you don't
00:12:18.043 --> 00:12:19.543
know where to look uh come to an
00:12:19.583 --> 00:12:21.005
event like this yeah and just
00:12:22.096 --> 00:12:24.037
Listen, look, consume,
00:12:24.596 --> 00:12:25.437
figure out what you like,
00:12:25.476 --> 00:12:26.778
and then take bits and parts of your
00:12:26.837 --> 00:12:28.958
favorite things that you see and make your
00:12:28.999 --> 00:12:29.418
own thing.
00:12:29.639 --> 00:12:31.119
I'm a physical therapist radio DJ.
00:12:31.240 --> 00:12:32.440
I literally just made this up.
00:12:32.500 --> 00:12:33.500
You just make things up.
00:12:33.519 --> 00:12:34.181
You're an N of one, right?
00:12:34.201 --> 00:12:35.041
Yeah.
00:12:35.100 --> 00:12:36.442
I would have loved for some help along
00:12:36.461 --> 00:12:37.542
the way or like a guidebook,
00:12:37.601 --> 00:12:39.202
but you can just do things.
00:12:39.363 --> 00:12:39.482
Yeah.
00:12:39.503 --> 00:12:40.363
And that's how things happen.
00:12:40.383 --> 00:12:41.442
Well, and it's part of the growth.
00:12:41.604 --> 00:12:42.283
Like, you know,
00:12:43.144 --> 00:12:45.144
the struggle and making mistakes and
00:12:45.205 --> 00:12:45.904
trying to figure it out,
00:12:45.945 --> 00:12:47.206
like that's part of the journey.
00:12:47.225 --> 00:12:47.385
Yeah.
00:12:48.166 --> 00:12:49.148
what I like about it the most.
00:12:49.168 --> 00:12:50.169
Listen, I'm here for a good time,
00:12:50.190 --> 00:12:50.811
not a long time.
00:12:50.850 --> 00:12:51.071
Ben,
00:12:51.110 --> 00:12:53.755
appreciate the stop by here at APTA CSM.
00:12:53.855 --> 00:12:54.476
Here, in.
00:00:00.009 --> 00:00:01.129
She's like, I'm in bed.
00:00:01.909 --> 00:00:03.871
The best conversations happen at happy
00:00:03.911 --> 00:00:04.152
hour.
00:00:05.091 --> 00:00:06.373
Welcome to ours.
00:00:06.512 --> 00:00:07.253
Welcome aboard.
00:00:07.333 --> 00:00:09.015
This is the PT podcast.
00:00:09.175 --> 00:00:11.455
Here's your host, physical therapist,
00:00:11.717 --> 00:00:12.696
Jimmy McKay.
00:00:12.756 --> 00:00:13.256
Good timing.
00:00:13.317 --> 00:00:14.458
Live from CSM.
00:00:14.978 --> 00:00:16.440
Twenty twenty six here in Anaheim.
00:00:18.240 --> 00:00:19.861
Want to say thanks to Empower EMR.
00:00:21.158 --> 00:00:22.760
If your clinic is stuck with an EMR
00:00:22.940 --> 00:00:23.760
that's slowing you down,
00:00:23.821 --> 00:00:24.963
that's your choice.
00:00:25.504 --> 00:00:26.565
That's your choice.
00:00:26.785 --> 00:00:27.545
You chose that.
00:00:27.686 --> 00:00:28.968
You can also choose a way out.
00:00:29.969 --> 00:00:31.591
Designed for PTs.
00:00:31.751 --> 00:00:33.213
Better notes, faster documentation,
00:00:33.273 --> 00:00:34.414
smoother operations.
00:00:34.435 --> 00:00:36.698
I always yell, smooth operator,
00:00:36.857 --> 00:00:37.418
whenever I say that.
00:00:37.859 --> 00:00:39.219
All wrapped up in customer support doesn't
00:00:39.259 --> 00:00:39.640
ghost you.
00:00:39.700 --> 00:00:41.621
Upgrade your clinic's brain with Empower
00:00:41.722 --> 00:00:42.061
EMR.
00:00:42.082 --> 00:00:45.344
Visit empoweremr.com.
00:00:45.384 --> 00:00:46.826
In a profession obsessed with
00:00:46.886 --> 00:00:47.707
specialization,
00:00:48.286 --> 00:00:49.508
our next guest is here to make the
00:00:49.548 --> 00:00:52.109
case that being a generalist isn't a
00:00:52.149 --> 00:00:53.871
weakness, it's preparation.
00:00:54.752 --> 00:00:56.552
Ben Lindeman, welcome to the show.
00:00:56.853 --> 00:00:57.374
Thanks for having me.
00:00:57.393 --> 00:00:57.753
Appreciate it.
00:00:57.774 --> 00:00:58.475
Where are you from, man?
00:00:58.494 --> 00:01:00.055
I live in Philadelphia.
00:01:00.356 --> 00:01:02.317
nice yep right now where this little
00:01:02.417 --> 00:01:04.659
shindig will be next year yeah yeah i'm
00:01:04.698 --> 00:01:06.060
right down smack down the middle of the
00:01:06.099 --> 00:01:07.501
city in the convention are you from pa
00:01:07.561 --> 00:01:09.783
uh born and raised in iowa but then
00:01:09.822 --> 00:01:11.584
moved out to pa for grad school and
00:01:11.605 --> 00:01:13.585
then just never left fantastic all right
00:01:13.626 --> 00:01:15.828
so uh there was an oxford debate a
00:01:15.847 --> 00:01:17.549
couple years ago at generalization versus
00:01:17.688 --> 00:01:20.251
specialist uh it was very interesting as
00:01:20.411 --> 00:01:22.212
oxford debates which should be brought
00:01:22.233 --> 00:01:23.793
back to the apta that's a hill i
00:01:23.813 --> 00:01:25.355
will die on and i'll keep pitching about
00:01:25.394 --> 00:01:28.076
until it gets brought back um and it
00:01:28.096 --> 00:01:30.239
was interesting to hear both sides yeah
00:01:30.539 --> 00:01:32.540
We like chasing things like titles and
00:01:32.581 --> 00:01:33.501
specializations.
00:01:33.542 --> 00:01:34.522
It is neither good nor bad.
00:01:34.542 --> 00:01:35.143
It just is.
00:01:35.602 --> 00:01:39.305
So why do PTs feel pressure to sort
00:01:39.346 --> 00:01:40.927
of specialize or do these things?
00:01:41.328 --> 00:01:41.688
I don't know.
00:01:41.727 --> 00:01:42.688
I think it's a couple things.
00:01:42.748 --> 00:01:43.790
I think if you, like,
00:01:44.069 --> 00:01:45.911
zoom out and just healthcare in general,
00:01:46.051 --> 00:01:46.292
like...
00:01:47.301 --> 00:01:49.581
physicians like everyone has a specialty
00:01:50.201 --> 00:01:51.641
and I feel like every time I have
00:01:51.701 --> 00:01:53.102
patients they're like yeah I have to go
00:01:53.201 --> 00:01:55.222
see the ortho guy but then he specializes
00:01:55.263 --> 00:01:57.504
in the knee and then it's only the
00:01:57.543 --> 00:01:58.823
right knee but not the left knee and
00:01:58.864 --> 00:02:00.743
I think it's just how our health care
00:02:00.763 --> 00:02:02.564
is designed from a top-down approach and I
00:02:02.584 --> 00:02:05.646
think it's just trickled into PT and
00:02:05.665 --> 00:02:06.885
there's a time and a place like I
00:02:06.906 --> 00:02:08.885
have my neuro specialty I'm not here to
00:02:08.925 --> 00:02:10.887
rag on it but I think just so
00:02:10.967 --> 00:02:12.747
often I hear oh you need to go
00:02:12.787 --> 00:02:14.147
see Ben he's the neuro guy he's the
00:02:14.168 --> 00:02:15.027
neuro guy and I'm like
00:02:16.444 --> 00:02:17.145
People are people.
00:02:17.626 --> 00:02:18.866
You don't necessarily need to have the
00:02:18.907 --> 00:02:20.527
specialization to provide best care for
00:02:20.548 --> 00:02:20.828
them.
00:02:21.688 --> 00:02:23.810
I get people know me because I have
00:02:23.830 --> 00:02:24.450
a podcast.
00:02:24.811 --> 00:02:26.331
And people are like, he's the podcast guy.
00:02:26.391 --> 00:02:27.073
And I'm like, actually,
00:02:27.372 --> 00:02:29.633
I have a degree in communications and
00:02:29.653 --> 00:02:30.134
journalism.
00:02:30.495 --> 00:02:31.876
So I could do words, too.
00:02:32.056 --> 00:02:33.076
Or I could do pictures.
00:02:33.236 --> 00:02:35.057
Or I could do a combination of both.
00:02:36.258 --> 00:02:38.060
So yes, you might be a neuro PT.
00:02:39.221 --> 00:02:41.902
You're still PT and there's a time and
00:02:41.923 --> 00:02:43.604
a place and neither is better or worse.
00:02:43.844 --> 00:02:45.225
But where does that pressure come from?
00:02:45.265 --> 00:02:47.127
Is that is the call coming from inside
00:02:47.146 --> 00:02:47.828
the house?
00:02:48.127 --> 00:02:51.310
I feel like it's like patients like some
00:02:51.471 --> 00:02:53.352
want that specialization because they feel
00:02:53.372 --> 00:02:54.453
that they're going to get better outcomes
00:02:54.473 --> 00:02:55.473
because of it.
00:02:55.514 --> 00:02:56.493
So I think it's a patient
00:02:57.455 --> 00:02:59.436
customer service based marketing thing.
00:02:59.735 --> 00:03:00.355
I'll take credit.
00:03:00.376 --> 00:03:01.217
Yeah.
00:03:01.276 --> 00:03:01.516
Shame.
00:03:01.757 --> 00:03:02.056
Yeah.
00:03:02.157 --> 00:03:04.237
And then I think it's, you know,
00:03:04.277 --> 00:03:06.579
people want to have that identity of like,
00:03:06.800 --> 00:03:08.901
I have this thing that nobody else has
00:03:09.001 --> 00:03:10.161
or very few people have.
00:03:10.181 --> 00:03:12.181
And so then it promotes this level of
00:03:12.222 --> 00:03:13.782
autonomy that you maybe don't have as a
00:03:13.842 --> 00:03:15.044
generalist or in that sense.
00:03:15.084 --> 00:03:15.864
So I think there's
00:03:17.402 --> 00:03:18.604
like talking about in absolutes,
00:03:18.625 --> 00:03:20.268
like it's just patients or just therapists
00:03:20.329 --> 00:03:21.250
or just administration.
00:03:21.330 --> 00:03:21.790
Never is.
00:03:21.951 --> 00:03:22.111
No.
00:03:22.252 --> 00:03:23.373
Yeah.
00:03:23.433 --> 00:03:23.655
But yeah,
00:03:23.735 --> 00:03:24.956
it's just one of those things that it
00:03:24.977 --> 00:03:26.199
was always kind of annoying when I was
00:03:26.219 --> 00:03:27.862
in full-time clinical practice was like,
00:03:28.509 --> 00:03:28.669
You know,
00:03:28.729 --> 00:03:30.050
I would just get all these people like,
00:03:30.129 --> 00:03:31.531
oh, Ben, you're the neuro guy.
00:03:31.550 --> 00:03:32.550
I want you to see this person.
00:03:32.591 --> 00:03:32.811
I'm like,
00:03:32.850 --> 00:03:34.132
did you even do anything with this?
00:03:34.292 --> 00:03:35.611
Like, did you eval them?
00:03:35.632 --> 00:03:36.171
And they're like, well,
00:03:36.211 --> 00:03:38.133
I don't have like you have skills like
00:03:38.173 --> 00:03:41.014
you graduate as a generalist and you like
00:03:41.074 --> 00:03:43.294
very few times I had to like truly
00:03:43.473 --> 00:03:45.555
dig in with my neuro knowledge and like
00:03:45.594 --> 00:03:47.655
to provide care that that probably that
00:03:47.735 --> 00:03:48.575
therapist could have done.
00:03:48.596 --> 00:03:48.936
But I'm like,
00:03:49.235 --> 00:03:51.036
ninety percent of what this person needed
00:03:51.056 --> 00:03:54.076
was just basic attention or a set of
00:03:54.717 --> 00:03:54.997
eyes,
00:03:55.078 --> 00:03:56.277
all those all those different things.
00:03:56.818 --> 00:03:59.240
What do we lose when we undervalue a
00:03:59.319 --> 00:03:59.740
generalist?
00:03:59.819 --> 00:04:00.560
I mean, here's the thing.
00:04:00.621 --> 00:04:01.300
We're at APTA.
00:04:02.201 --> 00:04:03.062
Fifty state chapters.
00:04:03.282 --> 00:04:04.022
Eighteen components.
00:04:04.522 --> 00:04:05.383
None of the components.
00:04:05.524 --> 00:04:06.805
There's pediatrics, geriatrics,
00:04:06.844 --> 00:04:07.465
orthopedic sports.
00:04:07.645 --> 00:04:09.825
There's no academy of generalists.
00:04:09.846 --> 00:04:10.646
I know.
00:04:10.787 --> 00:04:11.927
So maybe it's a little bit of like,
00:04:11.967 --> 00:04:12.989
well, if I don't belong somewhere,
00:04:13.008 --> 00:04:13.628
I don't belong.
00:04:14.789 --> 00:04:16.791
And I think they're trying to probably
00:04:17.653 --> 00:04:19.576
funnel that population into the new
00:04:19.615 --> 00:04:21.677
primary care and specialization stuff.
00:04:21.697 --> 00:04:22.478
Oh, that's a good point.
00:04:22.579 --> 00:04:22.879
Yeah.
00:04:23.901 --> 00:04:26.403
So to me, I view the primary care,
00:04:26.504 --> 00:04:27.144
this is my own thought,
00:04:27.185 --> 00:04:29.528
it's like you're kind of now a specialized
00:04:29.687 --> 00:04:31.209
generalist, if that makes sense.
00:04:31.870 --> 00:04:32.911
Now we're just going in circles.
00:04:32.932 --> 00:04:34.052
Now we're just talking in circles.
00:04:36.314 --> 00:04:36.536
I mean,
00:04:36.576 --> 00:04:39.759
it's just also like I enjoy the variety.
00:04:39.939 --> 00:04:41.920
I enjoy working with people with
00:04:41.940 --> 00:04:42.882
neurological conditions,
00:04:42.922 --> 00:04:44.182
but I love treating my runners.
00:04:44.303 --> 00:04:45.665
I love treating, you know,
00:04:46.105 --> 00:04:47.065
anybody who has a pulse.
00:04:47.105 --> 00:04:48.507
Really, I'm happy to work with them.
00:04:48.867 --> 00:04:49.629
So well said.
00:04:50.269 --> 00:04:52.471
So how does value based care change this
00:04:52.492 --> 00:04:53.372
type of conversation?
00:04:54.874 --> 00:04:55.535
That's a tough one.
00:04:55.694 --> 00:04:56.156
So I think.
00:04:57.880 --> 00:04:58.880
You have to define,
00:04:59.401 --> 00:05:00.982
like how would you define value though?
00:05:01.021 --> 00:05:04.343
Like what does that mean to a payer?
00:05:04.382 --> 00:05:05.903
What does that mean to the consumer?
00:05:07.064 --> 00:05:07.884
What does it mean to me as a
00:05:07.923 --> 00:05:08.483
therapist?
00:05:08.603 --> 00:05:10.925
And probably all answers are different.
00:05:11.165 --> 00:05:12.204
Yeah.
00:05:12.805 --> 00:05:13.365
They have to be.
00:05:13.386 --> 00:05:13.906
They will be.
00:05:13.946 --> 00:05:14.665
They have to be.
00:05:14.766 --> 00:05:16.487
Yeah.
00:05:16.507 --> 00:05:16.826
So I don't know.
00:05:16.846 --> 00:05:18.387
I haven't really given that one too much
00:05:18.447 --> 00:05:18.747
thought.
00:05:18.906 --> 00:05:21.728
But I think it would be kind of
00:05:21.807 --> 00:05:23.908
understanding or triaging or better
00:05:23.949 --> 00:05:25.528
triaging like who is truly going to
00:05:25.548 --> 00:05:27.509
benefit from a specialized individual.
00:05:28.069 --> 00:05:28.990
And I was, before I came on,
00:05:29.031 --> 00:05:30.814
I was like looking into some research and
00:05:30.853 --> 00:05:32.557
there is at least some research to
00:05:32.596 --> 00:05:32.937
support.
00:05:32.978 --> 00:05:33.158
Yeah.
00:05:33.178 --> 00:05:35.762
If you have like F and D or
00:05:35.822 --> 00:05:37.346
something that's really, really niche,
00:05:37.526 --> 00:05:37.846
then yeah,
00:05:37.867 --> 00:05:39.230
you're probably going to be best off with
00:05:39.250 --> 00:05:40.271
somebody who specializes.
00:05:41.298 --> 00:05:42.399
Cause some of this stuff is coming out
00:05:42.439 --> 00:05:43.081
of Australia.
00:05:43.141 --> 00:05:45.622
They're putting a lot more research into
00:05:45.661 --> 00:05:47.504
this idea of generalist versus specialist.
00:05:49.084 --> 00:05:50.285
And they're basically just saying, yeah,
00:05:50.466 --> 00:05:53.387
like you may need a specialist for like
00:05:53.468 --> 00:05:54.608
certain very niche things,
00:05:54.648 --> 00:05:55.928
but probably you don't need it for
00:05:55.949 --> 00:05:56.290
everything.
00:05:56.449 --> 00:05:56.750
Yeah.
00:05:56.769 --> 00:05:58.511
I mean, it's probably like a bell curve.
00:05:58.870 --> 00:05:59.011
Yeah.
00:05:59.031 --> 00:06:01.072
There is an extreme on either side that
00:06:01.112 --> 00:06:01.872
will need it.
00:06:02.033 --> 00:06:03.213
And then there's the middle of the bell
00:06:03.233 --> 00:06:05.276
curve and that's how bell curves work.
00:06:05.475 --> 00:06:06.115
Yeah.
00:06:06.136 --> 00:06:06.516
Crazy.
00:06:06.716 --> 00:06:07.096
It's nuts.
00:06:07.297 --> 00:06:07.476
Yeah.
00:06:07.536 --> 00:06:07.958
Yeah.
00:06:08.317 --> 00:06:08.358
Um,
00:06:10.423 --> 00:06:13.165
Why is generalist thinking critical in
00:06:13.225 --> 00:06:14.627
rural and primary care settings?
00:06:15.127 --> 00:06:16.487
Because you might be the only person
00:06:16.528 --> 00:06:16.928
within
00:06:18.072 --> 00:06:19.473
hundreds of miles or months.
00:06:19.752 --> 00:06:19.932
Yeah.
00:06:19.952 --> 00:06:21.274
The only person in health care.
00:06:21.454 --> 00:06:22.235
Yeah.
00:06:22.314 --> 00:06:24.076
And so having that adaptability in that
00:06:24.136 --> 00:06:27.617
range and that depth of knowledge is
00:06:28.399 --> 00:06:28.858
you're it.
00:06:29.158 --> 00:06:31.300
So because these people may not
00:06:31.341 --> 00:06:33.141
necessarily have specialists with access,
00:06:33.201 --> 00:06:34.002
even with telehealth.
00:06:35.062 --> 00:06:38.485
So having that really strong generalist
00:06:38.545 --> 00:06:42.247
mindset, I think, is what's needed,
00:06:42.267 --> 00:06:43.269
to be honest.
00:06:43.528 --> 00:06:44.870
And so many times it's just
00:06:46.163 --> 00:06:47.285
Yeah.
00:06:47.384 --> 00:06:48.567
I had a patient last week who was
00:06:48.586 --> 00:06:50.389
like, yeah, I went to this physician.
00:06:50.428 --> 00:06:51.250
I went to this physician.
00:06:51.290 --> 00:06:52.211
I went to that physician.
00:06:52.730 --> 00:06:53.732
Now I'm back in PT.
00:06:53.771 --> 00:06:54.372
And I was like,
00:06:54.413 --> 00:06:56.214
you just went to twelve physicians and
00:06:56.254 --> 00:06:57.817
still aren't anywhere near where you need
00:06:57.836 --> 00:06:58.036
to be.
00:06:58.057 --> 00:07:01.420
So, yeah,
00:07:01.480 --> 00:07:04.884
I think generalists are what's needed,
00:07:04.925 --> 00:07:06.065
especially in those settings for sure.
00:07:06.887 --> 00:07:09.569
You can't walk more than ten feet without
00:07:09.588 --> 00:07:11.389
running into a pack of students at CSM.
00:07:11.428 --> 00:07:13.029
Yep.
00:07:13.149 --> 00:07:14.490
It's a constant question from,
00:07:14.771 --> 00:07:15.752
I don't know, second grade.
00:07:15.791 --> 00:07:16.471
What are you going to be when you
00:07:16.492 --> 00:07:16.932
grow up?
00:07:17.012 --> 00:07:18.273
And then you get close to college.
00:07:18.293 --> 00:07:19.252
What are you going to major in?
00:07:19.293 --> 00:07:20.473
And when you're in PT,
00:07:20.494 --> 00:07:21.514
where are you going to practice?
00:07:21.533 --> 00:07:22.855
It's constantly what is next.
00:07:23.055 --> 00:07:23.274
Yeah.
00:07:23.636 --> 00:07:23.875
So...
00:07:26.007 --> 00:07:28.408
how would you speak to a younger clinician
00:07:28.730 --> 00:07:30.911
talking about identity and scope in terms
00:07:30.930 --> 00:07:32.451
of generalists during specialists?
00:07:32.492 --> 00:07:32.791
How would you,
00:07:32.932 --> 00:07:34.572
would you tell them to slow it down?
00:07:34.612 --> 00:07:35.634
Would you tell them to,
00:07:35.653 --> 00:07:36.954
what would you tell them?
00:07:36.994 --> 00:07:39.154
So my path into PT was I graduated
00:07:39.175 --> 00:07:40.656
then went right into a neuro residency.
00:07:41.177 --> 00:07:41.877
And I think that,
00:07:42.358 --> 00:07:44.298
accelerated my thinking in some aspects
00:07:44.338 --> 00:07:46.439
but i think it really put me in
00:07:46.459 --> 00:07:48.019
this kind of pocket of all right this
00:07:48.040 --> 00:07:49.240
is all i'm doing and this is all
00:07:49.261 --> 00:07:51.701
i can do and then once i actually
00:07:51.721 --> 00:07:53.663
got out into practice full time it's like
00:07:53.822 --> 00:07:54.963
i actually kind of like more of the
00:07:55.002 --> 00:07:57.363
generalist thing so i for a younger
00:07:57.384 --> 00:07:59.785
clinician i think you know try it out
00:07:59.824 --> 00:08:01.846
like pt is such a versatile profession
00:08:01.865 --> 00:08:04.548
where you don't have to be a specialist
00:08:04.608 --> 00:08:06.687
like you know a physician going from med
00:08:06.728 --> 00:08:07.689
school to residency
00:08:08.653 --> 00:08:09.213
Um, so like, yeah,
00:08:09.233 --> 00:08:10.432
take the first couple of years,
00:08:10.593 --> 00:08:12.374
like work in a place that's going to
00:08:12.413 --> 00:08:13.774
have lots of variety, right?
00:08:13.814 --> 00:08:14.814
Whether it's an outpatient,
00:08:14.834 --> 00:08:16.295
whether it's impatient, whatever.
00:08:17.194 --> 00:08:17.375
Um,
00:08:17.834 --> 00:08:19.415
and not feel pressured to feel like you
00:08:19.454 --> 00:08:22.055
need to define who you are right when
00:08:22.076 --> 00:08:22.815
you leave PT school.
00:08:22.915 --> 00:08:23.636
Cause I don't think that's,
00:08:23.735 --> 00:08:24.315
it needs to be the case.
00:08:24.355 --> 00:08:26.257
You get one PT license.
00:08:26.416 --> 00:08:26.617
Yeah.
00:08:26.877 --> 00:08:27.456
And, uh,
00:08:27.476 --> 00:08:28.596
when you want to go from piece of
00:08:28.617 --> 00:08:30.298
geriatrics or there's no,
00:08:30.858 --> 00:08:31.937
there's no toll booth.
00:08:32.138 --> 00:08:32.317
Yeah.
00:08:32.357 --> 00:08:33.658
There's no one saying you have to have
00:08:33.697 --> 00:08:34.038
this thing.
00:08:34.057 --> 00:08:36.019
And that's a little, it's, it's awesome.
00:08:36.078 --> 00:08:36.219
Yeah.
00:08:36.938 --> 00:08:38.539
I went from sports outpatient to peds,
00:08:38.559 --> 00:08:39.860
and I was sort of like waiting for
00:08:39.921 --> 00:08:40.221
someone.
00:08:40.400 --> 00:08:41.422
I was looking to get pulled over.
00:08:41.442 --> 00:08:42.481
I was like, where's the cop?
00:08:42.562 --> 00:08:43.602
And they're like, there's no cop.
00:08:43.643 --> 00:08:44.462
You can just do that.
00:08:44.482 --> 00:08:47.424
And that's, I think, part of our strength,
00:08:47.985 --> 00:08:49.306
but also maybe part of our weakness when
00:08:49.326 --> 00:08:51.927
it comes to explaining to people what we
00:08:51.966 --> 00:08:53.967
can do because you're a PT.
00:08:54.587 --> 00:08:55.188
Who do you work with?
00:08:55.208 --> 00:08:56.229
And you're like, okay,
00:08:56.369 --> 00:08:58.190
so I could work with this to this
00:08:58.210 --> 00:08:58.690
to this to this.
00:08:58.730 --> 00:08:59.770
So it is a strength,
00:08:59.791 --> 00:09:02.672
but it's hard to explain a profession to
00:09:02.731 --> 00:09:04.692
people or the many possibilities.
00:09:04.753 --> 00:09:05.114
For sure.
00:09:05.274 --> 00:09:05.734
A hundred percent.
00:09:06.222 --> 00:09:07.423
would you say to a pt who feels
00:09:07.563 --> 00:09:10.645
less than for not specializing how would
00:09:10.666 --> 00:09:11.966
you make them i feel like we need
00:09:11.986 --> 00:09:14.889
like soft music like okay sit down look
00:09:14.928 --> 00:09:18.211
right into my eyes i don't know like
00:09:19.971 --> 00:09:21.452
where is that thought coming from though
00:09:21.592 --> 00:09:23.594
like where who put that in your head
00:09:23.614 --> 00:09:25.355
that you needed to specialize or that you
00:09:25.394 --> 00:09:26.515
need to do that like
00:09:27.769 --> 00:09:29.831
So I would want to tell that person,
00:09:29.850 --> 00:09:29.991
well,
00:09:30.011 --> 00:09:32.114
you need to get new friends because that
00:09:32.134 --> 00:09:34.336
thought didn't come from just organically
00:09:34.375 --> 00:09:34.836
probably.
00:09:35.037 --> 00:09:37.219
But I think you then just go back
00:09:37.259 --> 00:09:39.321
to your patient outcomes.
00:09:39.360 --> 00:09:40.922
Are your patients getting better even if
00:09:40.942 --> 00:09:41.942
you're not a specialization?
00:09:42.083 --> 00:09:43.164
Do you like doing this?
00:09:43.245 --> 00:09:43.585
Yeah.
00:09:43.644 --> 00:09:45.346
And then is this satisfying to you?
00:09:45.407 --> 00:09:47.629
If you hate neuro and want to be
00:09:47.649 --> 00:09:49.331
a neuro specialist, then that's on you.
00:09:49.451 --> 00:09:50.211
Yeah.
00:09:51.077 --> 00:09:51.458
Yeah,
00:09:51.479 --> 00:09:53.301
I think there are people that love
00:09:53.341 --> 00:09:55.143
specialization, and that's their jam,
00:09:55.543 --> 00:09:57.024
and I'm not here to rain on that
00:09:57.044 --> 00:09:57.445
parade.
00:09:58.066 --> 00:10:00.788
But I think it's just my clinical
00:10:00.849 --> 00:10:04.033
observations and just seeing that it just
00:10:04.092 --> 00:10:05.914
organically happens where people get boxed
00:10:05.955 --> 00:10:06.274
into these...
00:10:07.196 --> 00:10:09.616
profiles or demographics.
00:10:09.797 --> 00:10:12.258
And I think it just really then is
00:10:12.778 --> 00:10:14.479
challenging for younger clinicians because
00:10:14.499 --> 00:10:16.198
then people just keep getting triaged.
00:10:16.799 --> 00:10:18.259
And then you never fully develop a skill
00:10:18.299 --> 00:10:20.640
set because younger clinicians would be
00:10:20.660 --> 00:10:21.160
like, oh, Ben,
00:10:21.201 --> 00:10:22.142
I want you to see this person with
00:10:22.162 --> 00:10:22.562
a stroke.
00:10:22.961 --> 00:10:23.501
I'm like, well,
00:10:23.522 --> 00:10:24.903
you can still learn from this person.
00:10:24.962 --> 00:10:26.702
And now you're just really limiting your
00:10:26.722 --> 00:10:28.063
ability to work with all sorts of
00:10:28.083 --> 00:10:29.844
individuals because they get scared or
00:10:29.864 --> 00:10:30.745
they're not confident.
00:10:30.825 --> 00:10:31.245
And I'm like,
00:10:31.705 --> 00:10:33.986
you can still do the basics really well.
00:10:34.327 --> 00:10:34.888
And then, yeah,
00:10:34.927 --> 00:10:36.249
if the patient's not getting better,
00:10:36.308 --> 00:10:38.071
then potentially triage or something like
00:10:38.091 --> 00:10:38.311
me.
00:10:38.350 --> 00:10:38.630
Yeah.
00:10:39.451 --> 00:10:40.852
But so many people just punt the ball
00:10:40.873 --> 00:10:41.354
so quick.
00:10:41.994 --> 00:10:44.356
And I think that's just limiting your
00:10:44.376 --> 00:10:44.616
growth.
00:10:44.636 --> 00:10:45.456
That's internal, right?
00:10:45.477 --> 00:10:46.778
That's our own problem.
00:10:46.859 --> 00:10:47.399
I'm guilty of it.
00:10:47.479 --> 00:10:48.299
That's why I can spot it.
00:10:48.360 --> 00:10:49.140
Guilty of myself.
00:10:49.780 --> 00:10:50.682
I'm not the expert in this.
00:10:51.022 --> 00:10:52.102
But I heard someone smart say,
00:10:53.166 --> 00:10:55.750
most of the time because only the sith
00:10:55.831 --> 00:10:57.573
speaks in absolutes i learned that from uh
00:10:57.693 --> 00:11:00.619
star wars uh most of the time you've
00:11:00.639 --> 00:11:02.461
gotta you don't need to be the world's
00:11:02.562 --> 00:11:02.982
expert
00:11:03.840 --> 00:11:04.159
on anything.
00:11:04.259 --> 00:11:05.341
I've never been the world's expert on
00:11:05.600 --> 00:11:05.941
anything.
00:11:06.501 --> 00:11:07.842
We need you to have enough expertise to
00:11:07.883 --> 00:11:10.764
speak confidently and competently.
00:11:10.784 --> 00:11:13.466
Confidence and competence is sort of the
00:11:13.546 --> 00:11:14.326
ticket you need.
00:11:14.706 --> 00:11:16.408
And then when you realize, hey,
00:11:16.447 --> 00:11:17.788
spending more time with me will probably
00:11:17.808 --> 00:11:18.529
be a disservice,
00:11:18.909 --> 00:11:20.870
that's when you do that power move,
00:11:20.890 --> 00:11:23.793
which is a handoff, when you notice that.
00:11:23.832 --> 00:11:24.874
Last thing we do on an episode,
00:11:24.894 --> 00:11:27.916
we call it the parting shot.
00:11:31.052 --> 00:11:32.192
This is The Parting Shot.
00:11:32.732 --> 00:11:34.413
One last mic drop moment.
00:11:34.813 --> 00:11:35.595
No pressure.
00:11:36.054 --> 00:11:39.297
Just your legacy on the line.
00:11:39.336 --> 00:11:40.317
No pressure whatsoever.
00:11:40.337 --> 00:11:41.359
So you can have your own parting shot,
00:11:41.379 --> 00:11:42.779
or I can give you a parting shot
00:11:42.820 --> 00:11:43.220
prompt.
00:11:44.801 --> 00:11:45.381
Let's do the prompt.
00:11:45.442 --> 00:11:45.802
Prompt.
00:11:46.121 --> 00:11:48.604
What's one mindset shift physical
00:11:48.644 --> 00:11:50.264
therapists need to make about their
00:11:50.325 --> 00:11:51.346
clinical identity?
00:11:51.706 --> 00:11:52.285
That'll be your question.
00:11:52.306 --> 00:11:53.908
What's one mindset shift?
00:11:54.288 --> 00:11:55.668
I feel like you've said it a few
00:11:55.708 --> 00:11:56.208
times.
00:11:56.769 --> 00:11:57.250
Yeah.
00:11:57.309 --> 00:11:58.370
I think you just need to...
00:12:00.985 --> 00:12:02.687
know just eliminate the noise around you
00:12:02.787 --> 00:12:05.429
and like don't be influenced by what your
00:12:05.450 --> 00:12:08.032
boss wants you to do necessarily or what
00:12:08.091 --> 00:12:09.433
other people are doing around you like
00:12:09.793 --> 00:12:12.076
find what you want and make that your
00:12:12.136 --> 00:12:13.717
identity and if you haven't found it keep
00:12:13.738 --> 00:12:16.360
looking yeah yeah and if you need a
00:12:16.400 --> 00:12:18.023
place to look that's good too you don't
00:12:18.043 --> 00:12:19.543
know where to look uh come to an
00:12:19.583 --> 00:12:21.005
event like this yeah and just
00:12:22.096 --> 00:12:24.037
Listen, look, consume,
00:12:24.596 --> 00:12:25.437
figure out what you like,
00:12:25.476 --> 00:12:26.778
and then take bits and parts of your
00:12:26.837 --> 00:12:28.958
favorite things that you see and make your
00:12:28.999 --> 00:12:29.418
own thing.
00:12:29.639 --> 00:12:31.119
I'm a physical therapist radio DJ.
00:12:31.240 --> 00:12:32.440
I literally just made this up.
00:12:32.500 --> 00:12:33.500
You just make things up.
00:12:33.519 --> 00:12:34.181
You're an N of one, right?
00:12:34.201 --> 00:12:35.041
Yeah.
00:12:35.100 --> 00:12:36.442
I would have loved for some help along
00:12:36.461 --> 00:12:37.542
the way or like a guidebook,
00:12:37.601 --> 00:12:39.202
but you can just do things.
00:12:39.363 --> 00:12:39.482
Yeah.
00:12:39.503 --> 00:12:40.363
And that's how things happen.
00:12:40.383 --> 00:12:41.442
Well, and it's part of the growth.
00:12:41.604 --> 00:12:42.283
Like, you know,
00:12:43.144 --> 00:12:45.144
the struggle and making mistakes and
00:12:45.205 --> 00:12:45.904
trying to figure it out,
00:12:45.945 --> 00:12:47.206
like that's part of the journey.
00:12:47.225 --> 00:12:47.385
Yeah.
00:12:48.166 --> 00:12:49.148
what I like about it the most.
00:12:49.168 --> 00:12:50.169
Listen, I'm here for a good time,
00:12:50.190 --> 00:12:50.811
not a long time.
00:12:50.850 --> 00:12:51.071
Ben,
00:12:51.110 --> 00:12:53.755
appreciate the stop by here at APTA CSM.
00:12:53.855 --> 00:12:54.476
Here, in.