Change the Model: Why PT’s Business Model Is Breaking
Physical therapy doesn’t have a value problem.
It has a positioning problem.
In this episode, Jimmy talks with Matthew Pratte about why private outpatient practices are getting squeezed — and what to do about it.
Key Topics Covered:
- Why fee-for-service puts control in someone else’s hands
- How inflation + stagnant reimbursement compress margins
- Why scale favors hospital systems and large chains
- The rise of direct-to-employer contracting
- What self-insured employers are — and why they matter
- Why PT clinics can often command higher per-visit rates through employer contracts
- Misconceptions about size and selling
- A simple first step clinic owners can take this quarter
Big Takeaway
Waiting for reimbursement to improve isn’t a strategy.
Independent clinics must rethink who they sell to — and how they position PT as first-line musculoskeletal care.
<p>This episode is part of the <a href="/physical-therapy-business-podcast">Physical Therapy Business Podcast</a>, where physical therapists and clinic owners learn how to get more patients, improve operations, and grow their clinic without relying only on referrals.</p>
<p>Looking for more episodes? Explore the full <a href="/physical-therapy-business-podcast">Physical Therapy Business Podcast</a> for real-world strategies on physical therapy marketing, patient acquisition, and clinic growth.</p>
0:08 Thanks, VoiceOverGuy. First, thanks to U.S. Physical Therapy. They were nice enough to host me at CSM. I got to hang out at their booth and do some live streams. If you've built something special, but scaling your clinic and planning for what's next, well, that can feel overwhelming. At U.S. Physical Therapy, they partner with clinic owners who want to grow with you without you having to give up your identity. You stay in control. They bring the support. Learn how at usphpartnership.com. That's usphpartnership.com, their website, USPH. Today, our guest believes physical therapy doesn't have a value problem. It has a positioning problem.
0:49 I like this. He spends his time helping independent practices stop waiting for reimbursement to improve and start rethinking how they get paid altogether. While most clinic owners are stuck negotiating contracts, chasing referrals, or hoping legislation fixes their margins. Spoiler alert, it's not going to do that. He's asking different questions. What if the problem isn't reimbursement? What if the problem is the model? What if the call is coming from inside the house? You get the idea. He's gotten to work with practices that want more control over their pricing, their relationships, their future by building direct relationships with employers and positioning physical therapy as the first stop for musculoskeletal care.
1:32 He's here to challenge the default system and give clinic owners in the audience a chance to think differently about power in healthcare. Let's bring him in, Matthew Pratt. Matthew, welcome to the show. Thank you for having me on. Pretty good intro, right? I tried to go NPR style. Yeah, I feel like I'm going to have a hard time living up to that, but that was really good. Thank you. All right. So I like bold statements and you say most PT practices don't actually have a reimbursement problem. They've got a business model problem. I like that because it changes the ownership on not our fault to it might not be our fault, but it is our problem.
2:14 So break that down. Break that idea down for me. Yeah. Well, let me start by first saying reimbursement is an issue for a lot of practices. I'm not minimizing that in any way. The reason I say that the way that I do is because the current traditional fee for service system does not position physical therapy, for the most part, in a position to win. You're constantly, where your people come from, how much you get paid, your referrals, all of that is dictated by someone else. We're hoping legislation will change that. We're hoping referral partnerships will change that. We're hoping that the hospital system won't go out and acquire our competitor across the street and just refer everything in house.
2:58 And so when you look at the reality of health, the healthcare costs in America continue to rise, right? I saw a post this morning by Dr. Eric Bricker and he, in his post, he talked about how for a family of five, the cost of healthcare for in Dallas, in the Dallas Fort Worth area was thirty five thousand dollars. which is, and that's my situation. I have a family of five, I'm married, I've got three little girls, and that's a lot of money, right? And so as these costs continue to rise, the people who are paying for care, patients and the people that employ them, they're looking for alternative methods to be able to bring those costs down, right?
3:44 And so for physical therapy, I think that there's this unique opportunity to position, not as a, you know, a cheaper than option, right? As in, you know, outcomes are worse, but you save money. But in the reality of this does save you twenty seven hundred dollars on average per musculoskeletal claim for these employers and employers are willing to pay a premium for that. So to me, when I look at it, the positioning problem is that the value that P.T., provides isn't being realized or recognized by the current system. So we need to look at alternative methods to go outside of, okay, who does value physical therapy and who's willing to pay what physical therapy is worth?
4:27 Because I believe, you know, a hundred and fifty dollar reimbursement across the nation should be average. But I know a lot of practices I've talked to, sometimes they're getting fifty dollars, you know, sometimes they're getting seventy five. So that's why I say there's a positioning problem. It sort of changed. This part of the conversation feels like that Spider-Man meme, right? Is everybody sort of pointing at each other saying it's your fault. It's your fault. It's your fault. It sort of shifts. It shifts that ownership. I mean, I heard Jerry Durham say this a long time ago, which the fact that we still call it reimbursement and not getting paid like. i don't reimburse my plumber i pay him like i might get the invoice a day later but i still pay him isn't that funny how we even just the words like reimbursement it's like well thank thank you so much i appreciate you appreciate you allowing me to take your money for doing the thing i did right yeah yeah so what specifically breaks in the traditional fee-for-service model for independent practices where does it where does the where do things break down I think that a lot of it goes back to control and like control in the sense of in the traditional fee for service model, the way that things are set up right now, independent, you know, outpatient practices, they don't have the opportunity to dictate who do they treat, when do they treat, right?
5:48 Obviously with greater direct access laws, some of that has opened up to a point, but I know certain States it's still, you know, there's caps on how many visits people can get on direct access and And so from a, the problem I would say with the current traditional fee for service model is it's not built to value physical therapy and for physical therapy practices to win, right? The people that are winning right now are the health systems, the people that are winning are the people who have the scale to go in and negotiate reimbursements. And I've even had this conversation with some people who agree and disagree with what I'm saying.
6:30 And that's great. I think that that's the discourse that we need. That's how the industry, that's how health care gets pushed forward. We have these conversations. But when your practice is located in a large metropolitan area, you have the demographics and the wealth to say, oh, I offer cash pay. I offer these other wellness services. And I can scale to the point where now I can negotiate my contracts and get meaningful change in my reimbursement. But what does the small rural pediatric practice who services mainly Medicare patients, what do they do? that they're they're forced to say well i have to take what i can get from insurance and that that is what it is right and so and i even in that conversation i've had you know people have told me well they decided to do that that's their problem right and like i understand but i think we all would agree greater access to care is good like we want people getting into the care that they need so we've got to find a way that it at least works for the vast majority of people and and i i don't i'm not in any way advocating that we should just trash the traditional fee for service model i i don't that's not what i think would be most beneficial especially for most practices but i do think that we're kind of getting to an inflection point where the cost of providing care Inflation, rising overhead, staffing, how much it costs to pay your staff.
8:00 People are coming out of PT school with, I think, you can correct me, Jimmy, I'm not sure. I think the average is like a hundred and fifty thousand in student loans is what people are coming out of PT school. So people with that much debt, they can't come in and start at sixty K. Right. Like they've they've got to make more money than that. Right. And we're getting to this point where it's getting incredibly hard for we'll call them the mom and pop private practices to operate. Right. Margins are getting so thin they can't eat the cost. Larger practices can. And for me, like just my my background and I think, you know, just uniquely to my experience, what I've been able to see, I've spent a lot of time emailing cold calling practices all across the country like some people who listen this you may even have a voicemail in your inbox from me at this very moment uh but in the month of january alone um i talked to two six location practices i'm obviously not gonna name names or locations uh talk to two owners who told me in january two six location practices that they were selling and i've seen that as a growing trend yeah over the last six months and i think we're getting to that point where the economics don't make sense that doesn't matter the math doesn't math and the concern that I have, you know, my background, um, I played football from fifth grade into college.
9:23 I've, I've had, I've been on a lot of treatment tables. Um, I've got a very good friend who's a physical therapist here in where I live. Um, I, I deeply care about the industry and about physical therapy. And my concern is that in, in five years, the, the The PT student coming out and saying, I want to go start my own practice because I just want to treat and serve my community. And maybe we scale it in the future. They're not going to be able to do that. Their only option is going to be, I've got to go, I've got to go work for this very large company. And we're going to only going to have four or five of those. Maybe that's, that's my concern. That's what I've been hearing, and that's what some of the smart people that I hang out with, which is you can do this as an individual provider.
10:09 This is where they say the rise of the one point five FTE location, right? It's like you running it, you bring someone on part time. But when you go to a step bigger than that, that that next step doesn't make any sense the other end of the spectrum is a giant multi-state um chain or a hospital system or you know you sort of do what danny mattei and his group talk about which is like it's just cash but will that work everywhere Maybe not. Right. Like, so, so the question I always ask people is like, what game are you playing? What game do you think you're playing? I heard someone say it on a podcast recently. I, you know, just somebody was saying, Oh my God, I'm just done with this corporate America.
10:50 I'm just going to go open a, um, a coffee shop. And the guy was probing and he goes, well, do you like spreadsheets and ordering coffee and cups and lids and napkins? And they're like, no, I want to hang out and talk and hand coffee over. He goes, you want to be a barista? That's what a barista does. So a coffee shop owner doesn't really does that one percent of the time. So I think when people are like, I'm frustrated by doing whatever this is, either a clinician or an owner, understand what game you're actually playing. Because right now for owners, it sounds like margin compression, referral dependency, or I mean, I've said this before, you need to be a marketing engine first that happens to sell physical therapy. Red Bull is a marketing company that happens to sell an energy drink, not the other way around.
11:35 And then, I mean, we've heard just in the last couple of weeks, Clinicians saying I signed on to that contract knowing I'm losing money every visit. I'm like, how do you do that with a straight face? Like, how do you do that with a straight face? So overall, we can say you've said PT needs better positioning. What does that look like to you in a practice? Yeah, I think the two ways that come to mind, you mentioned it a second ago, right? There's cash-based, and I think that should be a mix of every practice's payer mixes is just cash-based patients. I think the hard part with that is, And I could be completely wrong on this, but I haven't seen many practices that are cash based be able to scale really well.
12:28 And I think part of the problem with that is you're very demographic dependent, right? Just like the example I provided earlier. I mean, I grew up in a pretty rural area, blue collar family. We would have never had the money. to pay to go to physical therapy cash-based never would have had the money and so i think that's where you know the cash pay you know you get into well what are direct access laws you know does this work in every demographic it can to some extent right but i i don't think it's the solution in my opinion where I think the biggest opportunity for physical therapy and for physical therapy practices is in the direct direct contracting model with employers.
13:12 And I'll tell you why I think that's the case. it alleviates some of the problems that we just talked about, right? Like, oh, this is a rural area. These people don't have a lot of money. They can't afford to pay me cash pay, right? But I also, I'm not really happy with the contracted insurance rate, right? That I'm usually getting in the same area. When you contract directly with a self-insured employer, and Jim, are you familiar, Jimmy, with like what a self-insured employer is? Yeah, but just explain again, because I don't know if everybody does. Yeah. So basically, when an employer is self-insured, they have their own group health plan.
13:54 And instead of paying premiums to Blue Cross Blue Shield, UHC, they basically they have a third party administrator that can be someone like Blue Cross or UHC. But instead of paying for premiums, they're just paying all of the claims out of pocket. So for their covered lives. Right. So. Anyone who's an employee and then an attendant on their plan, they pay all of the healthcare costs for those people, right? And what that means is when my wife pulls her back at the gym, And then she has to go to the PCP. And then the PCP says, yeah, I don't really get musculoskeletal.
14:37 Let me refer you to a specialist. And then you go to the specialist and you might get a great specialist who's like, oh yeah, this sounds more like a PT problem. Let's get you into PT, right? My experience having gone through this before, they're gonna wanna do imaging. And then once you get imaging, they're either gonna say, let's do surgery or pain management. or maybe PT, right? But I think it's pretty rare that people go, they get pushed directly into PT, right? All of those stops along the way, it just inflates the costs. And these self-insured employers who are paying every cost along the way, every PCP visit, every specialist visit, they're looking at this rising cost of healthcare and going, How do I, how do I make this work?
15:23 Right? Like I only have so much budget that I can put towards this and then how do I make it work? So they are willing to be self-insured employers. And the majority of employers in America are actually self-insured. And what we've been seeing in our conversations at like Second Door Health is basically more and more employers, even smaller and smaller employers, because the premiums are getting so expensive, they're looking to go self-insured. It just costs too much. It's a gamble, but now there's skin in the game. So now you're advocating for better decisions and you're like, well, if this on average, because everything's an average, right?
16:06 This on average tends to lead to lower costs and better outcomes, getting that person back to work, covering them, right? Giving them care, back to work, solving the problem. And it's less money. Well, I'm going to want to do that. I'm incentivized to do that. Whereas the insurance company, you have paid them. Now they are now practicing medicine without a license, essentially where they will deny or use strategies to pay as little as possible. It's just, it's moving where the money is. It's moving where the decisions are made. Yeah. Yeah. And, and the reason why I think this is such a, I think it needs to be a very important model for the future of physical therapy and especially private outpatient physical therapy is that these employers, they're not looking to pay you less than your current contracted rate with Blue Cross Blue Shield.
16:58 Most of the time when we've had these conversations with employers, they're willing to pay above and beyond a per visit rate of what you're getting right now. The reason being you're saving them on average, twenty seven hundred dollars per claim for musculoskeletal care. Right. So they're looking at that and they go, well, if I had two hundred claims last year, that's five hundred and forty thousand dollars potentially in savings. That's that's yeah. They like that math, too. And the reason in all that being said, like, This model, it's not easy. It takes time. It takes time developing the relationships, the conversations, and it's new, right? Anytime you're trying to introduce a new business model, a new product, it takes time.
17:43 But the reason I think that it needs to be a part of the future of physical therapy is one, margins are an issue. This is a great way to solve margin problems, right? And, you know, When you have those direct contracts, you can set that up as onsite services, or you can just have people fed right into your clinic, right? If you wanna go onsite and you've got the infrastructure for that, you can do that. If not, you can just have people funneled straight into your clinic, most likely for a higher reimbursement than what anyone else is paying you at the moment. And it solves the problem we talked about earlier with the cash pay or the cash-based model. Because even in rural communities, your municipalities, your school districts, your fire departments, your police departments, those are all generally self-insured.
18:33 So no matter where you're located, you have people that you can go out and contract with and be able to fulfill this type of model. We'll get to misconceptions in a minute. I want to say thanks to Empower EMR, one of the organizations supporting the show. If your clinic is stuck on an EMR but slows you down, that's a choice you made. You don't have to do that forever. Empower gives you speed, clean workflows, and features PTs actually ask for. Better notes, faster documentation, smoother operations, all wrapped in customer support that just doesn't ghost you. Upgrade your clinic's brain with Empower EMR at empoweremr.com. dot com. Misconceptions. So with direct to employer, there's some misconceptions I bet that PTs have about it.
19:14 You just touched on it a second ago. I'm too small. I don't know how to sell. That's only for big groups. I mean, I guess two of those have to do with size, but are all those wrong? Are those wrong? Should people change their viewpoint on that if you're a PT listening? They â the size, yes and no. And this is â how I would answer that is when you're pursuing these contracts with employers, right, you have to have the clinic density and geographic coverage to be able to service the people that are employed by them. Got it. So where you are and where you're â where the organization is located is not actually where the people live because they might also get it so i'm understanding that god yes yeah so that that can be a problem and like we you know at second door like i've talked to single location practice practices that were like hey i want to do this direct to employer thing like let's get it going and i'm like i want you to do it too But you have one practice and there's two hundred employees at this one employer.
20:22 They probably have five hundred covered lives. You on your own can't service that. Right. And I think that's where I think for so long, because, you know, I would say just, you know, my humble opinion, I think in physical therapy, we've operated out of a scarcity mindset for a long time. And like the practice across my street, that's my competitor. I've got to beat them for referrals. I've got to, right. And, and I understand that. And to some extent that's been reality, but when you're looking at, okay, I can continue in the model that I'm in now, or I can partner with the other practices in my area and say, Hey, let's, let's start a network or like second door health.
21:05 Like we have a network of practices that are able to opt into employer contracts and let's band together and we can all treat, win this contract and treat it this negotiated rate. So size can be a barrier, but I think that's where, like as an industry, we have to be willing to come together and say, like, you know, rising tide lifts all boats. Like let's all benefit from this and more, and I want that more than I necessarily want to beat my competitor across the street. Right. How about, how about, I don't know how to sell. Yeah. So I would say most practice owners don't give themselves enough credit.
21:47 If you're a business owner, you're selling, right? And I would even say clinicians sell every single day. You've got to sell patients on a plan of care. Someone comes in for an eval. You've got to sell them on, hey, this is what I think is going to be best. This is how we're going to address what you presented in the eval. You're selling all the time. But I also get Most practice owners don't have the time, right? They don't enjoy it and they don't have the time to go out and sell this model to employers. And I think that's where, you know, I know some larger practices, they have their own staff that goes out and sells this model. But for what we're doing at Second Door, that's what we've basically that's what we've been doing is we say, OK, we know you don't want to sell.
22:34 We know that's probably not your specialty and you don't have the time. Let us go and sell for you. And then when a contract comes in, you just you you work with us through the negotiation process. Right. When a contract comes in, you treat it the negotiated rate. And I think that's where, you know, if anyone's ever seen anything I've posted on LinkedIn, Like the work that Second Door is doing as a company, I think is really important to the future of the industry because I don't know of many other organizations that are going out there and selling that model. I know that there's some like MSOs, some of those types of organizations that are trying to do some of that. The hard part is...
23:17 now you're getting into understanding how all of this crazy insurance works, right? Like if I go to a self-insured employer, do I need prior off? Do I not? Am I under direct access laws? Am I not under direct access laws? Yes, it gets convoluted. I will say the answers to that are pretty simple. When a self-insured employer creates their plan, they get to dictate that. So if you go to an employer and you say, hey, we can save you twenty seven hundred dollars per claim. If you get your people into PT first, they can say, OK, we don't want prior. We just want our people to go that they can set that up because they're not they're they're not dictated by what insurance says.
23:59 They make their they make their decisions for their own plan. If a clinic owner is listening right now, more often than not, they're like, okay, I'm nodding, but I might feel stuck or there's a barrier. What's one practical first move you can give them to make this quarter? Something that checks something off the box, but does move the ball forward. Yeah, I would say the first thing I would encourage practice owners to do is sit down and make a list or a spreadsheet and think about all of the connections that you have in your area, that your staff has in the area, right? You may have treated a COO at a local company, right?
24:42 You may have treated someone who oversees the benefits of a self-insured employer in your area. Start with that list and look at who do I know? What connections do I have? And the reason I say start there is because it's like, how do you eat an elephant? Like one bite at a time, right? So like start there and see like, oh, actually, I have just myself. I have twenty connections between business networking groups and other connections in the area. My staff maybe even has more. There's real potential for this. And then I would, I would say reach out to someone like Second Door Health who is already has, has walked through that selling process, who is doing that selling process right now.
25:29 The people there, Scott Hebert, Ryan Kleps, like their heart is, is for the industry as well. They love, they love, they, Clinicians, they love practices. They want to see the industry succeed. And they have a ton of free resources online as well that you can go and download or even listen to their blogs just to be able to see, okay, is this something that's feasible for me? And if it isn't, There are other ways that you can pursue to make that possible, whether it be through someone like Second Door who's providing a network where you can band together and treat those types of contracts with employers, or whether that's joining an MSO if you're not a part of an MSO or an IPA, something like that.
26:16 So that's what I would say, first and foremost, start with who do i know and see that there's actually like it's probably easier than you think it is sure okay uh looking towards the future there's got to be pain if there's no pain people don't move what happens if independent clinics don't evolve i mean i'm i'm what are mistakes besides just straight up going out of business i mean yeah yeah i in in my opinion and I would say as someone who does not claim to be an expert on this matter, I've never owned a clinic, right?
26:56 I probably never will, although I would love to potentially own one in the future. I think that My hypothesis, just in my opinion, I would say in five years, it's going to be very, very hard for the majority of private outpatient practices to continue to operate. Those who are already at scale, I think that they may be able to continue. But with... where cost is going where reimbursement is and we're reaching this point where like even if we get a three percent increase in reimbursement what did inflation do this year killed it like yeah i mean inflation increased more than three percent so like you're still getting paid less right and so my my fear and my concern and why i'm i'm passionate about this type of model for physical therapy practices is i i want practice owners to have the freedom to treat how they want to treat.
27:58 If they want to start a practice and scale to twenty locations, I want them to have the ability to do that. If they want to start one single location or maybe just treat out of a gym, I want them to be able to do that as well. I think the problem with the fee for service model at the moment, is all of those things, who you treat, how you get paid, when you get paid, it's in somebody else's hands, right? And so going going direct to employer is hard. And it's scary because it's new. But what's the alternative? Sure. Keep waiting for someone else to make a change? Yeah. I mean, it doesn't matter, you know, even like the APTA, all of the great work that they do for lobbying, right?
28:41 You're going up against, is the APTA putting more money into to lobbying than pharmaceuticals? Are they? Are they? No. And so, of course, pharmaceuticals are going to push for GLP-Ls, and we'll probably see subsidies for people to get GLP-Ls way before we see any kind of subsidy for payment in physical therapy. And so we can continue to wait and see who is something actually going to change, or we can pave our own path. And I believe the path is there because employers can't continue to pay these outrageous costs of healthcare. Agreed. All right. Last thing we do on each episode is called the parting shot.
29:23 This is the parting shot. One last mic drop moment. No pressure. Just your legacy on the line. All right, big thanks to Sarah Health, the remote care platform helping clinics boost revenue, which is good without adding staff. Sarah automates daily patient check-ins via text. No app, no logins, just better outcomes. Simple way to meet those RTM requirements, improve follow-through, and actually get reimbursed for the care between visits. Easy to set up, simple to use, and patients love it. SarahHealth.com. That's S-A-R-A-Health.com. All right, parting shot, Matt. What do you got for me? Change the model. The model has to change.
30:03 If physical therapy wants to continue to be successful and to grow, not just survive, we've got to change the model. Love it. All right. Find them on LinkedIn. I'll give you a link in the show notes. Matthew Pratt. Appreciate your time, man. Appreciate it, Jimmy. Thank you. That's it for this one, but we're just getting warmed up. Smash follow, send it to a friend, or crank up the next episode. Want to go deeper? Hit us at pgpinecast.com. Or find us on YouTube and socials at pgpinecast. And legally, none of this was advice. It's for entertainment purposes only. Bullshit! See, Keith? We read the script. Happy now?