Can Debt Actually Help PTs Grow? Yes — Here's How.
In this bold and future-focused PT Breakfast Club, Jimmy, Dave, and Tony tackle debt, growth, AI, and intake innovation in physical therapy. From how to buy a practice using only $50K, to why patient forms need a serious AI upgrade, this episode hits hard on what matters now — and what’s coming next.
In This Episode:
- Debt as leverage vs debt as risk
- Buying vs building a PT practice
- Should students still go $100K+ into debt for a DPT?
- Why “clipboard intake” needs to die
- Using AI to personalize patient experience
- Could AI replace PTs… or just make them better?
Guest/Host Links:
<p>This episode is part of the <a href="/physical-therapy-business-podcast">Physical Therapy Business Podcast</a>, where physical therapists and clinic owners learn how to get more patients, improve operations, and grow their clinic without relying only on referrals.</p>
<p>Looking for more episodes? Explore the full <a href="/physical-therapy-business-podcast">Physical Therapy Business Podcast</a> for real-world strategies on physical therapy marketing, patient acquisition, and clinic growth.</p>
0:10 All right, good morning to PT Breakfast Club. Dave, Tony, we're serving up some bold ideas and some espresso this morning. I'm doing a double shot. We've got two big topics coming up, and I want to start with debt because you texted it this morning to the group chat, and I know very little about it, which is something you never hear on social media. Everyone has an opinion and cannot wait to tell you about it. I know very little about it, so I want you to go slow and explain it to me, and then you can go advanced. Well, I mean, I'm certainly not the expert by any means, but I figured, let me share how we've used debt for twenty five years. It's one of those things where I think it comes with a lot of emotional baggage.
0:51 It comes with a lot of history from our parents and how they handled that either positively or negatively. uh, spouses, future spouses. You know, one of the things that we, we are talking about right now with my boys is, Hey, if you're going to marry somebody, you have to understand their beliefs around finance and the debt that they're carrying. And of course, you know, big topic in media and politics is, Oh, guess what? You have to pay for the money you borrowed. Um, that's going to be a hot button, you know? So I just think debt from a business perspective is, it's probably the biggest lever we can pull.
1:31 Like, it is our opportunity to accelerate growth, to improve our business. And, you know, blanket statement people make is, debt is bad, stay away from it, don't ever borrow. That's BS. I mean, that's absurd. That's like saying a deadlift is bad for your back. It's like, you know... So here's a little context. And then I want to hear from the businessman himself, Dave Kittle. When we were starting out, we were down in South Florida. So we would see a third of our caseload, like things would drop by seventy percent August and September because all the snowbirds were gone.
2:14 And then we would triple our volume January, February, March, because all the snowbirds were there. And so we would have to borrow money to cover payroll during those months. But we knew that we were going to make that money back. We just had to float the payroll until everybody came back to town. We would borrow money to open new locations. We would borrow money to buy equipment. And we never had an issue, obviously, paying that money. We borrowed responsibly. And people talk about credit card debt. Last one, credit card debt, right? We had credit cards. I don't know if they're still doing this today. That would offer us zero interest, six months on thirty thousand dollars.
2:58 I'd snap that up every single time it was available. Because I could leverage that money to grow our business, to buy more equipment, to hire staff, to run ads, to do whatever we needed to do. And I just think now like people have been so scared of debt because of other people's mistakes. Where are you guys on this whole debt topic? Yeah, what do you got, Dave? Debt is great. You got the epidemic of credit card debt, which is one area of debt. And then you have, let's say you're going to take out a business loan. Let's say Jimmy and I, we're going to team up. We're going to buy Tony's Total Therapy Solutions.
3:41 Tony's going to ride off into the sunset. We're going to acquire Tony's practice. uh and let's just say um and can I just can I pull up a hypothetical number because I was doing some homework before we did this okay let's say let's say we agree let's let's say we agree it's a million dollar purchase price so and let's say jimmy and I we're gonna split it fifty fifty right so it's like okay well historically if we're not gonna use debt we're gonna jimmy's gonna pull up five hundred k if we're splitting the deal and I gotta find five hundred k in cash and we buy it right If you use a seven day loan program, which is a government backed or it's fifty percent government backed for loans. We only have to put down ten percent, so Jimmy only has to pull up, get fifty K. I have to get fifty K and that includes like all the purchase, the closing costs, all that.
4:30 So we only have to come up with one hundred K total to buy a million dollar business. Assuming that, and of course we have to submit all the financial documents and we have to show the banks that this business, Total Therapy Solutions, has a history of doing business and has stable financials and all that. So we submit all that. We have to submit our personal financial documents, all that. We can buy this million dollar business for a hundred K, which is ten percent down. And assuming we make all the debt payments over the coming months and years, and if we don't default on it or anything like that, then our return on cash or our return on equity is about a hundred and fifty percent per year.
5:11 people want to put in money and get, you know, seven to ten percent in a stock market. This is why there's a lot of folks doing business acquisitions, because we can turn our, you know, fifty K each or one hundred K each on a annualized basis of one hundred and fifty percent return year over year, which and if we're going to buy total total therapy solutions, that we are using debt, but it's different than having thirty thousand dollars of credit card debt where the the interest rate of the credit card is like whatever it is, twenty, thirty percent, twenty five percent, something like that depends on the credit card and the interest rates to buy this business right now. And even through COVID, it's kind of going up and down, but it's kind of around seven percent to eleven percent.
5:55 So the the cash flow of the business of Total Therapy Solutions We check all the numbers and the cashflow that the practice brings in every month covers the debt service payments to the bank. It does not come out of my pocket or Jimmy's pocket. The cashflow covers the debt service and the overhead, the rent, utilities, the payroll, all that. So all of that needs to be figured out And that's why it's extremely or very, very safe and why folks are able to acquire a business, covers the debt service, and it's an asset versus the credit card payment where you do thirty K in credit card debt.
6:37 And the only way that that's going to get settled is your own money coming out of your pocket or assuming your job or whatever money you're making from wherever to make those payments at a higher interest rate. So debt is great. Debt allows individuals, it could be a physical therapist that has student loan debt, and I'm not sure if they're able to, but it depends on the person. They potentially could take out let's say they have no money, they could find an uncle or the rich neighbor nearby, Tony Meritato, and raise money from him. They could raise a hundred thousand dollars from the neighbor, Tony Meritato, and go buy a different million dollar physical therapy practice. Tony's gonna have to, he gets some pro rata or whatever, but you could have a therapist that has student loan debt, get an investor like Tony, buy a million dollar physical therapy practice, And yet it's debt on the business and it's different than the personal debt.
7:31 So anyway, that that's long winded. That's kind of like how, how anyone can utilize debt and private equity companies do this on a big scale. But you can also do it on a smaller scale to acquire a business. And that's why debt is great because it allows someone that is unable to come up with the cash, but they can acquire an asset like this. And then obviously they want to grow it and work in it and expand it and all that. Yeah, I guess it's what we talk about in terms of good debt versus bad debt. If you have a plan for what you're going to be doing with that money and you're going to put it to use. Because, of course, when I sat down to talk about debt with you guys, I, of course, went to my teacher, which is now artificial intelligence. And I said, explain it to me like I'm in tenth grade because I feel like I'm perpetually in tenth grade.
8:15 I'm like, get it, get it really basic for me. But I but after it explained it to me, I sort of understood it. Right. which is if you buy a flashy car just to drive around, that's bad debt, right? How is that going to bring you money or pay for itself? It won't. Social media. Social media, right. You could do that. I mean, there was a guy in South Florida. Then it's a write-off. Yeah. Yeah, it's a write-off. So there are different ways to play it. While we're talking about debt, I actually just did pay off my student loans. So just shy of ten years. Nope, nope, no big deal. But that does feel good. So let me twist this a little bit because there are conversations.
8:56 Can you hear them? I can hear them right now. People convincing other people not to go into our profession, to go into our profession because of finances. Just yesterday, someone was asking â I'm a physical therapist assistant in Canada. I want to move to the US. I want to get my DPT. Should I do that? And of course, you can hear them. They come out of the woodwork and they can't wait to tell you their opinion. And that thread goes long. Is education a good debt in your opinion? Because that's taking on loans to then hopefully make more. Would you consider getting a DPT in twenty twenty five? Good debt or bad debt? Yes, and I think this is going to be controversial. I think it is still good debt. I have a lot of anecdotal experiences right now with buddies or younger guys that are coming out of college that are on different baseball teams that I'm playing with.
9:44 And a lot of these guys are either not able to find work. They're working at restaurants and that restaurant, on average, that restaurant is going to go away in two to three or five or whatever years, right? So that job is not a long-term job. It's just like they're using something to go work somewhere and pay their bills or whatever. So what type of career is that, respectfully? I still think it's great. I think, especially if you're going to go into ownership, absolutely. Slam dunk, absolutely. Because Otherwise, like, I don't know, like, where else can you do what we're doing? Like, I'm seeing, you know, one patient a month. right now because I'm able to get out of the business and created a business and all that.
10:25 I still think with the other options out there, I know Tony has spoken previously in the past couple of months about some of the like the sweaty startups or like the, you know, manual labor, manual labor is kind of having a little bit of a resurgence in the U S in terms of like, you know, long care and tree care and what else, you know, HVAC and plumbing and electrical and all that type of stuff. And that stuff is always going to be needed and is vital. Absolutely. Does that have less of a cost? Yes. Is it faster to get into the workforce through those methods? Yes, I think you can get into the workforce faster. But then isn't your upside capped? That's, in my opinion, I think it is.
11:06 I don't know. I got a buddy who's an apprentice electrician, and I think it's taking him seven years to â now, he's doing the apprentice model, so he's in the workforce, but his upside is pretty huge. I think it goes back â so I agree with everything Dave just said. I agree â sorry. I think the upside is uncapped because you could own an electrical business or you could run a bunch of other guys. And I think the ultimate deciding factor is what do you like doing? Like that's I mean, you can make a million dollars doing anything. What do you like doing? Tony, what were you going to say? I was just going to say, I think education in general is always a good investment, especially taking on younger because.
11:46 Dave has brought this point up, which is the best point anybody has ever made about getting a PT education. It's not about a job. It's not about the W-II. It's not about how much you're going to get paid an hour. It's about the knowledge of human anatomy, physiology, injury prevention, injury recovery. That's something that is going to affect you on a personal level. It's going to benefit you the rest of your entire life. You can't. The value of that is so outrageous. Even right now, like I've talked to you guys before, you know, I'm paying attention to my physiology at the age of fifty. I'm losing muscle. I'm gaining fat.
12:27 I haven't changed anything really in my lifestyle, but I'm like, what the heck is going on with my body? I feel like I'm better prepared to try different things now on my own than if I was a layperson who had none of this knowledge and I would have to go hire somebody, pay for something, run medical expenses up. Or do nothing. Or do nothing and then wait for something bad to happen. Yeah. So I think that's the huge value. But it's about the perspective of, okay, why are you becoming a physical therapist? If you think you're going to get a job, W-to, you know, all this stuff and make the money you need, probably not.
13:09 It's more about just the knowledge, going for the knowledge. And that's where I would say... make the money, then go to PT school. So you have the freedom to do whatever you want. Just put that money in the bank account. Since Jimmy is in the revenue cycle management world now, some of the stuff that people don't talk about enough is, okay, so back when we were in growth mode, If I knew I was going to open a new clinic location, especially when we were down in Florida, we would do things like defer income. So I've got, you know, November, December worth accounts receivable and it's Medicare claims. I know Medicare is backed by the government.
13:51 I know I'm going to get that money. if I'm going to open a new clinic in the next calendar year, I'm going to manage my revenue, my cashflow, and just defer collections. We would literally stop collecting. I would borrow money if I needed to, to cover payroll. And then in January or February, I would bring that money in. That's when I would submit my claims so that I would push that income to the next calendar year. which is going to be offset by the new clinic we're opening, by the capital expense and the investment we're making. Those are some of the things that I think a smaller provider, somebody who doesn't have experience, doesn't have people around them, they don't even know.
14:34 They're not even thinking. And then, of course, I've got the advantage of real estate. So I own my building. I pay rent to myself as tenant and landlord. That rent comes in. It's offset by depreciation. I can depreciate my commercial building over thirty nine and a half years or whatever the time frame is. That's that's a way for me to manage cash flow. Gives me an advantage over another clinic down the street who maybe doesn't own their real estate or their property. We have to be better. about understanding how money works if we want to be business owners and grow business and be in that world.
15:16 There it is, right? I don't know why I use this example a lot because I think it's a little bit easier to see, but just because you're the longest tenured nurse or you're the best nurse does not mean you're gonna be good at being the charge nurse, the nurse in charge. That is a different job, but many times we're promoted. So you might be the best clinician at a clinic and you might be frustrated by your growth opportunities and say, I'm gonna take my ball and go home. I'm gonna open my own clinic. And here's the great phrase that happens usually shortly before catastrophe. How hard could it be? I see what the boss does. He's not that sharp. I'm smarter than him. Patients respond better to me.
15:57 Why don't I make all of the monies? And then sometimes it works out and sometimes it doesn't. And I think that the people that it works out for, They understand what game that they're now playing and they understand that they're now a business owner and they need to play that game and act accordingly. And that's a big differentiator. Dave, when did you know? Did you know before going to PT school that you were going to do this or were you like, hey, I want to be a clinician or you just said, I'm going along with this because this feels good and I'll figure it out later? Did you have a plan? I mean, I was always doing little entrepreneurial things when I was younger, so I always had the intention to have a practice and a business. Then I got swept up with the tech and the apps and all that, and I did Vinitial for a bit, and then that was a tech startup failure and all that.
16:40 Yeah, but that's a business too. Yeah. I mean, that's still business, and that's still forward thinking. You've got to understand a giant market. Yeah, but I always had it in my head to have my own thing. Absolutely. Absolutely. Yeah. The way you asked that made me think I started identifying as an entrepreneur when I was six. Nice. You could take that in a couple of different ways. But but no, seriously, like I would, you know, wash cars in the neighborhood. I'd go collect leaves. I do all this kind of stuff. And then I'd start getting neighborhood kids into my business like that. You're just born with that. You know it from the beginning.
17:21 Let me ask you, that was my question is, I did that too. I was the kid who would do two things. Number one, start knocking on doors and be like, we're playing baseball. Let's go. Grab it. Fifteen minutes, get like the galvanizer, right? And then I was the kid who was like, I'd like some pizza right now. There's a bunch of snow on driveways. So how could we organize and put our collective use â Did you, but you and I both gravitated towards bringing other people in. I never wanted to do any of these things alone. Like to me, it was if we're doing, I'll do it with one other person, ten other people, but never alone. Were you two similar to that? Like always looking for a partner? Because I always was and am. No.
18:01 No, no, that, I mean, that's why we're like, that's why I'm an entrepreneur and I did these things, you know, I wasn't looking to have the shared risk. I, whether it was, you know, even Tony's, um, you know, washing cars or trying to make money when he's six years old or whatever. Uh, but whether it was, um, even initial, like started that a hundred percent myself and then concierge pain relief started that a hundred percent myself. So, um, I think maybe that signals like you're a different version of a potential entrepreneur or maybe you're not an entrepreneur. I don't know. But like, yeah, I just know like it takes the it takes just the one person to be the go getter. They assume all the risks. They have the energy, the ambition and all that. So they get after it.
18:42 What do you think, Tony? Yeah, I never wanted a partner. I wanted people working under me. I wanted to direct and I wanted to delegate. But I never wanted a partner at the top. Like I always felt and to this day and I acknowledge like this is probably a shortcoming of mine that I would be far more advanced than I am. But I'm just one of those people that I feel like my idea is always the best idea. I acknowledge your idea might be equally good. Dave's ideas are equally good. But I don't want to do Dave's idea. I want to do my idea. I would rather do my idea and be less successful than do Dave's idea more successful because it's not my idea.
19:25 It's not what I want to do. Yeah. I was always looking for people to come with me. I think that's what I was looking for. You know, I didn't need that person to be at the top with me, but I wanted to, I didn't want to be doing the idea or executing alone. That for me, wasn't, wasn't really exciting. Yeah. Are you an only child? I forget. No, I got a brother. Okay. I was an only child. I did everything alone. I loved doing everything alone. I think there was like a. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. A. Everything before and everything after I love. I never even thought I'd be married. I never thought I'd have kids. I'm happy that I do. And I I am. But seriously, like I could easily be that hermit in a in a shelter living my life completely solo.
20:14 Dave, you got you got siblings? We're getting deep here. So yeah, we are getting deep. So I have a half brother and a half sister, but I was basically raised as an only child like they were older. So you know, they were in a different house. So I was just about to type in a chat GBT like if there's any correlation between having one child and entrepreneurial world or you know, entrepreneurialism. Real quick, Scott. Scott's here. One of the best fans we've got of the show. He said parents should teach their children at an early age. The best pro athlete all start at an early age. I'm already I'm already asking my thirteen month old if you've started a business yet.
20:56 I mean, you can't even fully speak. But I'm like, hey, did you start a business? You know, you got to move along. You got to do something. You got to go wash cars. You got to do something. Diapers ain't cheap. Before we started today, I told Jimmy, my eighth graders had their graduation yesterday and one of their requirements, the teachers made them write letters to their parents. And so I was reading the letter last night and both of them kind of had a couple sentences in there where they were so thankful that their parents are working and putting them through school. But they also said that they love that their mom and dad are teaching them about business and how to make money in the future. Like it is, it's a core tenant.
21:37 And I think this is one of those things that, you know, if, if a parent's never done it and they don't have exposure to it, young people need to find it somewhere. And I think they want it, whether I think it's an innate human quality, humans want to be creative, humans want to build, humans want to exchange value for value. And so, you know, kids are looking for it and and if we give them those opportunities uh they're gonna explore them did you want to talk about that uh ar uh idea or the ar situation tell me about it what I made it I made an intro for dave's profitability problems like three weeks ago I've been dying to use it I'm gonna use it whether we're doing it or not You were talking about in the group chat a bunch of companies offering to buy your accounts receivable for a percentage of the value.
22:32 It's another form of borrowing what we're talking about with debt. And you said if you had effective ads, you could borrow money today to pay for the ads, use the ads to generate cash flow this week, and use that cash flow to pay back the ads and keep the profits. Yeah, I brought it up, but let's kick it over to Dave because Dave runs way more ads than me. So Dave, do you want to talk about this? We talked about selling our accounts receivable or financing off of our accounts receivable before. What can you share about that? Yeah, I mean, well, even so I use Stripe for our credit card processor and they're always sending me emails like you instantly qualify for, you know, thirty or sixty or a hundred, whatever grand and I don't usually look at it because it's like... I mean, they take the repayment off of the future cash flow going through the credit card processor from my practice.
23:24 So there are a bunch of businesses that are always running ads that are saying, you know, hey, we'll... what is it like? Not a margin call. It's like they'll offer you cash now and it almost, it might almost sound like a loan shark kind of thing, like breaking thumbs. But yeah, they can offer cash upfront and they'll take a, they take the margin of the, between what they're paying you upfront and then they're making more, but they have better systems like a Phyllis or whatever their system is to capture the rest of that reimbursement in the long term.
24:04 I haven't seen it for the cash of like other like in a business to use it for ads or use it for payroll or whatever uh although usually it is for like you know payroll and then again I I'm just not I just don't know too much about this world because it does kind of kind of it kind of gets into the whole you know loan sharking thing a little bit and maybe it's like the most white collar maybe the most ethical up and up side of the like the loan sharking kind of thing um am I am i Thinking about it correctly, Tony, or am I? Yeah, I would say it's less available in your world because you're more cash pay. It's more in my world. And so if I know that I've got one hundred thousand sitting in accounts receivable for Medicare, I know that money is going to come in.
24:51 Maybe I bill three hundred thousand. I know one hundred thousand is going to come in. It's guaranteed by the federal government. But if I needed access to that capital now, there are companies out there that I could say, hey, I've got a hundred thousand that I'm expected to collect in the next thirty days from Medicare. I need eighty thousand now. They will give me the eighty thousand. They will collect the full hundred thousand. So they make the profit on the twenty percent difference there. But then I could take that eighty thousand. I could use it if I know that I want to run an ad campaign. I know I have a profitable ad and this is where people get stuck.
25:34 They don't have profitable ads. I don't have profitable ads. Dave can say if I put one hundred bucks in, I'm going to get three hundred bucks out. I can't do that yet. I haven't cracked that nut yet. But in theory, if I knew that I could, I would snatch that eighty thousand today instead of waiting thirty days. I would put it into something that's going to turn eighty thousand into two hundred and forty thousand. And I would just, you know, ramp that until it stops working. And at some point it doesn't work anymore. The ads don't work anymore. I've exhausted my local geography if I'm not doing telehealth. Um, so, you know, like Jimmy said, there's lots of ways to finance.
26:15 We're financing either with our labor. If I don't want to borrow money, but I'm saying, well, I'm going to work and I'm going to bootstrap and I'm going to do it all myself, but it's going to take me ten years longer. You're still financing. You're just financing it with your time and labor. Yeah. But there are so many unspoken, unknown strategies out there that you could use to grow. I think the mistakes that we make is we don't necessarily know enough about it. We don't have proof of concept. We're not sure. And then we borrow a little bit. We get scared. We fail at it. And then we never borrow again. You know, I picked up a fifty pound bag of horse feed.
26:59 I hurt my back. I'm never going to lift fifty pounds again for the rest of my life. yeah I think it's I think it's we're very tied emotionally to money and and fear myself right so I mean the room I'm sitting in I renovated when I bought this house because hey how hard could it be I bought a house and I owned a hammer and a screwdriver right now luckily I had a buddy who like loves doing this stuff and was good at it but If you had told me how much it was going to cost to get this, to pay someone else to do it, I would have said, you're nuts. And then I went and did it. And halfway through it, I'm sitting here covered in dirt and sweat, and I hate doing it. I was like, I now understand why people pay to renovate a kitchen. But I'm paying for it one way or another.
27:41 And that is a side view of what you're doing. The thing is, if you have a plan for it, that's the thing where I think a lot of people, right? Would you let a seventeen year old? Tony, how old are your kids? They're going to a couple and go to high school. Sixteen, fourteen, fourteen and twelve. Would you in a year? Would you let the seventeen year old borrow two hundred thousand dollars on their own? But you're doing that with college. You're saying, sure, good luck. Sign right here and we'll do that. So college feels like it's bowling with guardrails, but there's a lot of risk there. And do you understand what seven percent interest is over two hundred thousand dollars? The reason I paid off my student loans. I owed seventy two thousand dollars left.
28:23 And I was like, I had the money, but I like to have money because what if something goes sideways? Right. And then I went to chat GPT. Now, I understand a little bit about math, but I sat down one day. I was like, you know what? I'm going to crunch these numbers. I'm actually going to do this. I would have I would have had to pay two hundred and fifty thousand dollars to pay off. Seventy seventy was the principal. It would have been one hundred and eighty thousand dollars in interest, paying two thousand dollars a month for a decade. I paid it off the next day. As soon as I understood two grand a month, you know what I could be doing with two grand a month? Dave, making money. That's what I'm going to be doing right now. So I risked it. I said, you know what? No, to me, that's bad debt. I'm going to pay that off and I'm going to take a thousand dollars a month and invest it.
29:07 And the thousand dollars a month, the other half, I'm going to put it in my bank account. So to me, that looked like a good move. It felt like a good move. And I feel better every morning that I wake up now and don't have damn student loans anymore. Answer Scott's question. I'm curious, too. What happened to the basement renovation, the basement studio? Basement studio is done. Here's the problem. So, all right, let's rewind. So the basement studio was Jim. And then let's put somewhere where Jimmy doesn't have to do his live streams at his kitchen table. Jim's done. I'll do a full tour. I'd say it's ninety percent that I got put a few more lights down there. The problem is it's dark. It's a basement, right? I got a lot of lights, but I've got skylights up here. I got windows in all corners.
29:48 So I was using it and then realized I didn't like being down there for that. So I'm moving all of the desk equipment upstairs and I'm going to make the gym bigger. So renovated the gym slash studio, realized I didn't really like it that much, but didn't cost me much because I'm still just going to use it as a bigger gym downstairs. Yeah. Now, before we go to the next segment from Jimmy, full disclosure, we are not financial experts. We are not lawyers. We're not giving you financial advice. We are simply saying what we did. Speak to your accountant and your lawyer. That's right. All right, Jimmy, let's steal this segment. I have a meeting with a new accountant today, actually.
30:28 All right, time for you to steal the strategy. And I want to see if you two, because you guys are owners of clinics, virtual or brick and mortar, could you steal this today? Okay. All right, steal this strategy. I wanna take something that's ugly and invisible that people fricking hate doing. I just took my dad to a doctor's appointment and here's the thing. You walk into a clinic and what's the first thing you do? Here. Take this clipboard, take this clipboard and fill out the same information. Thirty seven times over and over. Even if you filled it out. Oh, yeah. But our system doesn't comply with this and that. OK, great. But what if you twisted it?
31:09 And I understand there's information you've got to get. Number one, you can use agents to make phone calls to get that information ahead of time. That's great. You can have people scan cards. What's the O.R.C. optical reader technology, whatever. Optical character recognition, OCR. Take a picture of this and just take that information. But what if you could use the intake psychologically? What if you could create personality driven intake to point out, right? What if it didn't just collect basic information, but actually gave your team a cheat code to connect with every patient on day one. Now the strategy came from slim chickens, slim chickens. It's a chicken restaurant. They've been using AI and behavioral insights to turn ads from boring to customized.
31:56 So it's using AI and they're, their customer behavior to actually change the ads that they're showing to people geographically, right? So this is making the invisible visible. So what I wanna do is pull personality and motivation insights from new patients before their eval. Think about this as like Spotify wrapped for physical therapy and healthcare. What if you could find out about a patient's coaching style, motivators, stress triggers, learning preferences? before ever saying hello. Now, psychologically, I looked it up, personalization builds trust, identity-based goals boost compliance, and autonomy fuels motivation.
32:36 Those are three things we want to build, trust, compliance, motivation. So it's like taking a personality test, but you could make it fun. Use like a type form or a jot form, use ChatGPT. I would actually suggest using a mix of open-ended, and multiple choice questions because I looked it up and psychologically they say that gives you the best insights. So I would say better connections, we say lead to better outcomes, more completed plans of care and fewer drop-offs and patients feel like, oh damn, these people get me. Now I know a great therapist can get this in an eval or visit one, two or three, but what if you could find out about that person or things you might not by asking those questions beforehand?
33:19 So this was turning that intake into something tactical and usable. Interesting. Very interesting. Question would be with the tablet or whatever with this process, Jimmy, is there five questions, ten questions? How are you pulling this information out of me? And would that be annoying to most like the average patient? Yeah, I would probably do it before the person ever came in and you could do it a couple different ways. You can do it with an AI phone call right now. You could do it through a series of text messages or you could do it with a tablet on intake. We're seeing people do that right now. I'd say ideally you wouldn't want to ask more than seven to ten questions at absolute most.
34:01 And it could also be it could also learn. This could be a decision tree. If you under if you could teach it, like if we understand what this person's motivators, we have the information we need. Don't ask any more questions. We're done here. Like questions, like I have some example questions. How do you like to be coached? Directing to the point, encouraging, collaborative, data-driven and precise. What motivates you? Reaching a goal, seeing visible progress, accountability from others. Preferred communication style, email, text, in-person only. Like things that annoy people, like how am I supposed to know that? It really drives me nuts when you always email me and I never see my emails. You didn't tell me that, but I never asked, and I didn't give you the option. For example, at Athelas, something I thought was kind of cool Instead of everything being digital, we offer people who are talking about accounts receivable, we can send out mailers with a QR code.
34:52 Some people of a certain age or just communication style prefer getting things in paper, myself included. I uncheck all the things from my bank to say that your statements go digital. I like to see it and be reminded to check it. And I get like blind to email in my inbox. So I like that. So that's a preference for me. And if that went away, I'm pissed. And Wells Fargo tries to fool me into it. because every once in a while, they don't want to, they don't want to send it to you. Well, what they'll do is when I log in, they don't want to mail it to you. They want to save on the postage and all that. So when I log in, they make me unselect and save versus like, so it's a damn trick. And I have to stop and be like, wait a minute.
35:32 I want to get the paper. So I have to unselect the thing. Cause of course they want to save a nickel times, I don't know. It's boring and it's necessary. It's fifty five damn questions anyway. What if you could sneak in seven that could give you insights to someone's personality to boost those things afterwards? I don't know if you guys remember, we talked about this months ago, maybe even a year ago. We did. When I was first getting familiar with AI scribes, I was saying how if this is going to listen to my conversation, it can identify characteristics within the personality of the patient. It could give me an assessment of this person.
36:16 AI will understand our personalities better than we will understand our personalities better. So I want it'll tell me like, hey, you should do this or you should do that. You should understand this anxiety or this fear. So much of what I do on a first visit is not about the patient care. It's not about the evaluation. It's not about any of that stuff. It's about understanding the personality. Like, is this a high anxiety or low anxiety person? Is this person fearful? Is this person sleeping? Is this person medicated? Like, what is all the other stuff? Then I, you know, who cares about a four out of five manual muscle test on adult doesn't matter.
36:58 AI will do that in amazing ways. And I think we could probably learn. And I don't know, I'm just guessing from counselors, from psychiatry and psychology. And they've taken that so far online. Like I thought I saw a number of like thirty or forty percent is done through telehealth for counseling. they've got to have the advanced technology and understanding of identifying these personalities, then getting back information on what this person needs, positive reinforcement, negative reinforcement, what's going to work best for them, what's going to motivate them. And, and, We see it in Facebook, right? We see it in all the social media platforms.
37:39 What makes this addictive? What triggers that dopamine release? How can I bring that into my physical therapy practice? Because I promise you, you can take all the best con eds in the world. If you know how to trigger that dopamine release, your patient's never going to cancel. Your patient's going to get a positive outcome. You are going to be the best therapist in the world if you trigger that dopamine enough times, but not too many times. I like this as a potential tool. My initial assumption would be that these busier in-network practices across the country probably won't buy this tool. They probably won't care about it because they're just like, you know, it's...
38:23 whatever their co-pay is to attract the patient to come in and they're you know they're good enough however what you're talking about on the front end of like learning more about this person and then trying to you could leverage this with like making sure that there's better completions of you know plans of care I think this would be way better for the out-of-network self-pay practices as opposed to in-network. If you pitch this to Tony, if you didn't know Tony, Tony, would this catch your eye? Would you then start paying, I don't know, whatever, a hundred dollars a month or whatever for this type of service? I can tell you if I see something that has a material difference in my operations, I'll pay in a heartbeat.
39:04 I absolutely will. What is, how do you make, what's material difference in your operations? Like make things easier, make things like, what is like, how do you, what is that? No extra work and more money. More money, more money. No extra work. No extra work first. But let me ask you this. And more money. Is this too far, honestly? Because what I'm saying here is, listen, by finding out these things about patience, later on, you're probably going to be able to measure this. There's a delay. There's a delay. So that's my question. Is the distance too far for you to invest? I guess the price would have to be right. If you were like, listen, for... you know x number of dollars like it's a dollar a patient right that you use it with or some person like we'll do it that way and if you're going to use it high volume but then could you build something into your ehr like I would do it with fifty percent of your patients in the first six months and fifty percent of your patients don't and then compare length of stay right could you do that that a b test it that way there you go yeah so that could be like a pilot or whatever a paid The value of it mostly talks about the difference between price and value and time.
40:11 If I could give you a thousand dollars and have a six pack abs today, I'm going to do it. But if you're going to tell me I give you a thousand dollars and I have to eat less and exercise more and do all these things in six months from now, maybe I get a six pack. I'm not going to do it. Um, with something like this, I think there's that, how long is this going to take me? And is there another way to make this work? Like, is this something that I can run? Okay. So Athelas has, um, agents or AI, you know, telephone calls, right? Is this something that I could just today I can run an AI to call patients who are scheduled for new evaluations, go through a series of three questions, not And at the end of those three questions, how many of these patients are going to buy my resource pack before they come for my evaluation?
41:05 So my resource pack has a set of pulleys, an ice pack, and a TENS unit. And are they going to put a hundred dollars in my bank account before they even come for the eval? Because the AI scribe Ask the right questions and pose this as if you really want the best outcomes. These are the products that we recommend to make you feel better today. You know, like that's immediate return on the investment. And I think that's something that would buy build buy in for this. so let's let's ask right so well a couple things that came to mind but if you had to ask three questions you could not ask for it doesn't matter here's what uh max our producer says are the three must-have questions I want your thoughts number one what is something specific you want to get back to doing that's number one although I feel like dave you asked that that's already in what you ask right Number two, how do you like to be coached or motivated?
42:03 This tells the therapist how to talk to the patient. Push, support, explain, or cheerlead. I hate being cheerleaded. I do like being coached. I do like understanding how far I am from the finish line. And number three, what usually gets in the way of you sticking with a routine? Gives you a heads up on compliance. So focusing on those three, those would be the three different questions that Max, our producer, the AI thinks we should ask. So I think that's what it thinks we should ask. I don't think those are effective questions. And I've been binge watching my six hundred pound life. What is that? I am unfamiliar.
42:44 I mean, I'm assuming based on the title, I can figure it out. But seriously, you've never seen my six hundred pound life. OK, it's a TV. Please don't don't screen share it. Do not screen share it. I'm not, but you gotta, like any therapist watching this has gotta go watch those episodes. So these are individuals that have accumulated a lot of body weight. They're going to this surgeon, Dr. Now, and they wanna get either gastric bypass or a lap band or whatever it is that he does. And so it takes you behind the scenes. You see what the patient says to the doctor And then you see the reality of the patient's life when the doctor is not around. And I think we see this in physical therapy constantly.
43:27 Right. Patient walks in the door. They tell me one thing. They tell me what they think I want to hear. Yeah. Then they do something likely very different behind the scenes, whether they realize it or not. So my problem with those questions is. These are really, really good episodes. My problem with those questions is the person is going to tell you what they think you want to hear or what they want the reality to be, but it's not the reality. I want the AI to ask questions that the patient can't get wrong. In other words... You know, I want to get into what have you actually paid for? What have you actually purchased?
44:08 And I shared a post recently. I'm like, look, the best patients are the ones who are already doing everything right. They're already eating well. They're not telling me they're eating well. They're actually eating well. They're already working out. They're already researching their condition. They're already doing everything. This person is going to get better no matter what. All I can do is screw it up. Right. These are the people that I want. So I want an AI that understands human behavior enough that they're not asking questions. They're observing what the person is already doing, plugging them into an algorithm, and then giving the information back. which is what Facebook does.
44:49 Instagram does. Facebook doesn't ask you what you want to see. Facebook starts showing you stuff. And based on how you respond to what it shows you, it gives you more of that. That's the AI that I want. That's going to grow my business. So could you use something that was predictive? So something that you would ask a question and then the second question would only be based on the answer the first? Is that what I mean? I would say probably still not asking questions. Figure out a way to get the information without ever asking the question. Like, I don't know, I don't know how we just, we just need the AI to maybe we'll talk to Apple, we'll get a little, a little earbud that plugs into their brain.
45:30 And then you know, we find out their true, the true likelihood of their willingness to change their behavior and invest time and money into their health and wellness. I mean, look, imagine a credit card company. They have unreasonable amounts of information about what we actually buy, what we're actually putting our dollars behind. They are the ones that have the best predictive information about how to approach this person for better healthcare decisions. It's got that whole big data thing that became popular years ago that This is where we're going to get the information, because I still think if you ask me what I want, even if I think I know what I want, it's not really what I want.
46:17 I don't know what I want. It's a blind spot for me. You have to see what I've done. What are the decisions that I've made? Like, I want to eat less sugar, but I still go get a piece of cheesecake. Right. So you've got to find what is it that's driving me the physiology to eat that cheesecake. Even when I know I don't want to eat the cheesecake, my body is telling me to eat the cheesecake. I understand Tony's stance on it might not even be questions that actually is so important. high level iq of understanding this topic because I'm I'm typing in chat gpt as we're talking like you know what are the best three questions to actually understand someone's likelihood of behavior change and all that and it said you know what happens if nothing changes in the next three to six months right so then they have to emotionally describe like then they're still stuck in that rut of whatever uh or why now as the second question or on a scale from one to ten, how committed are you to doing what it takes, including time, effort and financial investment to fix this?
47:16 So those are those are awesome. I love these. I love the ones Jimmy was talking about. But I also I'm also now stepping back and I'm like, of course, Tony's right, like most of the time. And if let's say if you had a patient, if they would have to agree to this, but you're talking about the credit cards and the financial history, could a personal trainer or a nutritionist or a dietitian or a physical therapist or whatever have some ai program that the patient approves of and then you're using ai to pull in like where do they go for food what you know restaurants or grubhub or mcdonald's versus some healthy greek food or whatever could that actually change behavior more because then they have oversight into their actual transactions the things that they're buying on amazon that are you know wasting money and they're not I don't know, no one buys DVDs anymore, but on Amazon Prime, every night they're buying a new digital rental on Amazon Movies or whatever it is, Amazon Video, as opposed to, I don't know, buying like resistant bands and new shoes for walking or whatever.
48:30 Tony, I'm just so impressed with you. Like, I'm thinking like, yeah, of course, it's question based. And I'm going to double double down on what we're talking about. And these are the questions that we ask anyway. But then it's like, wow, like Tony comes at this different angle. And it's like that actually makes the most sense to try to get into someone's brain and not through a questions based framework. So real quick, you know, what's funny about it is I remember my wife and I, when we went through, like when we were getting ready to be married, we were engaged. We went through this thing through the church and we had to like answer these questions. And both of us came out of it saying the same thing. We're like, Why are you asking me these questions? We know what the answer is supposed to be.
49:12 We're going to give you the answer that it's supposed to be. And for personality tests and all of those kinds of tests, I just, I always remember from a childhood, I know what you want me to say. I'm going to say what you want me to say. But Dave, you made me think of this. So there are apps, biometric tracking apps right now, continuous glucose monitors. We look at all of these step counters and stuff. Give me access to that or, and this is where I think AI replaces a physical therapist, Or give me a personal AI that can analyze my behavior across multiple platforms.
49:56 So what am I buying? What am I doing? How am I moving? When does my heart rate, my physiology change? When does my heart rate go up? What was I doing at that moment that made me excited and made me happy? Now, how do I leverage that dopamine response? I'm going to keep saying that. To enhance the behavior that I think I want, at least, you know, so if I want to feel good about making these choices, how am I feeling good right now? And how do I replicate that into feeling good in future choices? I don't think a human physical therapist can ever do that by themselves. They either need to be augmented by AI or they're going to be replaced by AI to create that kind of solution.
50:41 Yeah, too much information would be needed. But we have apps like this. I use rocket money, right? It tracks what I'm spending. It can actually do AI phone calls. to at t to negotiate for me to try to negotiate you know ten dollars off of my monthly bill does that like every three months because I told it to and I pay like six bucks a month but look what rocket money has access to everything that I'm buying and I bet you in the terms of service it's like by the way we can sell that information when I was working in a research lab at mount sinai I remember the people in the lab saying the data from this product that we're creating or researching is going to be worth more than all the money that they'll make from the product being sold.
51:25 Even if they make millions, the data is going to be worth hundreds of millions or a billion. And I remember being like, I don't understand that and then watching what they could do with that information. So you could have... I was reading an article the other day. I know the data they call from an Apple Watch, like dirty data. It's pretty good, but it's not precise enough. But it's pretty damn good in terms of activity and what you're doing. Could you make it easy to track what you're eating or doing at that particular moment? I mean, I have to think that we're there at this point just â Is someone motivated to take all that information together? Because now your treatment plan changes. When I was doing my last Ironman, I hired a coach, not because I didn't know how to train for an Ironman.
52:06 I'd done a couple before, but I wanted to get better. So I realized I had to change something. So he didn't just give me a plan for the month and say, I'll see you in a month. Like we changed it every two or three days based on how I did and how I was feeling or how I was sleeping or how much I was traveling for work. Could AI adapt to that? I mean, I don't even think I need to ask that out loud. You know, the answer is yes. Yeah. Do we have another segment? I didn't have another segment. Real quick, with that app, are we going to call it the Jimmy app? The Jimmy app? I mean, that service, though, is originally, again, we're talking about the questions-based framework, and then we're talking about pulling in someone's transactions and purchase history.
52:50 I'm actually fascinated with it, and it is maybe bigger than just, obviously, it's just bigger than physical therapy. Yeah, so the ultimate app, right, would be access to everything that you do, your biometric data from your Apple Watch, your search history, your food, what you're buying, but more importantly, what you're eating and when do things spike and things like that. That's like, I don't know. That's the government oversight. But I might now change... where the app is, since we have an AI scribe and there's fifty million of them, right? And some of them are better than others or different than others. Why wouldn't you use an AI agent to have this phone call? Like we give options like answer the phone call now or don't or answer these questions at a kiosk or don't.
53:34 Or do you bake this into the first conversation of the evaluation and now train the AI like, hey, part of these questions or I need you to get some semblance of the motivation of of this patient out of this to tell the the clinician how to style this and when you give suggestions for the treatment in subsequent visits that needs to be taken into consideration not just their diagnosis their psychology so I don't know does this have to live in the emr or is this part of the intake or is this always part of the process and should always be part of the process I think it should always be part of the process. I think good therapists inherently do this to some level already.
54:18 I modify my treatment based on the personality and based on the response. You know, so when I get an angry, frustrated, fearful individual who walks into my clinic, Everything that I was planning on doing goes out the window. I completely changed the way I'm approaching this individual. I'm matching their personality. I'm matching their tone. I'm trying to build trust. And what were you going to say? No, no, keep going. Whereas if I get that super jolly, super friendly little old lady who loves everybody and just wants to talk, I'm going to approach that very differently. I definitely think AI can figure that stuff out over the phone, by voice, and even to the point of, okay, if we're going to have this AI conversation, I think it can definitely know, does this person want to talk to me, the AI, longer?
55:11 Or does this person want to wrap up this conversation? And so for us to say like three questions, that's stupid because it should adjust to the context of the situation. Correct. Just had an idea. Hey, listen, Dave asking for a recommendation might be a little awkward from Dave's part. It might also be a little awkward from the person you're asking because now I feel obligated, right? It's a good way to get recommendations, but is it a good recommendation? asking someone else to ask is a different thing. So after visit four, could you have an AI agent trained and say, listen, we just want to see what your thoughts are. Is Dave a good fit for you? Like, would you want to maybe consider a different therapist or how's it going? Oh, it's going great.
55:52 Great. This, this sounds overwhelmingly positive. Now's the time to ask for. Yeah. a a a recommendation or what's the word I'm looking for how come I can't come up with it uh uh leave a review review review leave a google review like I'm losing nouns for some reason at nine twenty seven in the morning um leave a review is this overwhelmingly negative how can we make this better like so could you train it could be part of the ongoing process but it's not dave doing it it's a third party so you feel like a chance to be a little bit more honest maybe it's even better than it's ai because now I don't feel like I'm trashing dave I'm talking to a computer but I do want to you want that feedback that person probably would like the result of that feedback make it easier Let's look at parting shots.
56:39 One of the things I want to talk about next week is do we want patients, clients, prospects to know they're talking to an AI? Now, I know there's laws. I know there's regulations. I know compliance is going to come into play. But just in a perfect world where we could actually make our own decisions for ourselves, Would there be an advantage to the person on the phone knowing this is a robot I'm talking to? Or if the AI is at the level that it's imperceptible, I wonder if there is benefit to, you know, let the person on the phone just assume this is a human that I'm talking to. Real quick, my parting shot and then Dave and then Jimmy, you close it out.
57:21 So today was a great conversation. Guys, if you don't have mentorship, if you don't have people around you that are willing to share their personal experiences, share what worked, what didn't work, even if it's not going to work for you. That's why you get on social media and connect with people like us, people like Stephen Dunn, people like Scott. Like there are so many people at all stages of business development. go find them, connect with them, answer questions, talk to each other, build those relationships. You will advance so much faster if you have other people that are ahead of you and behind you. Man, parting shot earlier in the conversation, leverage is all about for entrepreneurship, leveraging other people's money in that acquisition example, or leveraging other people's time with hiring team members and employees.
58:10 That's why I'm able to only treat one patient a month or whatever. So thankful for that. But it took a lot of effort and time to get to that point. But that was part one of today. And then the second part about the fascinating navigation that we just did through the the idea stages of a potential technology or app for the intake or just for, I don't know, patient experience overall. And then also a sidebar, I just had Jerry Durham on the Dave Kittle show. It's coming out soon. We covered, Tony, exactly what you just said. So next Thursday, we'll talk about it, about the AI agents on the phones and all that. We covered it, but I have some opinions and thoughts on it. So I'll take it over to Jimmy.
58:51 Yeah, I would yes say on both of those things and say the idea is really great, but are you... if you think you're going to hide that idea because it's worth so much and you don't want to give it out um like the idea I you know gave out this morning it's sort of nothing and I think the conversation we had probably if I was going to take this idea to market I think even the twenty minute conversation we had sped that process up by six to eight months if if just I was sitting here looking at it right but again the idea versus execution light years difference right an idea is worth kind of nothing unless you're willing to do something about it there's a guy who's got an instagram account who just walks around and says um do you have a business idea right that's his whole thing and he just walks around the streets and just jams a mic a microphone in people's faces but he this is a brilliant media move because there he's I think he's from like a vc company where he's trying to show, not tell, hey, if you've got a great idea and you pitch it and you're willing to go all in on it, we're willing to fund it.
59:48 So what's your big idea? Don't keep it to yourself. I think that sort of yes ands what Tony is saying in terms of building the network. So we'll be back on Thursday. I don't know why Tony is saying we want to talk about that next week. I thought today was Thursday. Today is Tuesday, Tony. We are only at Tuesday. But check out the Dave Kittle show, Total Therapy Solutions, and we'll see you on the Pinecast pretty soon. Gentlemen, have a great day. You too, guys.