Conquering Physical Therapy Workforce Struggles & Boosting Productivity
Jimmy McKay welcomes back Larry Benz, PT, DPT, OCS, MBA, FAPTA, to discuss the pressing issues in the physical therapy profession today. From workforce development challenges to cultural shifts in clinical care, Larry offers deep insights into the productivity crisis and how therapists can regain control in 2024.
Find Larry's Blog Posts that inspired this episode here: AllThingsPhysicalTherapy
00:00 - Introduction & Welcome Back Larry Benz
02:00 - Why Larry Started Writing More
08:30 - Productivity Comparisons: PTs vs. Physicians
13:50 - Challenges in PT Workforce Development
19:00 - Solutions for PT Productivity & Cultural Change
24:20 - Regulatory Barriers & Payer Restrictions in PT
31:00 - The Future of Physical Therapy: Culture & Technology
36:45 - Final Thoughts & Encouragement for Clinicians
Discover the potential of AI, the role of middle management, and how cultural and systemic changes can shape the future of physical therapy. Tune in for a thought-provoking conversation that touches on everything from CPT code constraints to the economics of PT practice. Don't miss this essential discussion for any PT professional!
Timestamps:
<p>This episode is part of the <a href="/physical-therapy-business-podcast">Physical Therapy Business Podcast</a>, where physical therapists and clinic owners learn how to get more patients, improve operations, and grow their clinic without relying only on referrals.</p>
<p>Looking for more episodes? Explore the full <a href="/physical-therapy-business-podcast">Physical Therapy Business Podcast</a> for real-world strategies on physical therapy marketing, patient acquisition, and clinic growth.</p>
0:00 I'll have to edit that part out. That's not supposed to play. But Larry, welcome back to the show, man. Appreciate your time. Thanks. Anytime. You're doing something different. You're writing a lot. You're writing often. You've got a Substack platform. For people who don't know that, that's a really simple or streamlined or easily digestible way for someone to take words and thoughts. And then get them to a lot of people who might want to sort of tap into that. Where back in the day, it would be like a list serve or an email list. And I think now we're getting more sophisticated. Ironically, we're getting more sophisticated by making it simpler.
0:42 And you're using Substack and people can find you on Substack. What is the way that all things physical therapy? All things physical therapy. I think I'm also known as physical therapist on their physical therapy there. Yeah, absolutely. Now, before we get into this kind of two-part series that caught my eye because you show up in my inbox, why did you decide to start writing so much? What do you get out of that? Why? Because there's effort involved in that. No, absolutely. I think a couple of things. One is I've been writing for a long time. If you look at my body of work, we were the first multi-author blog. on the Internet and it was under evidence in motion, which still houses all my blog posts, hundreds and hundreds of them literally.
1:26 At the time, we were creating vibe in the industry by challenging some of the assumptions. So many years that I was a CEO, I did just as much writing, but I was writing different for my own employees. And not so much on the politics and the rules and regulations of PT, but more on employee motivation and culture and values. And now I've transitioned back. I've had this sort of pent up stuff on my brain for a long time about PT. And so I'm writing to my colleagues and if they find it useful and valuable, great. If they don't, or if it sparks some creativity, great.
2:06 I charge nothing for it. There's no profit motive at all. I really just try to get some conversation going and I try to expose things that a lot of people aren't talking about. Well, the reason this one, you know, I wanted to have you on for this is I saw it in my inbox. I saw it online and I saw people starting to engage. And I like that. I like when people agree or disagree, but have an opinion like challenge. And you sort of put it out there a few times, which is like challenge this. Like, is everything I say perfect? Absolutely not. But you got the conversation going. And I say this line a lot when people come to me like, how do I create content? I'm like, don't try to create social media content. Try to try to create something media that is social.
2:47 If you said that a water cooler, would someone agree with their eyebrow go up? So this is a two part series and we'll give a link in the show notes. People can go read and sort of go deep into this. But in the series, you revealed that PTs only see around four hundred patient visits per year. While our colleagues that are orthopedic surgeons are doing about eight hundred visits annually and family physicians manage nearly two thousand. And you write physical therapists on a per visit basis are only roughly about fifty percent as productive as an orthopedist and twenty percent as a family physician. So why do you think PTs are so much less? I'll use air quotes productive by comparison. And what are the biggest factors that contribute to this this gap?
3:30 Yeah, so in order to get to the answer to that, but what sparks all this is workforce development. If you look at some of the more academic writing that I've done, it has really been publishing articles that challenge workforce development that the APTA and the Workforce Development Study did not. now many years ago where they effectively said by this time we would have an abundance and have an oversupply of physical therapists. When the market has something to say about that and the expansion of the PT practice has something to say about it and the fact that at best we see twelve to fifteen percent of the population that needs us has something to say about that and the practice expands.
4:14 And things have moved out from a hospital and institutional environment to outpatient and to a wellness perspective that a lot of PTs work in. And so I've always had, you know, a keen sense of workforce development, how many PTs there are, how many programs there are, as you know, I'm very active in higher education, a physical therapist. And so I've always wanted to know what is our supply, what is our demand? There is a forthcoming work group that APTA put together that will have a paper that is right now under, you know, sort of confidentiality, but it will come out and I don't think the results of it will be surprising to anybody without letting the cat out of the bag there. But at the end of the day, let's look at our own profession and now let's analyze ourselves a little bit.
4:59 We have about two hundred and fifty thousand PTs in the US. We have roughly, and this is multiple data sources that suggest we have about a hundred million visits per year. Now those visits can take the form of an outpatient location, they can take the form of an inpatient, and really then you can extrapolate from it how many visits per PT per day. Now, many years ago, I want to go backwards one more time. I was on the advisory panel on practice for APTA for many years, appointed position. I think it's one of the highest regarded appointments that APTA does. And I was on it many moons ago. And through that, I got to know Andrew Guccione extremely well, who was head of that on APTA, who I have tremendous respect for. He's also a good friend.
5:41 And I would have meetings with him back in these days, and he would say, Larry, we have too many therapists. And I said, what do you mean? He says, well, just take the number of potential visits that a PT can do, multiply it, and you'll see we have too many PTs. And to a certain extent, he was right. And I'll tell you why. If you took two hundred and fifty thousand PTs that are licensed in the U.S. and let's say they average all average six or seven visits a day. There's not enough patients in the population of the United States, about three percent of which are getting PT at any given time. It's too many PTs. What you find, most surprisingly, is that only about twenty percent, it's actually slightly less, of licensed PTs are seeing patients.
6:21 Count me guilty. I'm one of them who isn't. And I know a lot of others that aren't. Where do they work? They work in academia. They work PRN. They work in research. They work in manufacturing. And some of them have left the profession altogether. And that's a really, really small number. Now, we produce about twelve thousand PTs a year. So here's another way to look at it. We have a very inefficient education system in the United States for PTs. We have about three hundred programs producing twelve thousand grads a year. By contrast, physicians have about one hundred and fifty programs in the US producing about twenty thousand graduates a year.
7:02 It would take the number of orthopedic practices, by the way, got twenty nine thousand practicing orthopedists, seven hundred fifty graduates from their residency programs per year. You know that it would take thirty eight years to reproduce the number of orthopedists we have and the number of orthopedists. They work well into their sixties. They're at the peak of their career. Their best highest use is seeing patients. They're allowed to use extenders. They make a lot of money. Average salary, four hundred thousand dollars. Family practice physicians. OK, we have roughly four thousand four hundred graduates of family practice residencies per year. About one hundred thousand of them practicing would take them twenty two years to reproduce their their numbers.
7:44 In PT, we have two hundred fifty thousand producing twelve thousand graduates a year take twenty years. The reality, though, is only take a few years if all the PTs saw patients full time. Right. So the math on it is actually spellbinding. And then you get to some of the reasons why. Now, my post, quite honestly, and I reveal this in the second iteration, I'm not really, I don't really care about productivity arguments. I'm not, you know, the fact that I'm comparing an orthopedic to a family practice to a PT is ridiculous. Honestly, quite irreverent and irrelevant, both of them. But I am trying to show that our best and highest use as a PT is obviously not clinical.
8:26 If that were the case, we'd have more than twenty percent of the PTC. And we're restricted and we're restricted horribly. We effectively have a compensation cap on the earnings that a physical therapist can do. Let me give you an example, Jimmy. Let's hypothetically say a PT works in an outpatient clinic and one hundred percent of their patients is either Medicare or Medicare Advantage or a payer in some states, the blues that follow Medicare rules. They effectively, the max revenue they can generate by seeing eight or nine patients a day, forty six weeks a year, forty seven weeks a year is around two hundred ten thousand dollars. That's gross. That's before overhead. Overhead. Right.
9:07 Yeah. And so that's before you paid for the lights. You've paid for revenue cycle management. You've paid for any support staff that you need that contributes to you seeing those patients. And why are we at such limitations? There, you've got a lot of factors. Our own profession has just really restricted us in terms of the RCs and exclusive PT can only be one-on-one, all that kind of BS. But the payers have also restricted us. They have superimposed rules that do not allow us to use extenders like PT technicians or PT assistants at the top of our license to use our extenders at the top of their license like ortho and family practice have. And then the other one, frankly, is cultural. A lot of people come into our field for the inherent flexibility so they can come in and out of the profession.
9:49 I think then that culture, though, has got some negative connotations to it. How many great clinical PTs do you know? I got board certification in two areas that are then incentivized to get out of seeing patients because they can make more money. They get rewarded by it, in essence, through management and other kinds of things. We have a higher burnout rate than a higher attrition rate. probably than any other profession. But the biggest concern I have, all that is a concern, but the biggest concern is I have is name me one industry, one profession that you could say is less productive today, given the advent of technology and innovation than physical therapy. The data will tell you that when we used to average about twelve patients a day, we're now averaging closer to ten.
10:35 And that is because of the external constraints, the rules and the regulations that are placed on us. I know no of no other medical professional that can say that. And that is a root cause problem that we got to address. Yeah, that was going to be one of my next questions. And it was that stat dropping from about twelve patients per day to ten, you know, despite technology and automation. Why is that moving backwards? Is it is it is this self-caused? Is this a little bit of us and a little bit of everybody else? I mean, because ultimately, If it's caused by us, that's sort of good because we can control it. If it's caused by other people, we can blame it. We can write about it on the internet. That doesn't do a whole lot, right?
11:17 But it draws attention to it. So how do we dig out of that? It's a multitude of reasons, by the way. One reason very simply is on the math is that, you know, let's say ten to fifteen percent of your patients cancel per day. That automatically brings your productivity ability down. So we can use technology to help us with quick call lists and with patients because there's a high demand for PT right now. I believe that problem is a little bit fixable. I think we can get it down to five percent open table and other kinds of things that use it in non-physical therapy have done a good job of reducing no-show cancellations. And when you have no-show cancellations, filling it back, filling it in with somebody who will sit at that table.
12:02 So that's a fixable problem. The second fixable problem is, is we've got to completely renovate our own profession. We have RCs, you know, practice restrictions and stuff within our profession that limit certain tasks that we do to exclusive one-on-one of a physical therapist. Can you imagine orthopedics or family practice physician advertising that patients should come to them because they get exclusive one-to-one? No, they operate at the top of their license, which I call neck up skills, which is a term I borrowed from my good friend, Carl DeRosa, who first started talking about this probably twenty years ago. And the reality is we have to change those limitations.
12:43 Most of the time. Here's the irony. Most of the time, our practice acts allow it. So it's not our practice act. Some states, New York, Massachusetts, there are some states that are really restrictive, just penalize our own profession. But it is it is our profession itself. And it is the payers that arguably, you know, restrict them. So that's a second factor that really drives it. And, you know, then, of course. The third piece that is also fixable is that we have a fee-for-service system that effectively has made us hourly workers. Every CPT code, with the exception of a few, are time-based.
13:25 And that is the way that we're reimbursed. I don't think we're going to be jumping into value-based care anytime soon, but I hope we do in many ways. And if we do, that could change that element of it. So parts of these are indeed fixable. You know, PT's salaries have gone up in part because of inflation and because of the education degree and student debt and all the things. And most notably the shortages, but it still has a cap to it. And that cap at some point will burst. Employers at some level can't pay above. I think the number is probably, you know, one hundred fifteen, one hundred fifteen thousand a year in the in the in the most expensive markets because again that cap is going to be two hundred to two hundred fifty thousand on the revenue side and we have legitimate overhead yeah um so hopefully that those are the things that I've come up with certainly other people would speculate otherwise but um you know in many cases we are our worst enemy but there are lots of externalities that have put pressure on us as well yeah the thing that jumped out of me the quote that you had said in your two-part series was we must stop incentivizing pts to stop seeing patients through over emphasizing management roles that detract from patient care Absolutely.
14:38 And that's what we do. How do you get ahead? You become a clinic director who then hires enough therapists where they don't get to see patients anymore. And everybody loses sort of in that process over the long run because you don't see a lot of PTs that get out of clinical care that go back in it. You just don't. Right. And so that's a tough nut to crack because our best and highest utilization might not be seeing patients. Arguably, it isn't because the majority of PTs aren't seeing patients. So it's a real problem. Still think we have the best profession going. We have so many good things going for it. But those challenges... are going to make it difficult. And private practice is really at the forefront of this because they get hit with all of these challenges occurring at the same time.
15:26 right so you can wave a magic wand we'll sum it up right you can you can fix a few fronts I won't ask you exactly how to fix it but where's the where is it in washington is it within our own profession where are the places that things need to change I won't because I feel like the how many different things need to change might be a a a three-part episode but where are these things like where would you put if you only had uh a certain amount of effort where would you put the pressure to actually change the things the biggest levers to pull to sort of reverse this yes yes and yes so first thing I would do is I would start within our own profession and make physical therapy the exclusive provision of a physical therapist acting within their state practice act What does that mean?
16:11 That means that within our state practice act and almost every state, it calls for us to allow us to use extenders, allow us to leverage our neck up skills so that we can see more and more patients. Then we have to battle the payers and particularly the CPT code system itself and others that really reward us for value, not volume. Yeah. I was in the military. We had no CPT codes. The average number of patients that a therapist saw in the Army, Navy in those days was about, Air Force was about thirty a day and never felt overworked because we used ninety one J's and other technicians to help us leverage our ability to do evaluation skills, manual therapy skills, and the higher order skills that physical therapists.
16:56 We became more case managers, but also utilizing our hands and our cognitive skills where that is what's the best way. The third thing is cultural. I would say we have to start shifting more compensation to our therapists. I know that sounds inherently obvious, but that means you have to stop rewarding middle management. You have to say, if you want to be a manager, you're going to take a pay cut. You know, if you become an office manager of an orthopedic practice, you make a whole lot less than the orthopedic surgeon or a family practice. And so you have to look organizationally and say, you know, PTs are pretty smart. They have transportable skills. They have good skills that lend themselves well for business, marketing, other uses.
17:37 And a PT can both manage a practice without needing a middle manager who's also a physical therapist that's managing a practice. You don't see MD or orthopedic surgeons being the manager of two or three multi-site practices. You see office managers and other administrative folks when you need them, and they make a lot less. than that so I think part of it is is indeed cultural and that's going to take a long time yeah it's we have to reward our clinicians I mean you have to you know go to variable pay where they get a good base salary and I'm not saying this applies to everybody because some folks don't like to to you know work under incentives but if they view another job of moving that's non-clinical for more money you're better off saying you can make more money as a clinician and here's how Yeah, the culture change, definitely important and definitely rules and regulations, as you highlighted.
18:30 I actually believe we got an email today as we record two hours ago, APTA New York reporting that a bill was passed by the governor that allows OTAs and PTAs to provide care to workers, compensation patients under direct and supervision of an authorized power being a PT in New York. And that looks like more neck up skill, more neck up skills being rewarded for being a physical therapist. That's good. In Medicare, they went the opposite way. You get paid less if it's done by a PT assistant. Yeah. Yeah. And fighting those things. One of those things is under our control, which is culture change. I think a lot of people are starting to begin to recognizing it and your piece, writing about it, stirring the pot a little bit and putting it out there and saying, let's talk about this.
19:12 Because if we don't talk about it, it doesn't change. What's your prediction next couple of years? Which one of these things is more likely to actually come to fruition? Is it the culture change? Because I always look at which one can I have my fingerprints on the most? And rules and regulations and advocacy, I'm all for. I'm glad someone else is doing it. That's not my bag. I'm glad it's going on, but I also recognize that's a long-term change. I look at culture being not... It's simple but not easy, but that's under our control. I feel like that's the control the controllables side. Yeah, so a couple things. One is I hope to see PTs regain productivity to more of the twelve rather than the ten.
19:54 I think through AI and other things, if they can get the matching to the right fields and all the regulatory things done correctly, I think that could help productivity and probably limit burnout a little bit. However, my fear, and there was just an article written about this about physicians that, yeah, there's a balance there. If all of a sudden you don't have the constraints of an EMR, you're still can suffer from burnout by seeing too many patients. But I do think you'll see some incremental gains there. There's no reason why we should have productivity loss. Second thing is I'm hoping the culture changes. I think the economics of PT is such, we're a penny nickel business. We're not a dime quarter business nor a dollar business. as such that the margins are so small that you're gonna have to see scalability and moving to a management level that is skinny at best.
20:44 And the good news is PTs don't need a lot of babysitting. They're trusted, they're autonomous. And here's the beauty, a PT that works in a more autonomous mastery purposeful environment thrives and needs less management. What I say to my employees all the time is those who manage best manage least. And then third thing is, I don't know whether value-based care is around. I suspect it isn't because providers are unwilling to take on risk when they've got their shins kicked in us for a lot less reimbursement over the last several years. And let's face it, value-based care, while it's attractive in many ways from a practice independent standpoint, It's not economical in most of the primary care models.
21:25 I mean, you saw what's happening with CVS. They're trying to now branch it in a separate company because of their they have the insurance side, but they also have the provider, you know, business side of it as well. And then I think lastly, we have to get the payers to change their, the fee for service environment to a per diem or an episodic case per day, you know, per, per, per case, whatever. Really instead of value-based care, you're going to see alternative payment models, which is different, right? They're, they're, they're, the one is not necessarily part of the other. And those alternative payment models may be, uh allow a therapist to scale and use their uh neck up skills uh I hope we go more to a military model you know from that standpoint yeah I've been hearing uh current and former military therapists acting confused.
22:22 Why is it this way when I leave the military? We do so well and it's so effective. And look, we have data. It's not just we think, we feel, we believe. It's look at this data and the outcomes and how effective, cost effective and quality outcome effective. And it's twenty twenty four. I've been hearing this since I was in school in twenty fourteen. Well, it's very simple, though, Jimmy. I mean, the government always absolves themselves of the rules they place on everybody else. That doesn't feel fair, Larry. No, I hear you. So if these are the kinds of topics that you want to dig into, I want people who are listening and watching to understand, like you're having these conversations pretty regularly.
23:03 You're creating, you're, you're having these conversations with yourself in your head. You're talking to friends with a keyboard. And then that's the beauty of this, not social media, but media that's social is these are the things that are in Larry's head all the time, or these conversations that are happening. in rooms around the country, right? We're coming up on PPS. A lot of these things, plus a couple other hundred topics get discussed, but now you're able to have those conversations at scale and share those things and people can interact, which to me is, instead of just arguing what we do on Twitter a lot, these are the good outcomes of platforms like Substack. So all things physical therapy on Substack. We'll share that link again. Larry, parting shot. What do you want to leave with the audience?
23:44 Hopefully a good note. Hopefully a good note. No, it's a word of encouragement. There's nothing wrong with data. Just realize it and then reflect on it and say, how can I as a clinician continue to sustain an environment throughout my career where clinical emphasis is maintained as priority number one? If I'm an employer, what can I do to keep my clinicians practicing clinically? And what am I doing through the unintended consequences or causing my clinicians to practice less clinically? And then from an advocacy standpoint, what can we agree with? Can we agree that physical therapists under the domain of physical therapy are the arbitrators and should be able to practice clinically?
24:27 through their state practice acts, which are heavily vetted at the state level through associations, rather than under the constraints of payers, or in our own particular case, our own profession, which has told us that one-on-one care is the way, the truth, and the life. That's very unfortunate. yeah yeah we did a live stream with about this and where's the value in being a pt and we we came upon or my my sort of outcome of that is it's a little culture change right we think Like if you the biggest mistake you can make if you if you create a product or a service or you provide a service is assuming what about that product or service your customer actually values.
25:14 I mean, so many providers will tell me, well, one on one care, they value it. And I'll say like every time you're saying every single one, because if you can solve my problem in half the time, I actually value that more. Now, this is case dependent, but what I mean is it's case dependent. So it's not just more one-on-one time is better. Why not two hours then? Why is one-on-one for an hour? Why should it be one patient a day then? Right, right, right. If it's so much better, then over-serve. Do a patient for eight hours. And of course, that's funny. but that's going to the edge of that argument. So like, let's figure it out. Like figure out what the answer actually is. And that's just not assume all things, physical therapy on sub stack. We'll share that link. Larry, are you headed to PPS? We're going to see.
25:54 Absolutely. It'll be a PPS. Sure. Stop. Come talk to me. That's how I get all my ideas is through interactions. I talk to physical therapists, owners, practice folks all the time. And these are the kinds of things that they're, that are on their mind and, And now I just have the ability to kind of write about them and report what people are telling me. The internet, it has some good uses as well. Larry Bench, appreciate you stopping by on the show. Absolutely.