The Best Conversations Happen At Happy Hour, Welcome to Ours!
Dec. 16, 2024

Breaking Free from Big Insurance

Breaking Free from Big Insurance
Breaking Free from Big Insurance
PT Pintcast
Breaking Free from Big Insurance

Tired of skyrocketing health insurance costs with little transparency?


Chapters & Timestamps

00:00 – Intro: Who is Gentry Harris?

03:18 – What Does "Breaking Free from Insurance" Mean?

06:50 – The Basics of Self-Funded Plans

11:24 – Pros & Cons: Fully Insured vs. Self-Funded

18:01 – The Role of TPAs: Your Health Plan Quarterback

21:37 – How PBMs Slash Drug Costs

28:14 – Success Stories: Real Savings for Clinics

33:45 – The Power of Transparency and Control

40:00 – First Steps for Practice Owners

45:20 – Gentry’s Parting Shot


In this episode, Gentry Harris of The Mahoney Group breaks down how PT practice owners can reclaim control over one of their biggest expenses—health insurance. Gentry dives into:


The differences between fully insured plans and self-funded plans

How third-party administrators (TPAs) and pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) can drive down costs

The pros and cons of self-funding vs. traditional plans

Real-world examples of saving thousands through innovative approaches like international drug sourcing

Why business owners hold the key to disrupting the status quo in healthcare

If you're a clinic owner frustrated with health insurance headaches, this episode is a must-listen. Discover actionable strategies to cut costs, improve employee benefits, and optimize your bottom line.


<p>This episode is part of the <a href="/physical-therapy-business-podcast">Physical Therapy Business Podcast</a>, where physical therapists and clinic owners learn how to get more patients, improve operations, and grow their clinic without relying only on referrals.</p>

<p>Looking for more episodes? Explore the full <a href="/physical-therapy-business-podcast">Physical Therapy Business Podcast</a> for real-world strategies on physical therapy marketing, patient acquisition, and clinic growth.</p>

Transcript

0:01 Okay. Gentry, welcome to the podcast, man. Thanks for coming on. Great to be here, man. You were standing in the wrong place at the right time or the right place at the wrong time because you were standing next to me at the APTA PPS conference. And I'm super shy and I'll just start conversations with anybody. And I'm like, hey, man, you know, where are you? I think I was like, where are you a PT? And you're like, well, I'm not. I'm like, OK, cool. Then why are you here? That's interesting. So how do you typically explain if someone like me were to ask you, like, you know, what do you do or where are you a PT? You're like, I'm not. What do you do? Yeah, after twenty years, I've had a lot of time to think of the answer to that question, Jimmy. So typically I tell people and they're a little shocked by this.

0:43 I think some of them, maybe not so much the PTs, but I just tell them I help people get away from the big, bad insurance companies. that, in my opinion, have destroyed our health care system. And obviously, that causes a lot of curiosity. But that's my common answer now is, you know, in the past, there weren't a lot of options. And I think there are more and more options becoming available. All right. So that's what you do. But how do you do that? How do you help people get away from the big, bad insurance company? Now, we'll zoom in just a little bit. Yeah, for sure. So depending on the size of the group, right, it's harder when you don't have as many employees, but when you have around a hundred or more employees, it opens up options to use third-party administrators that can adjudicate claims.

1:37 You can really tailor Your plan, you can get stop loss insurance to protect your company. You can choose a pharmacy benefit manager that's not one of the big three that's owned by the insurance companies or vice versa. So that's what I do is I create tailor-made solutions when it comes to health plans. So if you're someone, if you're a clinic or a group of clinics with a hundred, we'll just, we'll just drop a line at a hundred imaginary line at a hundred or more. You get to now you can come in and create or sort of get to start to choose your own adventure health plan for that organization. Yeah. Yeah, that's right. So we've had three this year alone.

2:18 One of my clients, Tim Spooner, a lot of people know him. He's kind of a pioneer here in Phoenix, Scottsdale area. He referred me to kind of his group, his practice group of different business owners across the country. And so we're fortunate to work with several of them this year. And we moved them from a fully insured plan to a self-funded plan. Two of them are in California, one up in Washington state, and we just finished up another one in Pennsylvania. So it's not state specific. We're licensed and all the fifty states can work with anybody. So that's cool. All right. So what problems does this alleviate? I'm guessing cost is if you talk cost, you got people's attention.

3:00 But whatever doors is it open? So I'm guessing, I don't want to put words in your mouth, but I'm guessing it reduces costs or at least to maybe make risk a little bit lower. What else? Like what are the things on the benefit side of doing this? What would you call this? Self-funded insurance for your company, for your organization? Exactly. So it's self-funded insurance, but you can go to a self-funded plan through what we call a book or I'm going to use that term Blue Cross United Signet. Now, those are the big insurance companies across the country. But obviously, it does reduce costs. Usually health insurance is the second or third highest line item on a company's P&L.

3:41 And this helps reduce that overall cost. It also improves the quality. There's a misconception in our country, unfortunately, that if I pay more, the quality is higher. And in health insurance, it's actually the inverse of that. It's the surgeons that do something more are better at it. And so they can charge less versus charging more. Now, where the cost comes in is these hospital systems, they like to refer to their surgeons and a surgery inside a hospital setting is much more expensive than a surgery in an ambulatory surgical center.

4:22 So- That's one of the benefits and the quality is significantly higher. So not only does it reduce the cost, but it also improves the quality for the patients, you know, and the members on the health plan. All right, so pros and cons of each approach, let's just go make sure we'll stay with the basics before we go deeper. So the difference is that the difference are fully insured plans, am I am I safe to call them like the typical plans, right, fully insured plans? Yes. Versus self-funding. Let's just do pros and cons. Give them the quick high level because if someone really wants to dig into this, they're going to call you and we'll put your information on there and we'll share that. But do pros and cons of each.

5:04 Yeah. So let's start with the cons first. The cons of a fully insured plan is you're subject to whatever the carrier gives you, right? In terms of your plan design, deductibles, co-pays, out-of-pocket. You can't do anything innovative within a fully insured plan. It is what it is. We call it shelf plans, right? They're filed with the state. They're mandated. They have all of the different requirements, right? So that's a huge con. Another huge con of fully insured is you get no reporting at all. Wait, no what? Say that again. Yeah. No reporting of data of where your money is going.

5:45 How is my money being spent by the members on my plan? I get zero data. Now, with a hundred or more employees, you get limited data, but you don't get full access to the data or the reporting in a fully insured plan. So that's another con. Why is understanding that? So the business owner you're talking about, the person who's funding the health insurance, why would you want that information? And then why can't we get it? So in every other aspect of business, a business owner has access to how things are being, where costs are going. Sure. And if you don't know where costs are going, you can't control a cost. And so I think it's on purpose.

6:25 Um, you know, I'm not going to go on the conspiracy theories or anything like that, but, um, You don't get reporting and they hide behind HIPAA. The insurance companies say, well, if you have a hundred employees, you could identify people and be discriminatory against them. That's not correct. That's not true. So a big downfall of a fully insured plan is you get very limited reporting and because of that you can't control where your dollars are being spent and the quality of it either so yeah I mean you mentioned that inverse proportion is we hear that every we hear that every every once in a while we definitely hear it every four years in terms of the us is the lo you know the biggest spender in healthcare and we're thirtieth on the list in this and forty second and fifty third um so that's definitely true all right so that's that's number one con blind I have no idea where this money is going I just keep throwing money into a hole I don't know how it's being spent.

7:17 And then, oh, magically next year or the next time my contract is up, it costs more and maybe I'm offered less. That's correct. So let me just give you one example of one of the plans that we worked with this year. We had an employee that was on a very high prescription drug. We would have never gotten this information from their fully insured carrier up in Washington State. And this individual, we were able to assist them to get this drug sourced internationally from Canada, right north of Washington State. And they were paying the plan, meaning the overall cost for this drug was around six thousand dollars a month.

7:59 And we were able to get it through an independent pharmacy benefit manager who works with a Canadian pharmacy. for roughly fifteen hundred dollars a month. So a significant difference. Right. By just going and being innovative, getting the same drug, it's shipped to the employee. There's no member disruption, you know. So it's it's very simple. There are lots of little levers and buttons to push within a self-funded health plan that you cannot do within a fully insured plan. Well, you couldn't do it, but there's no reason for the fully insured plan to even look into that. Right. There's no reason. Well, that's right. Claims equal premium. So the higher the claims are, the higher the premium that the insurance company can charge.

8:44 And so there isn't any incentive. And you have stockholders, shareholders that they have to increase their pricing in order to look better on their earnings. So there really isn't any incentive versus a self-funded plan. The employer has every incentive to control the costs without disrupting the members, right? Or at least working with the members to try to find other solutions and say, this health plan is our health plan. The better we utilize the plan, the better we save money by getting drugs outside of the country if we can, that directly competes with your W-II income.

9:25 So if we're more wise with the way that we spend our current dollars, we can offer better benefits and we can reduce the costs that we charge to you. All right. So you throw a few pros and cons. What else jumps to mind or what else do you typically I always ask what what what passes the eyebrow test? What when Gentry mentions it makes like a practice owner go, OK, didn't think about that. Yeah, well, obviously the cost, we do an analysis, right, for everybody that we start working with or want to, you know, start working with us. And we look at the overall, you know, benefits. Typically the first year, we don't change the benefits at all because we want to be able to gather that data within the first year, year and a half.

10:07 So then we can really start looking at are deductibles appropriate? Are copays? Are out of pocket? What other solutions can we be looking at? For example, diabetes. There are lots of different diabetes programs and vendors out there that can drastically reduce the cost and improve the health of employees. And so Those are the things that we're looking at. It's really a strategy of we have the data. Now we can start creating the plan based on your employee population. The great thing about these private practice groups are most of these employees are young. They're out of school. They're starting their families and they're healthy.

10:48 And so why be pooled with sicker risks when you've got an employee population that's much healthier than the general population in our country? Um, there's another acronym. We can't get too many, too many, too many acronyms in healthcare. Can't get enough of them. Uh, TPAs, third party administrators. You said they can be a key alternative to these traditional insurance companies. What are they? How do they operate? How do they operate differently? And what advantages can this third party administrator offer a business owner? Yeah, great question. So I like to think of a third party administrator as the quarterback to the plan.

11:29 So think about like an insurance company, customer service, ID cards, adjudicating claims. They're the ones that basically are running the plan and are the kind of the front forward facing of to the employees. But it's extremely important because they're the ones that implement the stop loss insurance and the pharmacy benefit manager and the medical management. And so it's really key that you have a team of people on the third party administrator front that understand what the plan is trying to accomplish. And kind of the Bible to the plan is what we call the summary plan document, right?

12:11 It's the Bible to the planet says for every little thing, what's covered and what's not covered and how things will be paid. And so you've got your network, you've got your pharmacy benefit manager, stop loss, medical management. The TPA is the one that's in charge of managing and coordinating all of those different pieces because what most people don't know, in your Blue Cross plan or your United plan, you have all of those different players right now. You just never see them. right? With a third party administrator and an unbundled self-funded plan, meaning completely independent of any insurance company out there, you get to see how all of those different pieces function and you get to choose best in class.

12:55 Right now we have a very limited market when it comes to fully insured. Maybe in any state you have four or five players. I can go out to twenty five or thirty different stop loss carriers. There are hundreds of pharmacy benefit managers. So you're really opening up your field to other options instead of just four or five. Okay, more acronyms, more letters. They went from TPAs to PBMs. Those are pharmacy benefit managers. You talked about an example of changing a cost from six thousand dollars a month for one employee to fifteen, right? So pharmacy benefit managers and stop loss protection, which you'll have to explain to me a little bit.

13:37 Talk to me like I'm an idiot because this is a little out of my comfort zone, but I want to learn it. So PBMs and stop loss protection play crucial roles in controlling costs. Walk us through what those things are, how those elements work together and where business owners can go wrong and right with their strategy. Yeah, so let's start first with stop loss insurance. So there are two different types of stop loss insurance. You have specific and you have aggregate. Specific is insurance on any one individual that has a catastrophic claim, like cancer, heart condition, serious back fusion, right? These high preemie babies, those are examples of a catastrophic claim on any one individual It could be a spouse or a child.

14:26 And so you buy specific stop loss insurance to protect the business, the plan from any one individual bankrupting the plan. So we use the specific stop loss to cover any one individual. And then we have aggregate or umbrella insurance in the case that we have lots of claims, just lots of claims from multiple individuals. So you're covering yourself from one individual and you're covering yourself as a whole using the aggregate insurance. Now, the insurance companies, when you get your renewal from a fully insured carrier, they increase your renewal on everything, right?

15:11 The administration of the plan, pharmacy benefits, medical management. On a self-funded plan, your renewal is usually just on your stop loss. There may be some minor increases to the other pieces of the plan, but you're not getting... ten or fifteen percent increase on the full premium that you're paying it's typically on just the stop loss and you're also paying taxes right on your full premium with a self-funded plan you're just paying the taxes on the insurance premium for the stop loss insurance so and then there are different contracts you know with a stop loss insurance you know you have what's called uh twelve twelve which is incurred in twelve months or paid in twelve months or you have a twelve twenty four.

16:00 I know I'm kind of getting in the weeds here, but incurred in the first twelve months, paid in the full twenty four months. So you have different contracts with a stop loss carrier because as most physical therapy, private practices know, when you submit that claim, it's not always paid immediately or sometimes it takes a while for the claim to be submitted. So you want to make sure that you're covered by that stop loss agreement in case it gets filed at the end of the year and claims are filed like January, February, March. You don't want to be not having coverage and be exposed to those claims. So that's kind of a generality of what the stop loss serves as.

16:43 And again, we have access to probably more than fifty. I know I said twenty. That's usually what we try to narrow it down to. But there's a lot of options when it comes to stop loss insurance. And our goal is to buy the least amount of insurance. So as the plan performs, we actually raise that deductible on the specific one individual. It's not the deductible that the employee pays. It's the deductible that the plan has as a risk, a cap. So on a hundred life group, you may have a specific deductible of anywhere from, you know, fifty thousand or seventy five thousand per member that's on the plan. And then you have, you know, that aggregate umbrella insurance for the rest of the group.

17:29 you already sort of talked about pbms so that's a pharmacy benefit manager how they come into play in terms of thinking creatively about costs is that like an accurate you know that that person's job is to think creatively or think more responsibly about costs so um Maybe people have heard, maybe they haven't. FTC is actually suing a lot of the pharmacy benefit managers. We have three major pharmacy benefit managers that source eighty percent of all drugs in our country. Express Scripts, CVS and Optum. And CVS owns Aetna. Optum is owned by United Healthcare and Express Scripts is owned by Cigna.

18:13 So those three are all pooled together and they collude and they help each other to make more profit. And so these pharmacy benefit managers, they'll have what are called formularies. They're lists of drugs that are covered or not covered. And they steer people into the different drugs that they get paid higher rebates on. So maybe you've heard of rebates, maybe you haven't. But a rebate is basically just a kickback on higher cost drugs, usually specialty drugs. And so those rebates are paid back to the fully insured plan. They're not paid to the employer on a self-funded plan. Those rebates come back to the plan to help offset future costs.

18:57 So that's one major difference between an independent pharmacy benefit manager, one that's not owned by one of the large insurance companies and the three that I talked about. Another thing that they do is these pharmacy benefit managers, the ones that are creative, they're looking for ways to reduce costs. So you may have seen at the end of commercials at night, right? These drug commercials for specialty drugs, Sovaldi, Manjaro, the GLP-I's are very popular right now. At the end, they'll say, you may qualify for assistance for this drug. Well, what that is, is these pharmacy benefit managers have found a way to work with these manufacturers to basically find programs where those costs can be reduced both for the member on the plan, as well as for the plan sponsor, the employer.

19:57 So their patients assistance programs, their copay assistance programs, and an independent pharmacy benefit manager will actually look at those drugs, work with the member to see if they qualify for those programs and reduce their overall cost. versus the larger pharmacy benefit managers typically don't offer those services. Some of them are starting to do it more. The other big thing that I talked about was international sourcing. So these independent pharmacy benefit managers will work with third parties to find the drugs that are same manufacturer, same labeling. It's just at a lower cost and shipping it from Canada, New Zealand, United Kingdom.

20:41 We have some plans that actually get drugs from Mexico. So we look at everything and see what makes the most sense and what the plan sponsor feels comfortable with and roll out a strategy of communication to the employees to help them with that. Just feels like more transparency, more control. When you go into anything that's sort of franchised out, right? Something so huge, you're going to have less control. It'll feel like you can save some money, but when you start to do the math, it doesn't really look like that. So it feels like you're just getting this off the shelf thing, so it should cost me less and be better. And we're saying, again, that's sort of inversely proportional. The more you pay, you're not getting the best thing.

21:23 That's correct. Yeah. And employers, I think, feel like they're kind of stuck, right? They play this game every year. I've played it where every couple of years they have to switch insurance companies. They get a ten or fifteen percent and we negotiate it down to seven. It's like this game back and forth. And you always ask them, why am I getting an increase? Well, you have some high claimants and it's due to trend. And A lot of employers just fed up with it. They're like, I'm tired of running on the rat wheel and I wanna do something different. I wanna have control and get information that gives me more control. And this is more of a necessary evil, unnecessary annoyance. Like not many PT practice owners open to practice to think about the third most expensive thing on their line item, which is health insurance for their employees.

22:12 They wanna offer this. They wanna create a great culture, a great place to work. And they wanna have motivated employees. And they've got to become an expert in this every time a contract negotiation begins or every time a contract ends and another one begins. And that sucks. But if you're one of these big companies, if you're one of those big three you mentioned, you're just going on math. and you knowing what what else is being offered so you're saying this is my best offer take it or leave it well now there's there's these different options so for business owners listening we'll talk about real world impact for the practice owners who are like okay either I need to pay attention to this or I've been hit with this health insurance costs are a huge line item as you mentioned the I think you said the third most expensive one typically whatever two salaries and overhead Yeah, and then health insurance.

22:58 What's one immediate step practice owners can take to start getting better control over those insurance costs? And then how can your approach you're talking about make a tangible difference in their bottom line, their P&L statements? Yeah, this is going to sound like a kind of a strange answer. OK, get get your broker to start looking outside of the book as the major insurance companies. There's lots of companies that are starting to develop and even for smaller companies. Right. Not just the hundred plus, but there are other companies that are coming to market. that can be viable options, right? So one of the things that drives down costs significantly is what's called reference-based pricing.

23:44 So instead of having a network of doctors like Blue Cross, United, Aetna, or Cigna, you can actually work with one of these, I call them bundled, non-carrier-owned solutions. And there are various ones in different states out there now. where they can do what's called a level-funded plan, where you're still paying a monthly premium into the plan. And then at the end of the year, you can look at how your plan is performed. You get limited data. It's better than what you get with the major insurance carriers, but it's still limited. But it's kind of a middle step, right? If you're not ready to go down the full self-funded plan that I've been talking about, there are other options kind of middle of the road called level-funded carriers, right?

24:31 And there are more and more coming about, you know, I was just at the Rosetta Fest Health Rosetta Conference a few months ago in DC, and there were probably three or four new ones that I'd never heard of before. So I think that that's something that, you know, smaller groups, it's a solution that they should be looking at. The risk, there is no risk for them versus with a self-funded plan, they have taken on a little bit more risk on that specific deductible. So that would be just, You have more power than you think you have as a business owner. And you really need to start pushing these advisors and brokers like myself that may not be aware that there are other options out there when there truly are.

25:14 Love it. All right. So if someone is out there nodding, number one, how can they get in touch with you? Like throw out the easiest way, website, email. What would you tell people to call you? How do they get you? Yeah. The best way to get ahold of me is just send me a text on my cell phone. Um, four eight Oh five one eight three nine four two emails, simple JD Harris at Mahoney group.com. And then my LinkedIn profile Gentry with a J. So I'm the only Gentry Harris out there that I'm aware of. Smart man. All right. Last thing we do on an episode, we call it the parting shot. What's, what's your last idea? Mic drop moment, soapbox statement. You want to leave with the audience? What do you got? Yeah, so like I said before, I think business owners are the sleeping giant when it comes to health care.

26:01 You have more power than you think you have. And don't be afraid to try new things. There are some things out there that can be damaging and not good solutions, but just find an advisor that has experience in self-funding, ask them pointed questions, ask them for references, look on LinkedIn, talk to other PT practices that are doing self-funding. and really do some homework because at the end of the day, it's extremely advantageous. There is a solution to fix healthcare. We've just been told otherwise. And as Jeff Gold, one of the direct primary care doctors said at a conference that I attended, we are addicted to a system that is broken.

26:46 And it's time for us to get off of the addiction of health insurance and fully insured plans. Well said. All right, Gentry. Thanks for making this at least palatable, even for someone like me, understanding like, listen, first of all, if someone takes something away, there's another option. You don't have to just go with these, what'd you call them? Bucas again? Blue Cross Blue Shield, United Healthcare. So there's alternatives. You don't have to. And there's people along the way to help you to figure that thing out. So you don't always have to go with these big giants and the off the shelf things. Gentry, thanks for making this understandable, even digestible for someone like me, man. Thanks, Jimmy. Appreciate your time, man.