Are Physical Therapists Really Doctors? Unpacking the Research
In this episode, we sit down with Lance Mabry from High Point University to discuss groundbreaking research on why only 20% of doctorally-trained physical therapists use the title 'Doctor' during patient introductions. We dive deep into the implications this has for patient trust, therapeutic alliance, and the future of the physical therapy profession. Lance and his co-authors, Dr. Justin Martino and Dr. James Smoliga, explore key demographic trends, legal considerations, and how the use of the 'Doctor' title can advance the profession.
Want to know more about Physical Therapists using their “Doctor” Title?
Read the latest article in the Journal of Manual and Manipulative Therapy
Link: https://doi.org/10.1080/10669817.2024.2396706
Get $25 off Musculoskeletal Imaging CME
Taught by Dr. Mabry, PT at Redefine Health Education
Coupon Code: mskimaging2425
Link: https://redefinehealthed.com/imaging/
Key Topics Discussed:
- Why only 20% of physical therapists use the title 'Doctor'
- The impact of using 'Doctor' on patient trust and therapeutic alliance
- Gender and experience differences in title usage
- Legal implications and best practices for using the 'Doctor' title in PT
- Future trends and how PTs can embrace the change
Special Guest:
- Lance Mabry, PT, DPT, OCS, FAAOMPT – Assistant Professor at High Point University
<p>This episode is part of the <a href="/physical-therapy-business-podcast">Physical Therapy Business Podcast</a>, where physical therapists and clinic owners learn how to get more patients, improve operations, and grow their clinic without relying only on referrals.</p>
<p>Looking for more episodes? Explore the full <a href="/physical-therapy-business-podcast">Physical Therapy Business Podcast</a> for real-world strategies on physical therapy marketing, patient acquisition, and clinic growth.</p>
0:00 Yeah. Lance is back on the podcast. Lance from High Point University with the branded background. Welcome back to the show. Thank you. Thank you. It's good being back. Before we hit record, I said, what's new? You said more research. So we're talking about research today, but we're going to make it applicable, right? Like, I think some people get turned off on research because it can be dense. But there's a new tool out there. I took the research that we're going to talk about today. I copied it. I put it into ChatGPT and I said, explain it to me like I'm in eighth grade. And then I understood everything. You have to send that to me. I'm excited to read it. It's nice and easy. But even better than ChatGPT, I got the person who's responsible with it.
0:41 This wasn't just you. I always want to make sure we mention co-authors, people who helped before we kick it in. So who was with you on this particular piece? Yes. So the primary author is Justin Martino. He was a student at High Point while he matriculated under me and recently graduated. He's now Dr. Martino, physical therapist. And Dr. James Smoliga, who's a veterinarian, is working for Tufts University. So that's a cool mix. Title of the piece, which we're going to put a link in the show notes, Journal of Manual and Manipulative Therapy. But the title, I love it. I even did like a Twitter poll on it too. And that was one of the selections. You have to send me that too, yeah.
1:21 Yeah. So the title is not... that kind of doctor an exploratory study on doctor of physical therapy patient introductions in the united states so first let's just start with like why'd you do this what was the there's got to be a pain point right there's got to be a question you want answered what was the instigating sort of problem question whatever that started you three from going down this road and looking into this Yeah. So I think for me personally, I went through the same journey as many other physical therapists. I now earned this degree, this doctorate degree. Am I going to use this title? Am I Lance? Am I Dr. Mabry? Who am I? And I think just like the rest of us, I tried different things out with patients to see what worked.
2:08 And in the end, I found that you know, using the doctor title was actually very influential in helping patients be more adherent to their process, you know, less of a friction point with, you know, I'm just, you know, the patient saying, I'm just here, you know, treading water until I go back to the surgeon, you know, and And using that title kind of fixed a lot of those things and really helped with that patient experience. So in talking to other providers that have gone through the same journey, they kind of found the same thing, that using that doctoral title has been influential in patient care. So this is a question that's been burning inside me for years is, you know, very, very clearly, you know, in the first phase of PT literature, we are all comparing patients.
2:52 you know, manual therapy to exercise and doing those kind of things. Now we're getting into this pain science contextual factors, you know, what we say matters to patients. And and my student at the time, Justin Martino, came up to me and said he had a passion. He wanted to do this. And I said, Well, let's let's get it done. This is right in my alley. Let's, let's figure it out. So, uh, you know, the first step we had to figure out before we take you to the clinic, because we do want to set up a clinical trial on this is, uh, who's even using it. So our physical therapist using the doctoral title and, and if so, why, and, and, you know, just figuring out, you know, what, what metrics should we actually use when we, when we hit the clinic with this question? Now, if you're watching this on YouTube or if you're listening on a podcast, I would love for you to chime in.
3:33 It's easier on YouTube if you just drop it below. If you're a PT, do you use the title or not? And even if you're not a PT, would you expect them, if they're doctorally trained, to use it or not? And then we can get into some of the reasons, and let's get into the reasons. So, Lance, your research found that only about twenty percent of physical therapists are using the term doctor. during the patient introductions? Why do you think so many are hesitant to use it? And what are some of the top reasons that actually that you found that sway those who do? Well, I think one of the first things we found was setting was a factor. So those that are working in pelvic health were actually very likely or comparably more likely to use that title doctor than those that weren't.
4:20 Orthopedics and sports was also similarly more higher compared to others. And as we would expect, lower areas was pediatrics, geriatrics, acute care, SNF, Actually, private practice was high. So the setting seemed to make a difference in whether or not people were using this or not. Because there are so many settings and so many patient populations, we didn't enter that into any kind of regression, but we did see huge differences in that part. Uh, therapeutic alliance is a major factor in, in that decision to use or not to use. I feel like I'm quoting Shakespeare. Um, help us understand how using or not using the term doctor can impact patient trust and communication.
5:08 And have you seen any specific examples where this actually made a difference? Yeah, so we actually asked the PTs, both those that were using the title and those that weren't, why were they using it and why weren't they using it? So in those that were using the title, two of the things that pulled out as being um highly influential was that in that was to demonstrate expertise to their patients and also to advance the profession and that kind of ties to that therapeutic alliance piece so when you look at the research patients when you use the title doctor in front of patients they have a greater belief in the competence of the provider.
5:51 They trust them more. They believe they are more caring and compassionate. The research isn't expansive in this, but there is this kind of suggestion that using your earned title doctor does positively impact that patient alliance through trust. However, it also popped out on those that don't use the title doctor. So those that don't use the title, their top reason was they felt that they believed it could confuse patients. And then the second one was therapeutic alliance. So both those that are using the title and not using title are both using it or not using it. because they believe it it improves therapeutic alliance and only one of those things I mean it's possible that both are true so imagine you know maybe in a setting like pediatrics not using the title improves that therapeutic alliance versus in I don't know sports it improves therapeutic alliance so it's possible that both of those things are true um but we just don't know so um that's going to be one of the things you know if we're hoping to get this into the clinic um that's going to be one of the things we're going to look into is does that influence trust does it influence therapeutic alliance.
6:59 And hopefully if we can extrapolate that out and actually track things like adherence and outcomes and things of that matter. Let's zoom in a little bit too. Your study revealed some interesting demographic trends, such as older PTs and males being more likely to use the title and the opposite being true, right? Females and younger PTs may be less likely. Yeah. What do you think drive these differences and how might it influence future generations of PTs? Yeah, well, frankly, some of these were surprising. So one of the things I hear in chat rooms was everybody was saying, oh, it's easier for the younger PTs. It's easier for PTs now to use Docker than it was years ago when this first started. And if I had to guess what the research showed, is I would have guessed that it would have been that way, that newer PTs would have been more likely to use it and maybe older, comparably less so.
7:51 When we actually looked into the comments from the respondents, one of the things we saw was it took PTs a while of practice before they felt like they, quote, earned it. That it didn't feel right for them at first and it took them a while to get there. And frankly, that was my... journey as well. My first few weeks, months, years out of school, I didn't use the title doctor, and it wasn't until it felt comfortable with me that I started using it. The other one was male gender. So there is some research coming out now. Physical therapy has been predominantly a female profession. I mean, since its inception, men weren't invited when the PT profession was first made.
8:38 so now some of the research that's coming out that's showing that women are uh you know have lesser leadership titles have lesser uh pay in physical therapy it was interesting to see that they are also less likely to use this uh this title of doctor versus men aren't so I I do think that there's some uh psychological factors that that could be of value to tease out there that's probably beyond my love my skill set to tease those out but Um, but I do think that that's, uh, an interesting parallel to some of the other research we have coming out. Yeah. Uh, there's also some legal implications. People bring this up. This makes its rounds on Twitter every once in a while involving healthcare professionals and the use of this title doctor.
9:20 Help us understand more about that. How might PTs navigate these challenges without causing the things that most of the clinicians are trying to avoid patient confusion or facing legal consequences? We want to do it for the right reasons in the right way. Sure. Well, if you look at the one thing, always check with your, if you're ever worried, always look at your state board and your practice act. So one thing I'll say to PTs is what we can and can't do does not live solely in the practice act. This isn't something I realized until I actually started digging in here. A lot of the granular stuff on what we can and can't do is spelled out by board rules and board opinions. So making sure you're familiar with those is a value. uh however um those that get more detailed on this pretty much say that you have to pair the word physical therapist with doctors so uh you know when I'm meeting my patients hello I'm dr mabry I'm a physical therapist um and I haven't had any issues with patient confusion I've used it on inpatient I've used it outpatient I haven't had anybody ask me for a colonoscopy yet so um so tying that physical therapist again look at your state but tying that physical therapist to the introduction is uh is important um uh there is a case that came out recently of a doctor of nurse practitioner that got sued because she used her title her title doctor and interestingly she actually worked in a clinic that was owned by a physician and she was encouraged by the owner and the physician to use that title doctor so there was a lawsuit that came out about it my understanding is there's uh
10:52 that that case might come up again that the the Final outcome of the case is still pending. I'm curious to see where this shakes out. But but I do think that ultimately that the the word doctor is going to be very difficult to defend because it's been used in academia before it was used in medicine. Yeah. As topics like this evolves, what changes would you you personally like to see in the profession regarding title usage and what role do you think it could play in advancing the profession as a whole? Well, I think the big thing is it all comes down to patients, right? So I posted this this research on online and one of the things I saw was something to the effect of this.
11:33 This this is not a clinical question. And frankly, to me, I am a clinician. I I have more than a decade in the clinic. I still see patients. And to me, it's a hugely clinical question. That contextual factor and how that influences patients and their outcomes is hugely important. So where I would like to see this going is, one, we have to figure out, is this a net positive for patients overall? Does that vary by population? Does that vary by age? Does that vary by demographic? Not just in the PTs, but also in their patients. And then how can that help guide our care and help influence our care? So if it does in fact match what the other research and other professions show, that using the title doctor does positively influence trust or belief in trust, belief in caring, belief in competence, then I think we should probably start being that change in our profession.
12:32 And one of the things I see, you know, you and I are both on social media. One of the things I see is a lot of people, you know, complain about the profession and complain about changes they want to see in the profession. But the same people that are complaining aren't willing to actually Make the changes. So let's make the changes. Right. So if I mean, if we are going to diminish ourselves as a profession, then we're going to be if we're if we're less in the eyes of ourselves, then we're certainly going to be less in the eyes of others. Yeah. Yeah. Uh, no one questions Dr. Seuss. No one's ever asked him for his credentials, but we just truck that Dr. Seuss is in fact a full doctor, not that kind of doctor and exploratory study on doctor of physical therapy, patient introductions in the United States.
13:14 Uh, again, we'll share that link in the show notes in the description below some other findings on top of, we said at the top of the show, only one in five PTs use doctor title around around twenty percent. Uh, older PTs and male PTs are more likely to use the title. Also, experience matters to PTs who completed extra training like a residency program were more likely to use the title. However, PTs who serve as clinical instructors or CIs who train student PTs were less likely to use the title. So imagine you're a student. you'd be very confused. Of course, you're going to come out very, you know, you've got, you've got, you know, professors in class telling you maybe instructing one thing, then you go to a CI, it's a different thing.
13:55 You're watching what everyone else is doing. No wonder students might, and younger physical therapists would, would be confused. I think everybody's kind of going through this journey. Are we going to use this? Are we not going to use this? I think everybody at some point asks themselves this question. And when we do control for the other two major factors, age and gender, those that completed the residency program more likely. But as you said, those that serve as CIs were less likely to use the term a doctor. So this was very much an exploratory study. That's in the title that it's an exploratory study. And as we dug into this, there were things that, you know, usually as a researcher, you build a study and you kind of know what the outcome is going to be before you even do the study.
14:40 There were things that shook out about this that surprised me. Why are CIs less likely to use their title doctor? Is it, you know, does it kind of predispose which people choose to be CIs or which clinics are minimal to CIs? That was something that shook out that we just did not expect. Yeah, some other information, reasons for using or not using the title. We mentioned some of those before, why some PTs use the doctor title to show expertise because they feel like they've earned the title, which they have, and to help advance the profession of physical therapy. If we all do this, it will change perception and perception could be reality and why others might avoid it. Concerns about confusing patients, which I can empathize with, or worrying that using the title might hurt their relationship with patients, that therapeutic alliance.
15:28 Anything I didn't ask about this or that came up that surprised you in a good or interesting way? Yeah. So you mentioned about advancing the profession. So when you look at some of the research that we found on this is from optometry. So optometry has the same question. If optometrists, which are now doctors, the research suggests, hey, we should be using this title to advance our profession. um interestingly one of our co-authors on this james dr james malaga is a veterinarian and uh he said that veterinarians were the uh were the original not that kind of doctors that veterinarians went through this same journey of are we are we doctors are we not doctors should we you know are we doctors with our patients and you know they've kind of gotten to the other other end of that and yes they are and you know, looking at podiatrists kind of going through the same journey.
16:19 You know, there's there are now surgical and non-surgical podiatrists. Podiatrists years ago were doing a lot with, you know, inserts and lifts and various other things. But now podiatrists are in the operating room and they're performing surgery. They don't have an MD. They don't have a DO. They have a DPM, a doctor of podiatric medicine. um they have come out on the other end and nobody questions when they use the the title doctor uh or not that I've seen so I think our journey is going the same way um I think we are going to come out on the other side where we're probably using it more than not um uh so just one clarifying point so it's not twenty percent of pts but it's twenty percent of doctorally trained pts understood um because uh obviously masters and bachelors trained pts probably can't use that title but um but when you look at them when you look at the curve of innovations uh there's the uh the early adapters and then once you hit a certain threshold then things kind of really take off um when you look at where we are with twenty percent of dpts uh using it um I think we're kind of really close to that threshold where you're gonna see this uh you're gonna see this change and it's gonna be it's gonna be a fast change I believe Right.
17:28 Yeah. Mentioning veterinarians and podiatrists, veterinarians being the, you know, the guinea pig. See what I did there. And then podiatrists, right. Blazing the trails. You know, Dr. Scholl's, you know, teaching us the way of making sure we understand who those who those professionals are. Lance, last thing we do on the show, as you are aware, is the parting shot. What would you want to leave with the audience about what you learned with your co-authors on this? Oh, man. So I think the big thing is, for me, is embrace the change. So when we started digging into the background on this, I didn't expect to find so much research on using the title Docker and that it would be positive.
18:12 You know, I grew up with you don't wear a white coat because it makes people's blood pressures high, the white coat syndrome. That's what I expected to see when I when I dug in the research on this to write the introduction. And as we started digging in more and more now, again, there's not abundant research But the research seemed overwhelmingly positive in favor of using the title doctor, which which surprised me. So so ultimately, I would say for those that are that are running in the opposite direction and saying it's for therapeutic alliance or the other thing I see is, you know, those that use the title doctor are just arrogant. And that's not what I'm seeing at all. You know, the top. know two of the top three reasons is you know kind of that build that trust with patients through expertise that therapeutic alliance and advancing the professions this is all very altruistic stuff so I think we need to to lower our swords a little bit and and start listening to both sides and see where we are and and and and then again just taking that next step the next step is let's take this clinic let's take it to the clinic and let's let's see what shakes out with patients I'm the kind of research guy that I love it goes on, but I'm probably not going to do it anytime soon.
19:19 But there's probably room for this. Again, this is a non-research guy asking a research guy. There's probably room for this. We probably should ask patients, right? There's someone should be doing some research where they ask patients their perceptions. So we're not guessing at what the other half of this therapeutic alliance is thinking or feeling. Yeah, no. And that's what we're hoping to do next. So what I'd like to see next, we haven't we haven't set up the study. We haven't called an IRB. What I'd like to do next is take it to a patient and dichotomize, randomize what the therapist is introducing themselves as. Are they introducing themselves as Lance or are they introducing themselves as Dr. Lance Mabry, your physical therapist? And then afterwards, seeing what shakes out. Does that change trust?
20:01 Does that change adherence? Does that change outcomes? That's where I'd love to see that go. That's obviously going to take a lot more manpower and a lot more time and effort. There are also some smaller stuff that can be done as well. I just posted a picture that was done by Devlin et al back in They actually took snapshots of offices and put diplomas in some offices and no diplomas in others. And they asked patients what they thought. And patients thought those that had diplomas on the wall were more qualified, more energetic. And those that had diplomas were also more qualified and energetic, but that was heightened when you added family photos in there. So very, very minor tweaks that we can do to influence all the great stuff we already do.
20:48 We're already great at exercise. We're already great at manual therapy or dry needling or whatever our skillset is. We're already great with that. This is just doing one extra little thing. Put up a picture of your family in your clinic. Put up your diploma on the wall and see how that influences patients. Well done. One more time, not that kind of doctor and exploratory study. I'm a doctor of physical therapy, patient introductions in the United States. Lance, thanks for stopping by to help us understand a little more about research. Thank you much. I appreciate you having me.